Violence and reaction in South Africa
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-10-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
'Beyond Aparth This summer in the Transvaal over a thousand people have been killed.
The fighting has centred around the political confrontation between Chief Gatcha Buthulezi's Inkatha party, a zulu nationalist organisation, and the African National Congress. It is a dispute of long standing. Over the last five years some four to five thousand people have been killed in Natal in fighting between Inkatha and the ANC-UDF supporters — though the killing developed a dynamic of its own among militant youth and mafiastyle warlords.
The violence is the visible expression of an unfolding tragedy, which could upset the whole 'peace' programme but which is more likely to paint it red — not in the colours of socialism but of blood and authority.
The conventional explanation of the violence looks first to state thugs (seurity officers) stirring, organising and participating in it. While this is certainly true, it is difficult to see what interest the de Klerk government has in this project; it seems far more likely that the thugs came from the far right seeking to discredit the reform programme.
More important though is that the right wing conspiracy theory cannot explain the violence as a whole.
The second line of explanation looks at the brutishness of Buthulezi's Inkatha movement. More specifically, as Inkatha lost support with the re-entry of the ANC into legality and its likely coming to a share of power, it needed to make its political presence felt.
Inkatha was some time ago launched as a national party -previoulsy it was a local Zulu party in Natal - and is organising hard parucularly among migrant workers in the Transvaal.
We also need to look to the role of the ANC, which is reaping the bitter fruit of its own past mistakes and present inabilities to learn from them. The fighting in the Transvaal started in late July, a few weeks after COSATU called a stay-away in the Transvaal the demands of which were the dismantling of the Kwazulu police, the arrest of the warlords in Natal and the marginalisation of Inkatha. It was a provocative move, accompanied by reports of violent opposition to Inkatha organisers appearing in the Transvaal.
From the ANC's point of view, this might not matter if it could successfully isolate and beat down all opposition. But the political battle with Inkatha is increasingly turning into a xhosa vs zulu confrontation that bodes ill for any decisive resolution.
Inkatha is well organised, whereas reports of the ANC inside the country are ones of disarrary, division and confusion.
I was brought up as an American first, but more recently my family have become interested in expressing the Arab part of ourselves. My father has begun to take more of an interest in his religion, Islam, than he did when I was growing up.
Although we did visit Egypt regularly, we were forced to choose to be either Egyptian or American. Joint citizenship is not possible, even when you "belong" to both cultures. In order to live here we had to "choose" to be American.
The new interest we feel in the other part of our culture must have to do with confidence in America — in its ability to accept different cultures and opinions. ArabAmericans now want a distinct voice, a distinct identity - in the same way other ethnic groups have. There are still only a couple of Arab-American journals in the United States.
It should not be necessary to choose, because neither choice would be the full person, the full experience.
I am worried that the war will mean attacks on Arab-American groups and individuals - perhaps not in New York, but here in the Mid-West. Anyone who is not quite white, anyone not a practising Christian, is suspect automatically. The confidence which ArabAmerican groups had begun to feel will not outlast such attacks.
I am loyal to this country. It is my home even if I have a brother in Kuwait and I am taking classes in Arabic. I hate the thought of war and I hated America's actions in Panama.
I will continue to assert my right to have these opinions, and my right to find out about my Egyptian "half" . But I am worried about the consequences now Inkatha has shown itself capable of making effective populist appeals especially to poorer migrant workers, claiming their neglect by the ANC and the inutility of the old ANC policies. Ironically, however, the real policy differences between Inkatha and the ANC are now minimal. The ANC is caught, however, in the results of its own nationalist images and 'ungovernability' strategy of the mid-1980s.
"The worst of that the ANC seem: destined to become more dependent on its new allies in the government"
The worst of it is that that ANC seems destined to become more dependent on its new allies in the government - witness perhaps Mandela's confusion over whether to call for police action in his response to the violence - and that political opposition to the new order is likely to be of the dangerous ethnic populism favoured by Inkatha rather than have anything to do with socialism.
don't know how far the stalinisation of the trade union left has gone, but the re-grouping of a democratic (non-stalinist) socialist left remains crucial.