Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Israeli reactions to the Gulf crisi

Socialist Organiser no. 460, 13 September 1990 · scan pp. 8–9 · about 3,998 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

From page 7 On that day Feisal Husseini and others called for the resolution of all conflicts through peaceful means and for an Iraqi withdrawal from Kuwait, and condemned all acquisitions of land by conquest. A Peace Now spokesperson, Amiram Gelblum, attacked Sarid directly, stating: "We do not want Arafat as a personal friend — we want him as a partner for peace. The only relevant question is whether he still wants peace...If Saddam Hussein himself should offer to open peace talks with Israel, there is room for that, too." (Ha'aretz, 28 August 1990)

According to some political observers, Sarid's new posture was motivated by a desire to return to the Labor Party, which he left in 1984 and where a struggle for the leadership has begun. However, Ya'el Dayan — a Labor Party member - was among his sharpest critics; Labor Doves Uzi Bar'am, Avraham Burg and Aryeh Eliav all reiterated their continuing conviction that there must be negotiations with the PLO (Al-Hamishmar, 17 August 1990); and even Labor leader Shimon Peres stated in a radio interview: "So there were demonstrations in support of Saddam! Ten years ago, there were demonstrations in favour of Humeini. Now Humeini is dead and we are still here. When the dust settles, we still have to make peace with these people."

On August 24 Sarid's critics were joined by writer AB Yehoshua, Sarid's personal friend and his ally in many previous controversies: "l telephoned Sarid and I think this was an emotional slip of the pen. I think he now regrets having written "They can come and search for me!'. I can understand his emotional reaction, like I can understand the Palestinians who suddenly support Saddam Hussein, or like I understand the mobs who attacked Arabs in Jerusalem."

On August 26 the Ratz secretariat reaffirmed its commitment to negotiations with the PLO. Sarid remained isolated, with most members supporting the position of KM Shulamit Aloni:

Yitzhak Shamir 'I think this [Sarid's statement] is an expression of distress. This distress has many causes, but a person must not let such feelings overwhelm him. A feeling of distress is not a justification for forgetting all rational thought, all long-term considerations. There are several things I have to say in this matter: first, I can make no accusations against the Palestinians; second, I cannot renounce the principle that every people has the right to self-determination; and third, I am willing to continue meeting them, always, every time. I am sure that, in the end, my colleagues will also agree that Israel's security needs require the continuation of that dialogue." (From an interview to Ha'aretz, 24 August 1990) | •Two days later, a public Israeli-Palestinian meeting took place -the first, as all the papers noted, since Sarid's attack. Some 150 inhabitants of the Arab town of Taibeh, in Israel's "Triangle" area, witnessed a public discussion between KM Dedi Zucker of Ratz, Israeli Communist Party Secretary General Tufiq Tubi, and Radwan Abu-Ayash, one of the prominent members of the East Jerusalem Palestinian leadership.

On the same day, Communist KM Tamar Gozanski and Dr Ruhama Marton of the Israeli-Palestinian Physicians' Association met with Nabil Sha'ath, a senior Arafat advisor, in the context of the European NGO's Symposium on the Palestinian Question: Naturally, both meetings were mainly centred on the Gulf crisis and the two sides' relation to it. At the time of writing, Likud and Tehiya KMs have called for Tamar Gozanski to be prosecuted; on the other hand, Labor Knesset Members, led by KM Shevah Weiss, have declared their intention to oppose and obstruct the proceedings against PLP KM Miari.

'In the first weeks of the Gulf crisis, the Zionist Left — together with the mainstream - gave uncritical support to the American military build-up in the Gulf, and to President Bush's declared policies. In the Hebrew press, there were but few and scattered dissenting voices; they deserve to be enumerated:

• The Communist Party, which supported sanctions on Iraq but opposed American military involvement;

• Yemini Ben-Dror, editor of the radical Oriental Jewish monthly Hapatish, who wrote in Yediot Aharonot (15 August): "What Saddam did to the Kurds is much more serious than what he is doing to the Kuwaitis, but then the world was silent";

• Uri Avnery, who, in an article in Ha'aretz (21 August), called for democratic elections in Kuwait, and condemned Mapam and Ratz for supporting American demands to restore the corrupt old Kuwaiti regime;

• The Israeli Council for Israeli-Palestinian Peace, which published an advertisement stating: " ...The Kuwaiti Crisis should be solved peacefully, without a flare-up which could set the whole Middle East on fire" (Ha'aretz, 17 August);

• Yossi Dahan, who exposed the lies and hypocrisies on both sides of the Gulf battle-lines: 'In war the first casualty is always the truth" (Hadashot, 19 August).

As long as the outbreak of war seemed imminent, most Israelis prepared to sit back and watch the Americans destroy Iraq's military and nuclear capacity. ""The Americans clean up the mess, and our hands stay clean!" These were the words of Police Minister Roni Milo, and they hit the point for a very broad section of society.

However, in the last week of August this dream seemed to recede, and Iraqi withdrawal through diplomatic mediation became a realistic possibility. Such an outcome would, among other things, create a precedent of an occupied territory evacuated under international pressure.

In Ha'aretz Yoel Markus started to beat the war drum: "George Bush, President and Commander in Chief, must give immediately the green light for the destruction of Saddam Hussein" (August 28).

Dan Margalit, who counts himself among the doves, wrote in his column: "There must be no mediation and no negotiations... Iragi withdrawal from Kuwait, under the doubtful auspices of the UN, will make the situation much worse...President Bush must give Saddam only two choices: to withdraw from Kuwait and resign from power...or face trial for war crimes." (Ha'aretz, 27 August)

Former General Avigdor Ben-Gal waded in, calling upon the US to use "tactical, non-polluting nuclear arms"

"In B'ney north of Tel shantytown was destroyed with brutality. The homeless becoming increasingly bitter and alienated..."

On August 29; columnist Gideon Samet wrote a fiery rebuttal: 'Starting a war seems a simple matter for newspaper columnists and former generals. Thank God, it is more difficult for the one who has to push the button... War is a very unpredictable thing. It never develops as it was presented at the General Staff's computer games..I beg forgiveness of all these heroes. I hereby inscribe myself among the decadent cowards, who regard war as a bad idea — even a war against today's Bad Guy Number One."

This struggle on the pages of Ha'aretz probably reflected governmental machinations, which came to light only in the form of Shamir's denial on August 28: 'The accusations that we are pushing the US into war are nothing but ridiculous Israeli schoolchildren with gas masks lies."

Among Saddam Hussein's first Israeli victims were the new homeless, those who lost their houses after the boom in rents due to the influx of Soviet immigrants - and therefore created shantytowns and "tent cities" all over the country. The invasion of Kuwait moved the media spotlight away from the homeless encampments.

Knesset Members and Ministers ceased to come and promise quick solutions: instead, the police started raiding the tent cities and arresting the organisers. In B'ney B'rak, north of Tel Aviv, a shantytown was destroyed with much brutality. The homeless are becoming increasingly bitter and alienated; some went as far as applying to UNWRA to ask for refugee status.

The movement is far from broken, as was shown in its rally on Tel Aviv's Municipality Square on August 18, in which thousands of supporters came to show solidarity. The many leftists present had an experience ditterent trom their long history of rallies in the same place: the music between the speeches of the tent city representatives was oriental...

Another news item relegated to the back pages was the recent rise of Israeli unemployment figures above the 10% mark. It is far from certain that the government will suceed in containing such explosive social problems after the dust from the Gulf settles down.

1. During his first term at the Defence Ministry (1984-'84), Arens was the godfather of the IAl's Lavi Aircraft Project, and resigned from the government in protest at the Lavi Project's termination. On reassuming the Defence portfolio in 1990, Arens tried to get Washington to finance the Lavi's revival. Upon failing, he now concentrates upon the IAl's 'Arrow' , an antimissiles-missile which constitutes part of the American Strategic Defence Initiative, better known as "Star Wars"

2. In fact, Israeli governments since the 1950s were opposed to the entry of Iraqi or Syrian forces into Jordanian territory. However, this policy was never, until now, proclaimed in public. Moreover, between 1967 and 1970, considerable Iraqi forces were present in Jordan, and Israel did not start a war to evict them.

3. ''We pray to the Lord to make our land bigger, so that a great many more Jews can come and live wherever our feet touch the ground. The whole of the Jordan River will be inside our EretzYisra'el. It will be a holiday resort where we could swim from one side to the other, and both sides will be inside our country". This statement was published in Oz, the (governmentfunded) weekly magazine of the Gaza Strip settlers, and reprinted in Yediot Aharonot on August 24.

Scan page 9

This cartoon from a US paper parodies a famous photo of US troops raising the American flag on a reconquered island in Gerry Bates replies to last week's letters on the Gulf Tony Dorman and Stephen Ryaptis ask related questions about a socialist attitude to the Gulf crisis should it develop into an all-out war. Both say that the approach we adopt at the moment, opposition to both the imperialists and to Iraq, should be maintained.

Says Dorman: "It is not the business of socialists to help the younger robber to rob the older" • And Ryaptis: "Surely it is in the nature of a younger imperialist power...to come into conflict with an ageing imperialist power."

Ryaptis also criticises SO for advocating "the unity of the Arab people" on the grounds that such unity would oppress national minorities.

The conflict began through a sub-imperialist gambit by Iraq, designed to assert its regional authority and seize control of Kuwait's rich oilfields. Iraq is certainly the "younger robber". But that is not the end of the story.

It is now difficult to imagine an end to the conflict that does not involve a concerted imperialist attempt, with or without UN approval, not only to get Saddam Hussein out of Kuwait, but_to remove him in Iraq. Already US military forces have established themselves as the effective dominant power in Saudi Arabia; state power in Iraq - that is, neo or semi-colonial power in a real sense, not the nebulous sense in which those words are widely used -could be the outcome of the endgame now being played.

Other scenarios are possible: it is even remotely conceivable that the US could do a deal with Saddam in which they agreed to fund him as the Gulf's policeman, although that looks very, very implausible at the moment.

But if the more likely scenario is right, we are, or will be, no longer talking about big robbers and small ones. We would be talking about a huge, imperialist, military presence in the region, sparking mass revolts across it, firing the justified hostility of millions of people. Saddam's sub-imperialist gambit would no longer be the main issue. If the war escalated to an attempt by the United States effectively to conquer Iraq, we would need to raise the argument for the defence of Iraq's national rights.

It is right to make historical comparisons, but important not to get bogged down in them. If Iraq were an imperialist power straighttorwardly comparable to the US or Britain, competing for control of Middle East oil, even its overrunning by foreign armies would not make us "defencists". . We were not defencists for France even when Nazi Germany conquered most of it.

This was not because we were unconcerned for the national rights of the French, but because the French bourgeoisie — de Gaulle - were not fighting for those national rights: they were fighting for the French empire.

Saddam Hussein's wild ambitions - who knows, perhaps he would like to be the new Hitler? -are not seriously comparable to the material reality of French colonialism. In reality, Iraq is a small, sparsely populated country which, if the world's imperialisms combined to smash it to bits, would be fighting not for the oil fields of Kuwait, and still less Saudi Arabia, but for its life as an independent nation.

At the moment, it has not escalated to such a level. Maybe it won't. Even if it did, socialists would remain implacably hostile to Saddam Hussein's regime. But we would not be impartial on the question of Iraqi national rights, and would not reduce the war as it had developed to the ambitions of the regime in its opening rounds.

Socialist Organiser has distinguished itself from the rest of the left by taking a concrete approach to recent wars. •When Britain went to war with Argentina in 1982, most of the Left saw everything in terms of abstract schemes. The terrestrial actions of mere mortals played no part in much of the Left's analysis. Galtieri's invasion of the Falklands /Malvinas was, they thought, a first — messy and reprehensible - step in an ineluctable process of anti-imperialist revolution which would eventually result in socialism.

We argued that it was a conflict in reality confined to the islands. There was no struggle on the Argentinian side we could support — no issue of national liberation. We opposed both sides.

When the US sent ships to the Gulf in 1987 to back Iraq against Iran, we argued that Iranian national rights were not being threatened. The American aim was 'containment' , not conquest. And this is not a matter of speculation. We were proved 100% right. Khomeini's regime, if not the old bastard himself, is still intact and the US is satisfied if not overjoyed.

In both cases we said that if the conflict escalated beyond the immediate issues, and national rights were at stake, we would be for the defence of Argentina or Iran. We said such an escalation was very unlikely.

But such an escalation now is very likely. It is almost unimaginable that the issue will remain confined to the Iraqi occupation of Kuwait. We are talking a much bigger ball game.

It is true that socialists don't change sides in war just because one side is weaker. If it really remained an issue of imperialism versus subimperialism, there would be no case for taking sides. But only by the most arid series of logical deductions can it be believed that it will remain that. If war starts, it will be bigger than Saddam Hussein. A massive wave of nationalism is already gripping the region.

Dorman says that we should not "help the younger robber to rob the older robbers"; Ryaptis, that even imperialist nations can suffer foreign occupation and oppression, and that 'whatever the level of conflict, or whatever the location of the fighting, the nature of the conflict would remain unchanged...

They argue far too abstractly. At that level of abstraction, why support Vietnam against the US? Vietnamese victory led to Vietnamese domination over Laos and Cambodia. Why support Algeria's war of independence against France? Independent Algeria has oppressed the Berbers. Why support Egypt against Britain, France and Israel in the Suez crisis? Nasser's victorious government went on to establish a sort of sub-imperialist domination over Syria and North Yemen.

Every capitalist (or Stalinist) ruling class, however weak, has imperialist impulses. Every war between capitalist (or Stalinistbureaucratic) forces has elements of an inter-imperialist conflict. Follow the logic of Dorman and Ryaptis, and we would never support any nationalist struggle. We would have to regard the principle of national self-determination as futile and play with words, without any possible grip on reality in a capitalist (and Stalinist) world:

In fact we must analyse concrete:

In fact we must distinguish between conflicts where national self-determination is the main issue, and ones where inter-imperialist rivalry is the main issue.

War is the continuation of policy by other means. Iraq is continuing a policy of trying to establish itself as à big power in its small region. The US and Britain are continuing a nearly 200 year old policy of trying to keep that region under. their direct control or the control of forces they consider safe.

In the event of a full-scale assault on Iraq by the US and its allies, aimed at disabling Iraq from ever again upsetting regional stability, Kuwait would become a secondary issue and the main issue would be Iraqi self-determination.

The approach of Dorman and Ryaptis is the flipside of the approach of (for example) Socialist Worker. SW dissolves all concrete issues into the issue of the inequality of power between America ('the main enemy") and Iraq ("objectively anti-imperialist"); Dorman and Ryaptis dissolve concrete issues into the inter-imperialist aspect of the conflict.

Ryaptis also raises the question of the character of Arab nationalism. I am extremely sceptical about Arab nationalism. It is a nationalist tradition surely near the end of its tether, after decades of failure. Nationalism has failed to secure any of its objectives; not Arab unity, not economic prosperity, and not a solution to the Palestinian question.

Part of Saddam's current appeal, certainly among Palestinians, is that he is reasserting an old, militant nationalism against the failure of the 'moderates' to get anything through negotiations. He is, incidentally, in one respect therefore Israel's creature, the Frankenstein's monster of their intransigence.

Nothing would please me more than to see the final demise of Arab nationalism and its mythologies, to be replaced by a socialist internationalism.

But is it a socialist attitude to the masses simply to decry their "false consciousness'?

Sometimes, if the consciousness is just false, it is. It is false for white workers to believe black workers are their enemies. It was false for British workers to believe it was in their interests to bash the Argies in 1982. It was false for Argentinian workers to believe that the Falkland /Malvinas islands were worth a single drop of their blood.

But if the Arab masses mobilise against a colossal imperialist military presence in their region? We want a massive mobilisation against the imperialist military presence. Not led by Saddam Hussein; against him, better without him. But we surely don't believe that the mobilisation is simply reactionary, simply part of Saddam's war effort.

In my view, only socialist revolution will achieve Arab unity. But it is ridiculous to say that Arab unity as such is bad for national minorities. Obviously, we're for an Arab unity that allows the Kurds, Israelis, etc., the right to self-determination, Presumably we were for the unity of pre-Maoist China; but we should not have been for the conquest of Tibet.

The big danger in the nationalist wave obviously gathering strength in the Arab world is that it will be absorbed more and more by Islamic fundamentalists. Saddam Hussein's sub-imperialist adventure may turn out to be the last gasp of pseudosecular nationalism. Especially in Saudi Arabia, where the American presence must be provoking immense hostility, fundamentalism must be a real danger.

Surely we assist the fundamentalists if we declare the whole unfolding conflict to be nothing more significant than the previous US World War 2 military build up, in 1987, in Saddam Hussein's support. It is much more significant than that. The Middle East is about to be completely reshaped.

For the moment, it has not escalated. But I can't believe though I'd like to - that it won't. And as it escalates, the issue of Iraqi (and for that matter Arabian, Jordanian, who knows?) national rights will become more and more relevant. That won't mean that Kurdish national rights don't matter, or that we show Saddam Hussein an olive branch. But it must mean we are for Iraq's defence.

Ryaptis also raises the question of "self-determination for Kuwait". , saying that we should b for it; Tim Wilding however, argues that we should drop the slogan "Iraq out of Kuwait"

Wilding jumps too far ahead. A big US assault on Iraq is possible, even probable. But it has not han ened vet. and it is not certain. If and when that assault comes, Kuwait will become a secondary issue. But it is not now. Iraqi withdrawal from Kuwait would, at the very least, strip many of the US's allies away from it, and make it very difficult for the US to invade Iraq:

Is Saddam Hussein and A the occupation of Kuwait grips the headlines everyone forgets the other occupation - now 23 years old - of the Palestinian West Bank and Gaza Strip by Every Saturday for over two years Women in Black has held a vigil outside the offices of El Al, Regent Street, London W1 to call for the end of the Occupation, an end to the killings, the brutalities, the deportations. Women in Black desperately needs more women, more voices, more of a presence.

It is a non-sectarian group of women who agree on a minimum programme: the end of the Occupation, the recognition of the PLO, the right to self-determination and independence for the Palestinians and à boycott of Israeli goods.

Women in Black dress in black to remember those who have died at the hands of the Israeli forces and to show solidarity with Israeli and Palestinian women who hold similar protests in thirty-one places across Israel. Women in Black is now an international movement of PREMIUM It's unlikely that resistance in . Kuwait or in Iraq can force Saddam to withdraw from Kuwait. But why should that stop us expressing our opposition to Iraq's military occupation?

Iraqi withdrawal from Kuwait "without a shot being fired" would certainly be claimed as a victory by the US. But we do not just write a minus where Bush writes a plus. We side with Iraq's national rights against Bush. We do not side with Saddam's sub-imperialism against Bush.

So we are for Iraq getting out of Kuwait, which means that we are for the people in Kuwait deciding their own future. You could call that "self-determination" but it is not the general principle of self-determination of nations.

The Kuwaitis are not a nation, they are a rentier caste. The people living in Kuwait are not a coherent community which could sustain a viable democracy, socialist or bourgeois; they are a rentier caste, plus a certain number of long-term resident migrant workers, plus a very large floating population of short-term contract workers. Any long-term democratic solution must mean the inclusion of Kuwait in some larger democratic unit.

solidarity stretching from Australia, across the USA and Europe.

Our vigil lasts from four till five each Saturday afternoon, outside El Al offices. If you cannot spare one hour each week, just come when you can. For further details ring 071-249 9718.

Jenny Bourne for Women in Black Be are writing a history Wine righties, from the the eighties, from the perspective of rank and file members.

We would be interested in hearing from Party activists from all regions of the country about their experiences in the Party in recent years. In particular, we would be interested in any details about the effects on the Party's grass-roots of the policies and practices pursued by the Party's national leadership.

Confidentiality will be strictly respected ánd all correspondence will be answered.

Please write to us at 79 Inderwick Road, London N8 9LA.

Richard Heffernan Mike Marqusee

----- pull-quotes -----

Request for information

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 460

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →