Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A third way i

Socialist Organiser no. 460, 13 September 1990 · scan p. 5 · about 1,549 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

racism and 1 Britain's first Race RelaB tions (as opposed to Immigration) Act became law 25 years ago.

In 1976 another Act established the Commission for Racial Equality. The first Act outlawed the most blatant "no coloureds" signs on advertisements for jobs and housing, and the second made provision for tribunals to sit on employment discrimination cases.

Yet racism in housing and employment seems as rampant as ever. It has just gone underground.

Nothing fundamental has changed. Two weeks ago the BBC Most of the opposition the USSR now sees private-protit capitalism as the only alternative to Stalinism, and even in the emerging independent trade union movement the "radicals" are usually radical free-marketeers. But there are individuals and groups seeking an alternative both to capitalism and to Stalinism. Vadim Orlov, from the International Discussion Club in Moscow, spoke to Lowles That do you mean mean •third way"?

I mean it is not capitalism and and how other peopie live. There is now some democracy in our country, so we must say thanks a lot to Gorbachev. But I'm sure he is from that time, that he has that conciousness. He was created as a political figure by the old Communist Party, as a party leader in that field of time. His mind has all those negative aspects.

There are a lot of examples where he doesn't act consistently, the national question, the problems of the party paper. He is influenced by the Conservatives. It may be difficult for him to do what he wants, that may be so but we must speak of the reality.

What is your view on the national problems of the Republics, especially those of the Baltic states? : If you look at our history Russia has had an empire for. a considerable time, dating back to the times of Ivan III and IV. We continue being an Empire but as you know all the great Empires have collapsed in the 20th century. As many scientists have said the 20th century has been the century of nationalism. In many cases they are not wholly independent, but dependent on the West, economically and politically but they are independent states, they are on the map in their own right.

As I see it, it is no bad thing that the Baltic States want their independence. - It is natural and I think it is the objective way of developing. Lenin said, and I agree with him on this, that there are two ways of developing under capitalism. Firstly, when capitalism is not so developed, nations want to be independent and there is a process of disintegration. Then when capitalism reaches a higher level it goes through a period of integration, I think we are seeing this in Europe now. While we do not have capitalism in our country, I think we are going through the same process, now we see disintegration and maybe like many politicians think we may integrate on a new basís. I agree with them.

Gorbachev doesn't go about this in the right way, especially in the Baltic states and increasingly we see confrontation. Maybe he understands that this break up must happen but he is facing strong opposition from the conservatives, the army most of all. Maybe we don't understand his action, his manoeuvring between these groups, but I'm sure that this policy may lead to a political explosion. Do you think there is any possibility of the army and conservatives removing him from power?

Yes I think that is a possibility. Many of us thought that of the 28th Congress of the CP; Gorbachev would not be elected to the position of General Secretary. Yet by the end of the Congress he was stronger and many more liberal positions had been passed.

If the army overthrow Gorbachev would there be a crackdown in the Republics and a confrontation with the people, even civil war?

Yes I'm sure that is the case, there would be civil war, and that is the common view among my friends. The living standards are falling, the people are angry. Compared with the West's standards we don't have any standard of life. The conditions are very bad, and the situation is declining, and so Gorbachev must do something economically and politically by giving independence to the Republics. That may bring him into confrontation with the army and conservatives. At the moment he is between two chairs, two opposing political ideas. It Is interesting because often the man who balances between two chairs wins, but it is a very dangerous position, he can easily fall between the two chairs and they can close over him.

%. illing Do you think there is anything to learn from the introduction of the market in Poland, do you think similar things might happen in the Yes I think similar things might happen, but I don't know if that's the way we are going. Our government hasn't decided what it wants: one time they do one thing another time they do another. But all the time the people get angry, and these words 'market economy' have an influence over everyone. There is a wave of protest among common people, we have had 5 years of perestroika and one year of the new government and yet nothing has changed. The people want to know what it all means and what the government is planning to do about it.

As for Poland, you see we found it very difficult when we arrived to understand how it can be that there are all these goods and food. I see that in the West there is more but for us this was enough. Yes the prices are high but at least there is food. For example there are bananas; they may be very expensive, but on every street . corner, every shop there are bananas. Maybe you think my example is primitive but tor us it is serious; even if we can only buy one banana, it is one more than we can buy in Moscow. I think it is better to have food and have not a lot of money to buy all you want than to have some money but have nothing to buy as is the case in our country.

In the west we hear a lot about the rise of anti-semitism and fascism in your country, is this the case?

Yes. It is a problem in France too. Le Pen is saying that all the problems of France, unemployment etc, is the cause of the Arabs. Such ideas are of course very dangerous, and they could have a big social base in a situation, where the economic level is falling.

As for the anti-semitism, fascism, Russian fascism and especially the organisation 'Pamyat'. Well you see I don't talk to these people, I don't talk with them but according to our press it is a very strong organisation, with large structures, and influence. Well I disagree. To my knowledge, our press - I don't know why - try to enlarge the problem. At the moment Pamyat is not very dangerous. But as I have said in this situation of declining economic standards it is dangerous, maybe very dangerous.

In Russia the problem is not one of some great fascist party but in the minds of the ordinary people For example on the bus you can often hear someone saying "what do you want, Jew?" It is nationalism in the common context of the bus, street, etc that is the problem. If you look at our history, there was some explosion of this antisemitism, even before 1917 it existed and you can read about it if you read some of Lenin's articles Yes it is a problem. I don't know if it is a great problem, but I understand when thousands of Jews are leaving the Soviet Union there is a problem. After all they are citizens of our country, it is their homeland, they were born here and now, they are leaving. This is a problem, something must be done.

Can you tell me something your organisation?

First we were an ecological movement "The Next Stop" , I think it was founded in 1985 or '86. We had ties with the Scandinavian countries and also with West Germany. But then in the summer of '89 we decided to broaden our organisation and we transformed ourselves into the International Discussion Club. We organise conferences, exchanges with student and youth groups. What type of subject does your club discuss?

It is a club to discuss political and economic ideas, primarily political ideas and problems. We do not just discuss issues to do with the USSR but international issues. We are now preparing a conference with our Italian friends to discuss political, economic, social and ecological issues, maybe to be held in Rome. It will be a conference to discuss a third way of development. Has the Soviet government tried to stop you organising?

No, we are not a political party, so we are not campaigning against the Communists directly. Things have changed over the last few years, there are many political parties, some campaigning against the Communists, some are not. The problem is that most are still very weak.

----- pull-quotes -----

mosques be burned?

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 460

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →