Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

This war is about oil

Socialist Organiser no. 460, 13 September 1990 · scan p. 12 · about 1,309 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

Troops out of the Gulf!

Get us not be told that the duty of the House of Commons is to unite behind whatever the Government of the day does, because that is not what the House is there to do. We are hère to represent peopie and to contribute our own opinions as best we can.

I have no complaint of any speech made today about how we feel that the crisis should be handled.

I will use plain language. I fear that the United States has already decided that, when it is ready, it will create a pretext for a war. That is what I believe. I acquit the Foreign Secretary of being in that hawkish clan because, so far as one can penetrate the inscrutable corridors of power and the minds of their inhabitants, he seems to be a bit of a dove. But let me say this, too, without offence. Britain is a minor player in this game.

From front page believe the answer is to begin to talk and to negotiate.

I am an old shop steward, and whenever I went into a battle,..I made certain that I left a door ready to be opened. If you close the door behind you, sometimes you cannot get out of the situation.

I believe that we must have a door ready to be opened in the present situation - a door that will give Saddam Hussein some chance of saving some face, so that the problem can be solved by negotiation and not by war. If there is war, who knows where we shall end up? I do not know, and no-one else knows. Perhaps the war would be over quickly, like the Galtieri situation.

[Another MP asked him to give way.J No, I am not giving way, This may well be my last speech in this House. I do not know.

We must talk in order to find a solution without going to war. I agree entirely that there should be no question of going to war unless that is agreed by the whole of the United Nations. We should all agree on thar if we cannot agree on everything else.

The last point I want to make concerns the damn hypocrisy of We have had a debate today as though everything hinged on whether the Prime Minister decided to go to war. The Prime Minister too is a minor player in this unfolding tragedy. She decided to go in with President Bush, perhaps because of the transatlantic relationship, the so-called "special relationship", or as thanks for the Falklands, or because she did not want to get mixed up with the EEC. But she is a minor player and once she and the Cabinet decided to commit even a notional number of forces — including the RAF and the RAF regiment and now the troops - she was locked into what President Bush intended to do.

It is important that we should not discuss, as if we were in a position to decide the post-cold-war order, what the Prime Minister will be doing here and there. We are a minor partner in an American strategy.

It must be known by now that I am opposed to a war against Iraq. I am opposed to action outside the United Nations. I believe that it would divide the Security Council. It might not exactly unite the Arab world, but it might bring many Arab countries together against us. The outcome of such a war could not be sure because President Saddam Hussein would certainly have the capacity, were he to choose to do it, to destroy so many oil installations that even though he himself might be destroyed it would some of those involved. The Secretary of State for Defence says that we stand by the law.

What law did America call uD when it invaded Grenada or Panama? What law did it call up when it undermined the elected president of Chile and helped to get him murdered? What law did it call up when it assisted the Contras in violent means against the Nicaraguan government? What sort of law is that?

That is not law; that is interests. That is imperial interests. What worries me is whether we are going to Saudi Arabia to fight for the rights of the Kuwaitis and the people of Iraq who have been oppressed for so iong.

Where were Conservative members when the likes of me were working hard to assist those people? Selling weapons.

An American senator has said that if Iraq was only growing carrots, America would not be interested. Of course it would not be. It is a question of oil and oil interests. It is capitalist oil interests. It is imperialist oil interests:

That is what worries me. I want peace. I want the peoples to be free and genuinely free. I do not want us to be rushed into a war because of the oil companies. inflict a burden on the world economy and the middle east which could not be contemplated.

I must also say something else to the House without in any way being offensive. Governments of any colour in any country are not the main practitioners of morality. America went into Panama and 3,000 people were killed. America went into Grenada. America supported Iraq when it attacked Iran. America did nothing when Cyprus was invaded and partitioned by Turkey. America has no moral authority any more than any other superThe same would be true of the Soviet Union after Afghanistan, or wherever. It has no moral authority. Nor, might I add, because these things must be said and nobody else has said them, can we defend the Emir or the King of Saudi Arabia, neither of whom practice any democracy.

I am not saying that they are not entitled to the protection of the UN charter — I have already said that they are - but, given the denunciations of the breaches of human rights in eastern Europe by Ministers, one might have expected one of them, in this dispute, to point out that a person found guilty of shoplifting in Riyadh will have his hand chopped off. Are we to live in a world where morality is Turn to 2 calling on the National Executive not to expel supporters of Socialist Organiser.

We need several dozen more to be sure of being able to force the platform into allowing a real debate at the Conference. We have 18 days in which to get them, before the Conference starts on Saturday 29 September.

So far Ealing Southall, Nottingham South, Peckham, Harlow, Honiton and Hyndburn CLPs, and the CRS Political Committee, have passed emergency motions. Many CLPs which have already pledged support against the ban on SO meet towards the end of the month, and should pass emergency motions then. And we are receiving messages from more and more CLPs each day.

Today, for example, we had a letter from Reigate CLP: "Would you please send a copy of Socialist Organiser as no member had seen it? Our members resented the action by the NEC" • The National Executive Committee voted to ban Socialist Organiser on 25 July. SO had had no notice of charges, no notice of evidence, no hearing. It had no official communication until Joyce Gould wrote to it on 1 August announcing the ban. Even then, Joyce Gould gave no clear reasons for the ban, and the very definition of the ban itself was scarcely even grammatical. (The NEC resolution says that SO is "ineligible for affiliation" to the Labour Party. But hundreds of thousands of members of the Labour Party are members of groups "ineligible for affiliation" - CND, Anti-Apartheid, and many others — and no-one wants to

----- pull-quotes -----

speech in Parliament o 6 September

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 460

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →