[to serve the oc serve the There are…]
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-09-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
to serve the oc serve the There are supposed to be gas masks available for everybody, but whether Palestinians who are citizens of Israel have been included among "everybody" is in question; Palestinians from the Occupied Territories are definitely not, though tens of thousands of them work daily in Israeli cities which may become the target of a gas attack. Could it be that in fact the Palestinians are Israel's «human shield"?
Yizhar Ba'er seems to think so: «The non-distribution of gas masks to inhabitants of the territories can be interpreted, on the strategic level, as placing this population in a hostage-status, another means of deterrence against an unconvential attack by an Arab state." (Ha'aretz, 12 August 1990)
Columnist B Micheal of that same Ha'aretz suspects the government of 'self destructive racialism". In order not to let the whole world know that there are no masks for Palestinians, they just wait with the distribution until it is too late...
Over the past six years, Israeli peaceniks again and again railed at Yitzchak Shamir's stubborn clinging to the status quo and his unwillingness to take any initiative. Ironically, at a time when Israel Samos on and a dance very prove a virtue. remember the refrain which Menachem Begin and his followers used to sing in the old days: 'The Jordan River has two banks, one is ours, and the other as well." Already, settlers in the Gaza Strip raised the call for a "Greater Israel" including Jordan; the Techiya Party's leader, Ge'ulah Cohen — a Deputy Minister of the Shamir government - already stated in the Knesset: "If the Iraqis enter Jordan and our army goes after them, the territory should never be given back to King Hussein!"
The Likud never gave up totally the ideological claim for Jordan, elaborated by the original founder Ze'ev Jabotinsky in the 1920s and '30s. Ironically, this claim bears much resemblance to the Iraqi demands upon Kuwait which derive from the same period. In 1922, the British drew both the border separating Iraq from Kuwait and the one dividing Mandatory Palestine from the Emirate of Trans-Jordan (later the Kingdom of Jordan). The Iraqi nationalists have, then and later, claimed that Kuwait is an artificial creation of colonialism, which should be reunited with the 'Iraqi motherland". Using much the same phrageology, Jabotinsky - and later Menachem Begin - railed against "the amputation of Eastern Eretz Yisra'el (Jordan)."
Since the 1970s, the Jordanian claim was pushed very much to the background in the Likud propaganda, but never dropped entirely. Up to the present day the Likud statutes contain a paragraph stating that, under a Likud government, "the Israeli Defence Forces will strive, at the right moment, to liberate Eastern Eretz-Yisra'el."
When the fat is in the Jordanian fire, the danger of mass deportation of West Bank Palestinians would inevitably come closer. The idea of "transfer" is quite widespread, far beyond Rehav'am Ze'evy's 'Moledet' Party which openly advocates it. Yuval Ne'eman of the rival right-wing party Tehiya disagrees with Ze'evi only because "such things should not be talked about, they should just be done when the time comes" . Ne'eman is the new government's Energy Minister, and his attitude is known to be shared by several of its Likud members..
During the present crisis, an unnamed aide of Prime Minister Shamir was quoted in Ha'aretz as saying: "If we have war with Iraq and the Arabs make trouble behind our lines, they will soon find themselves outside". Indeed, the proponents of "transfer" have always known that their design requires war to be implemented - a major war which would create a feeling of national unity and absorb all the media attention. From their point of view, the United States becoming involved in a Gulf war is even more of a windfall, since it would distract public attention not only inside, but also outside, Israel.
The peace movement is preparing itself. Yesh G'vul activists, who as reserve soldiers refused to serve in Lebanon, or to serve the occupation, are nowadays liscussing ways in which mass deportations could effectively be opposed. And the wisdom of the 'Arens-Sarid National Consensus" is more and more openly doubted.
On August 26, the editorial of Mapam's newspaper AlHamishmar stated: 'In certain circles, a concern is felt about the
Scan page 7
bssil lteri traw ie in • go me, liver nter wall p to lat I jont.
blity of large Iraqi forces ng Jordan...The talk about ring a line in the sand' is firing nagination of those who want back to '67 and conquer, this the East Bank of the Jordan ...If only minor Iraqi forces : Jordan, Israel should low' the provocation and not • war. It is, after all, unlikely raq will risk opening a second La wide of Israel.
Over the past two years an extenive network of political and perpnal contacts have been built betreen a wide range of Israelis and ne PLO. Since the PLO's recogniion of Israel, in December 1988, he whole Zionist left became inolved in meetings with PLO presentatives and Palestinian leaders of the Occupied Territories. In these meetings, agreement was soon reached on most components of the proposed solution, and discussion mainly turned on how to get the general Israeli public - and the government — to agree as well.
Three days after the invasion of Kuwait, a major Israeli-Palestinian meeting took place at the Notre Dame Hostel, on the border between East and West Jerusalem. On the Israeli side were 15 Knesset members, including all ten KMs of Mapam, Ratz and Shinuy, as well as five Laborites; the 12 Palestinians were among the foremost leaders in the Occupied Territories.
The issue of the Kuwait events featured prominently in the discussion with the Israelis strongly condemning Iraq and the Palestinians holding to a more general "condemnation of any military occupation anywhere" . Although the participants did not succeed in formulating a definitive statement, signed by all, they did produce "guidelines" to be elaborated in further meetings.
In these guidelines, the recognition of the Palestinian right to self-determination is accepted as being based on the UN Charter and the 1960 General Assembly Resolution condemning colonialism. At the conclusion, KM Yossi Sarid told the press that the conference was 'an outstanding success" , and that "if it was up to the participants in this conference, peace would soon be achieved" (Ha'aretz, 6 August 1990). Peace Now, in close cooperation with the Palestinian leaders, was busy organising a mass peace petition - to be widely circulated among the Israeli and Palestinian day bodies Israeli two Jewish boys, stabbed to death, were found in Jerusalem. As usual in such cases, the murderers were -ahead of any proof - generally assumed to be Palestinians. While racist mobs ran amok through the streets of Jerusalem, the participants of the Notre-Dame Conference found themselves on the defensive. Furiously rebutting the accusation of "having encouraged the murderers" , several of the leftwing MKs did feel compelled to denounce the Palestinian leadership for "not condemning strongly enough the murders"
Meanwhile, the anti-Arab mobs did not need encouragement to continue stoning and burning Arab cars and beating up their passengers -with the police present and doing nothing. Dozens of Palestinians who happened to fall into their hands (as well as two Pakistani tourists) had to be hospitalised; one Palestinian died of his wounds.
Some individuals tried to stem the tide: an army officer — on leave from service in the Gaza Strip -tried to prevent an Arab from being assaulted, and was assaulted himself. Avi Alzam, head of the Shmu'el Hanavi Neighbourhood Council, was stabbed after calling upon his neighbours to stop attacking Arabs.
The peace movement as a whole was in shock. The Jerusalem peace groups started to organise a kind of fire-brigade for future events of this kina, but these preparauons were not in time to help the Palestinians attacked on this present occasion.
It was during these same days of horror and outrage that, throughout the Occupied Territories, demonstrations broke out in support of Saddam Hussein; Iraqi flags were carried with the troops attack Palestinians Palestinian ones, and in some places the slogan "Saddam, be quick with your gas!" was heard. The groundswell in favour of Saddam reached also many of the Palestinians holding Israeli citizenship. A Nazareth inhabitant told the Jerusalem Post (10. August 1990):
"'There is a sense of wanting revenge for this [the Jerusalem pogroms] and all of their suffering and grievances. They believe that Saddam Hussein will supply the means of their retaliation.
These feelings also found expression on the organised political level. KM Abd-el-Wahab Darawsha, heading the Arab Democratic Party, went as far as taking radical Pan-Arab positions: "The unity between Iraq and Kuwait is a positive step on the road to a comprehensive Arab unity...There are 21 Arab states; that number should be reduced to five or SIX, eliminating wasteful regimes. Should Yemen conquer Oman, or Egypt conquer Libya, we will support it." (Yediot Aharonot, 17 August 1990)
By taking this position, former Israeli Labor Party KM Darawsha went far beyond the positions of the PLO, which never included support for the annexation of Kuwait. Many journalists, however, presented Darawsha's positions as those of the whole Palestinian people.
Columnist Yaron London, hitherto a supporter of dialogue with the PLO, came out with the conclusion that the Palestinians do not really want to have a state for themselves, but merely want to be swallowed up in a giant Pan-Arab state; therefore, no question of self-determination is involved.
At the level of party politics, the first denunciation of the Palestinian leadership came from Mapam chairperson El'azar Granot, who accused the PLO of 'having joined the terror alliance of the rulers of Iraq and Libya", he stated that Mapam will think twice about participating in meetings and conventions with Palestinians unless the PLO changes its position (Jerusalem Post, 12 August 1990). However, he left a possible line of retreat open, telling in a radio interview: "I still have my contacts inside the PLO, quite high in the hierarchy. They tell me that the PLO is having second thoughts."
KM Yossi Sarid went further; on August 17 he published an article in Ha'aretz entitled 'Let them try to find me' . He announced in it the total breaking off of his contacts with Arafat, Husseini and Darawsha" — ie. with all Palestinians, whether exiled, Occupied Territories inhabitants, or Israeli citizens. Yossi Sarid. — always considered one of Israel's foremost "media acrobats" — dominated the news for about a week, but his achievement soon started to work against him.
The right wing was quick to seize upon "the confessions of the leftwing penitents" (as KM Geula Cohen put it). The 'Moledet' Party leaflet congratulating "the leftists who have at last woken up? • Deputy Foreign Minister Binyamin Netanyahu ordered Sarid's article translated into English and distrubted by Israeli embassies.
This atmosphere may have encouraged Attorney-General Charish in his decision to request the removal of parliamentary immunity from Progressive List for Peace KM Muhammed Miari, in order to have him prosecuted for meeting PLO members at Athens in February 1988.
not need encourage Arab cars and the police present doing nothing"
However, the atmosphere quickly began to change, with the great majority of the peace camp rallying in defence of continued dialogue with the PLO. Hadashot columnist Yehuda Litani called Sarid's emotional action 'a reaction benefitting a chila, but not a political leader" (21 August 1990). He was followed by numerous others who came out against Sarid on their pages. Peace Now published 'An Open Letter to the Palestinian leadership in the Occupied Territories' which, while expressing "disappointment over the enthusiastic Palestinian support for Saddam Hussein", also praised the Palestinian leaders for their August 15 statement:
----- pull-quotes -----
cupation, are nowadays discussing in which mass deportations could effective ly be opposed'
"Over the past iwo years extensive net- vork of politic and personal contacts has been built bet-
range o PLO" and the
"Meanwhile the anti-Arab mobs did
ment to continue stoning and burning
beating up their passengers - with