Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The eye of the storm

Socialist Organiser no. 461, 1 October 1990 · scan pp. 7–8 · about 1,780 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

Adam Keller reports from Israel on The law says that if a general testifies that the latest clashes in the occupied there is an urgent military need then the territories and Israeli responses to destruction of houses can go ahead immediately. (But they must pay compensation and find the people alternative Y in Jerusalem enf Peace Now with the esterday there was a big meeting They have destroyed 34 houses and shops.

Deportations are still being debated inside the establishment. That issue too, will go to leader Faisal Husseini. He tried to the Supreme Court, which will take time. explain the position of the Palestinians.

He distinguished between the position of the Palestinian leadership and the position of ordinary Palestinians. The Palestinian leadership has never taken a position in Either the Iraqi army entering Jordan or favour of the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait, on destabilisation and overthrow of King the contrary it is for Iraqi withdrawal. It is against the American intervention and it The official policy of the government which has some support amongst the left, is that Iraqi entry into Jordan would be enough But ordinary Palestinians feel that the political process is heading them nowhere.

Talk of international initiatives and The Jordanian King is riding the wave of international law had little effect on these anti-Western Arab nationalism. There are reports in the Israeli press that he is quite people: they feel international law has little to popular in Jordan at the moment - even He said that the Palestinians feel that they among the radical parts of the Jordanian are living in the jungle. The Israeli tiger is free to eat them. They like the Iraqi tiger For Hussein this is a very dangerous game.

The destabilising factors include the bad he Israeli opposition to the Gulf War and deteriorating state of the Jordanian is, I am afraid, quite marginal. economy and the refugees coming through Israeli society in general is one of the most pro-US societies on earth. It is The blockade of Aqaba has led to 10,000 not surprising when Israel gets such a port workers losing their jobs in the last week The Israeli right-wing is hoping that the US The Jordanians are afraid of the refugees. will give Israel a free hand with the They are trying to put them in the desert where they will not have contact with the Palestinians; the Israeli left is hoping that the US will use its power to force Israel to make population. These tens of thousands of peace with the Palestinians. But both sides, another place. He drove in his private Now the extreme right ministers have penniless, desperate people living in awful in many ways, are orientated to the USA. car. Although that is against army demanded the destruction of all houses conditions are adding to the tension in the There are some groups who have organised within a 200 metres radius of where the small demonstrations - including outside The reserve soldier took a wrong turning. reserve soldier was killed and the immediate the American Embassy. There are petitions Instead of going into the military camp he circulating. But we have been unable to Ahrens was not happy with this idea, and mobilise Peace Now, for instance, to support withdrawal of these Americans from the than a soldier. He was in civilian clothes and The people thought he was a settler rather he delayed several days in starting the Are than seen ed ted that.

The Israeli Civil Rights Association then One of the most significant elements of the They threw stones at him. He tried to turn appealed to the Supreme Court. The Ba'ath party have declared their Gulf issue is what it means for the role of round but backed his car into a cart. He precedent is that the person whose house is to support for Syria making a united front with Israel. Israel has been an ally of the US be destroyed is entitled to a written order and Iraq and the PLO against imperialist against the Soviet Union and the spread of He was in the market place, and hundreds then the right of appeal — first to a military Soviet influence in the Middle East. It is not of people were there. They threw stones and commission and then to the Supreme Court. I do not think Assad is giving much weight The problem now for the US in the Middle then set his car on fire. He burned to death. The incident was seized on by the extreme The Supreme Court gave a temporary order to support amongst the Palestinians. Assad sent armed forces to join the US in Saudi East is how to maintain conservative Arab Then on the following day, yesterday (26 Arabia despite knowing it would be a very regimes against radical nationalists. In this They are dissatisfied with the policy of September), the general in charge of the Gaza unpopular move. It was more important for context Israel is an embarrassment for the Strip came to the Supreme Court and said Ahrens has a policy of avoiding big that the destruction of houses was not meant The Syrians had relied on the USSR as confrontations with the Palestinian as a punishment but was needed as an urgent their main ally. Now, clearly, the USSR is an population. He has concentrated the army on unreliable ally. Assad is prepared to sacrifice controlling main roads and the roads which The destruction of the houses was needed goodwill among Arabs for the goodwill of widen a narrow alley which troops were the Gulf crisis.

the prominent Palestinian Arab wants to be a mediator.

offer them: it leaves them out.

which comes to fight the Israeli tiger.

large amount of US aid.

Gulf.

very useful now the Cold War is over.

United States.

ast week an killed in the home on let WRITEBACK Write to SO, PO Box 823, London SE15 analysis of the situa- Jerry Bates in his tion in the Gulf, (SO 460), gets himself into a considerable muddle over Kuwait.

I don't think anyone on the left, (perhaps excluding Newsline!) raised the demand that Saddam Hussein should invade Kuwait. Although when one considers how effectively the Emir held down oil prices for his imperialist Israeli reserve soldier was : Gaza Strip. He went Ive. His unit moved to troops train he had a gun.

injured two boys.

right in Likud.

lead to settlements.

Terry Bates (SO 460)

determination for Kuwait' on the grounds that the people living there could not sustain a viable masters it is hardly a surprise, with hindsight, that he did.

Since he did, matters have changed. Bates notes that if Iraq simply withdrew from Kuwait this "would certainly be claimed as a victory by the US". . Indeed it would. And Bush would reinstate the corrupt and undemocratic Emir, or possibly even worse. Labour's front bench certainly supports this position, but surely socialists don't?

Bates goes on to argue that the people of Kuwait should regulations it is very often done.

drove into a refugee camp.

Defence Minister Moshe Ahrens.

lemocracy, being a nixture of a 'rentier caste' plus long-term and short-term contract workers.

How does this argument square with SO - quite correctly - calling for selfdecide their own future. But he simultaneously points out that Kuwait is not, in any sense a nation. Or it is as much of a nation as the six counties of Ulster. Both were created by British imperialism drawing a line on a map towards or just after the end of the 1st World War.

Bates does hit upon the correct answer when he suggest that Kuwait will need to be included "in some larger democratic unit", Although one might ask, why not deportation of 200 people.

destruction of these houses. to stop the destruction of the houses.

military matter. determination for the Falklands Isles during the South Atlantic War of 1982? -At a time when everyone from George Bush to Gerry Bates is dreaming up schemes for the future of Kuwait, it seems to me to be rather unfair that the only people socialist? The best hope for the toilers of Kuwait lies in the working class of Cairo and Baghdad. Of course Saddam Hussein will not take this cause any further forward. But Bush has the power to give out a very powerful setback. Particularly if we show any sign of equivocation in our complete opposition to his imperialist war drive.

Ernest Jones, using.

houses). to justify war.

Jordan.

and truck drivers too.

country.

There have confrontations Aqaba and the the US.

who cannot have a say in the future of Kuwait are the people who live and work there.

With regard to Stephen Ryaptis' objection of SO's passive acceptance of an Iraqi-unified Arab state (see SO 458), should one ever come about (which it won't) the otherwise garrulous Gerry Bates is strangely silent.

The emergence of a powerful pan-Arabist blurring over of class divi movement would lead to sions rather than to 'clearing the decks' for the class struggle.

Gerry Bates waxes at length about possible scenarios in which he would feel obliged to go and defend Iraq. Surely the problem here is that he is dealing with scenarios, not the tacts of the case so far, i.e. the conflict between an expansionist subHussein could lead to an Israeli entry. public who were always against him.

already between refugees.

new phenomenon emerged today. The e are afraid that a situation will arise that will lead to the Israel army going into Jordan.

It is a very unstable situation.

been reports the population aggression in the Middle East.

him to get the US's good will.

imperialist power and America for control of oil reserves and for regional hegemony.

Although the scene and the level of conflict may, and probably will, change, that is not in itself any evidence of a change in the character of the conflict and the issues at stake in it.

In fact, it is more than "remotely conceivable' that Hussein and the US knock together a deal: he gets a couple of islands, an extra oilfield, and additional financial support; America gets Iraqi withdrawal from Kuwait. Hussein has always done a good job for Western imperialism so far. And where - another question which Gerry Bates fails to address - would America find a replacement for Hussein?

Stephen Ryaptis Liverpool

Scan page 8

Labour Party Socialists debate Socialist Organiser No 461 1 October 1990 Page ABOUR PARTY

----- pull-quotes -----

Kuwait: deal with facts not scenarios A muddle over Kuwait

Greaffirms opposition to the slogan 'self-

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 461

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →