Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A new spiral in th Palestinian tragedy

Socialist Organiser no. 461, 1 October 1990 · scan pp. 10–11 · about 1,809 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Wing reality - or being absorbed by it Sean Matgamna malign old bastard, part 2. roof that God is an incorrigibly A few weeks ago, but in a different political world, betore Saddam Hussein invaded Kuwait and before the USA started moving towards war and probably the recolonisation of parts of Arabia, I wrote in this column about the curious feeling I had of living through a period in which history payses to repeat and summarise — as in the concluding chapter of a well-organised book - the terrible history of the Jews of Europe and the Arabs of Palestine.

The looming war in the Gulf intensifies and strengthens one element in the historical recapitulation we seem to be living through. It adds the terrible prospect of a new spiral of tragedy for the Palestinian Arabs in the West Bank and Gaza, who have surely had more than their share of tragedy, but have now lined up behind Saddam Hussein.

In 1948 the Palestinian Arabs in the area allotted to them by the UN's 1947 partition plan rallied to the armies of the surrounding countries — Jordan, Egypt, Syria — which immediately threw themselves, under the command of British officers in some cases, against the Jewish state in an attempt to conquer and destroy it. Nothing is more natural than that the Palestinian Arabs should have done that.

and Parliament There are two ideas, cherished for more than a century in the British labour movement, which I confess, I have never been able to take seriously.

First is the idea that socialism, the most enormous upheaval in human history - the replacement of a society of inequality, oppression and exploitation by one of cooperation, equality and freedom - can be achieved through Labour MPs trooping down division lobbies in the House of Commons!

Not even mildly intelligent Guardian writers take the place seriously! etcher declared that Britain would go f hile the members of our great of Parliaments' were sunnir various holiday resorts!" *there are many circ which Parliament its claim to sor resort"

Yes, times par!* walks Irresolvable conflict of interest with the Jews, the sense of displacement and of stinging injustice, together with religious fervour and the banked-up hatreds of decades of conflict with the Zionist colonists, all combined to hustle the occupants of the fledgling Palestinian Arab state into complicity in the drive to destroy Israel, And as the invading Arab armies were driven back, the Palestinian Arabs paid an awful price. Some fled in terror before the Israeli army, many others were driven out of Arab towns, villages and lands which were now incorporated into the triumphantly consolidated and expanded Israeli state.

At the end of the war of 1948 the Palestinian Arabs still had a state of their own. But not for long.

In 1949 Israel and Jordan got together and carved up what was left of the UN-chartered Palestinian Arab state. The West Bank went to Jordan.

years later, in June 1967, Israel responded to a feeble Egyptian attempt to blockade one of its ports with a blitzkrieg which smashed the armies of Egypt, Jordan and Syria, and put Israel in control of all pre-war Palestine. The Arabs there have lived under Israeli overlordship ever since.

Neither UN resolutions, nor pressure from the old Stalinist bloc, nor war between Israel and the surrounding Arab states in 1973, nor even the Palestinian Arabs' own struggles -for three years now their intifada - have freed the Palestinians from Israel's colonial grip.

When, after 1967, Israel was offering "land for peace" — acceptance of Israel's Alan Johnson patronising smile from the sophisticated socialists of the born again Labour left. No such cliches for them. Transform the state bit by bit they say, do it very cleverly, over a long period, ensuring that no single 'bit' of transformation alarms the ruling class so they are provoked to violence. Softly, softly, Over a century ago, William Morris faced this argument. Here is an authority the pseudo-sophisticates of the LCC and Marxism Today will listen to surely. What did he "Those who think that they can deal with present system in this piecemeal way very underrate the strength of the tremenganisation under which we live, and hoints to each of s their place, and t chance to fit it grinds us down Nothing but a tremendous force this force: it will not suffer membered, nor to lose ly is its essence without ce in resistance; rather h it considers of imroof of the world vitalism isn't ny instituenough one by 1985 Labour Party Conference in pr The UN devastate Korea Autumn 1950. 'Rubble in Korea' David Hall some West Bank state - the Palestine Liberation Organisation would settle for nothing but the destruction of Israel and a vague offer of religious freedom and citizenship rights for the Jews in an Arab "secular democratic state". And Israeli politics drifted sharply to the right partly as a consequence of this.

For 13 years now, right-wing governments, or coalitions depending on the right, have ruled Israel, until today the most right wing government in Israel's history holds sway. Those who want to annex the West Bank and expel the Arabs are a power in the land, and in the government.

The PLO recently decided to recognise Israel and settle for a West Bank/Gaza Palestinian state — but the right wing has been strong enough to frustrate even those in the Israeli Labour Party who were willing to talk about it at a peace conference.

And the pressure on the Arab areas from Israeli settlers continued to build up. The the roof of the world down upon its head". How serious their reaction is depends on how serious is the reforming government and how much struggle from below it has stirred up. Sometimes an investment strike, destabilisation, flight of capital, accelerated inflation, this will suffice. At other times more brutal action is taken to restore the 'normality' of capitalist relations of production. No pariamentary road to scats, ow the other idea I've never been able no parliamentary road to socialism, then socialists should ignore parliament.

Related to this is the notion that because the pressures to move to the right become immense in Parliament — as Gramsci put it *emsade to beatsorbed by ty they en no socialist should risk exposing themselves to Parliament.

But Gramsci rightly judged this response to the problem to be useless, a mere 'running away from reality'. This idea of fighting on the ground of reality but not becoming absorbed by it is found also in Lenin.

Now, in my view, there is a whole debate to be had about Lenin and democracy. But he would surely have given short shrift to the "anti-parliamentarians' of the British left. To their like he spoke thus in 1920. "'It is more difficult for western Europe to start a revolution than it was for us. To attempt to circumvent' this difficulty by 'skipping' the arduous job of utilising reactionary parliaments for revolutionary purposes is absolutely childish. You want to create a new society yet you fear the difficulties involved in forming a good parliamentary group made up of convinced Communists! Is that not childish?... You think my dear antiparliamentarians that you are 'terribly revolutionary' but in reality you are frightenad by the comparatively minor difficulties of struggle against bourgeois influences the working class movement.? opening up of the Stalinist states, combined with a vast renewal of popular anti-semitism in those states, created the conditions for a big new movement of Jews - comparable almost to the movement of Jews from Russia and Poland in response to the waves of pogroms in 1881 and after.

The Palestinian Arabs viewed the vast new Jewish immigration with mortal fear, and not without reason, combined as it was with a government which includes unashamed advocates of expelling the West Bank Arabs.

It is not surprising that the West Bank Arabs should rally to Saddam Hussein, who challenges the status quo and the other Arab states, who is taking on Israel's friend and protector, the US.

As little surprising as was their fathers and mothers rallying to the Arab armies invading Israel 42 years ago. And potentially as tragic.

The PLO, which is backing Saddam Hussein; those Palestinians in Kuwait who reportedly are active supporters of the Iraqi occupation; and the West Bank Arabs, who are looking to Saddam Hussein as their liberator — they will all suffer terrible consequences when Saddam Hussein is defeated, as in an all-out war, the war the US is openly preparing, he must be.

And what will happen to the Palestinians if their champion Saddam Hussein strikes at Israel with poison gas? In the war now being prepared Saddam Hussein will have nothing to lose by striking at Israel, and possibly a great deal to gain. An attack on Israel will establish him as the Arab champion in a holy war, and put tremendous pressure on the Arab allies of the US.

But in the chaos of war, there is a great danger of an Israeli chauvinist attempt to seize the chance to drive out — or kill -large numbers of Palestinians. (Iraqi gas may do a lot of the killing for them).

The peace movement in Israel considers this a real danger, and has prepared contingency plans to try to stop it.

he chances of history repeating itself must be very great.

George Bush has responded to Saddam Hussein's attempt to link Kuwait with the West Bank with his own talk of a general settlement, which will include a settlement of the Palestinian question after Saddam Hussein is defeated. Bush is concerned to keep his Arab allies, and to counter Saddam Hussein's propaganda.

But afterwards? We can't foresee the "settlement" the Americans will go for in the region. But it would be naive to believe that Bush will look after the interests of Saddam Hussein's Palestinian allies and supporters. He has not exactly been kind to America's own long-time stooge King Hussein of Jordan, caught in an impossible position between Iraq and its enemies.

Nor can the Palestinians rely on Bush's Arab allies. Arab governments have been content to let them languish as refugees because then the question of Israel's right to exist could more plausibly be kept in play. Mass slaughter of Palestinians has mainly been the work of other Arabs - the work of America's new ally Syria as well as of King Hussein of Jordan, who organised the great slaughter in the Black September' of 1970.

No: in any of a number of likely scenarios, the prospects facing the Palestinians are grim and terrible.

Scan page 11

Labour fudges while Tories tight: ur fudges while Tories fig anise

----- pull-quotes -----

AGAINST THE TIDE

right to exist by the Arab states in return for ity CHEPOLITICAL FRONT

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 461

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →