This war is about oil
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-09-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
2 THE GULF From back page seen as the product tary majority?
The real issue is this. Everybody knows it, and nobody has mentioned it. The Americans want to protect their oil supplies. I think that I am right in saying that not one Member on either side of the House has drawn attention to what the former Attorney-General of the United States, Ramsey Clark, said on the radio last night. He said that the United States forced Saudi Arabia to accept its army there because it wanted to protect its oil.
We are experienced as an imperial power and that will not shock the Conservatives. I am not asking anyone to be shocked, only to recognise the fact that stares us in the face. America has benefited much recently from cheap middle eastern oil. It was reported in the Financial Times that it has reduced its oil production and increased its oil imports from 31 per cent to 52 per cent. It has become hooked on this cheap fluid that now has to be controlled by the American army. That is honestly the position. The United States want a permanent base.
I have not had a distinguished military career, but I served in Egypt in 1945 and I still have my identity card saying that I was exempt from Egyptian law. I looked at it the other day. We had a base at Tel-el-Kevir in Egypt from 1888, when Mr Gladstone put it there, to 1956. If one talked to any Egyptians, all they did was read a list of promises by successive British governments about when we would withdraw our base. We withdrew in 1956 and were in again within a few weeks.
Then there is the arms trade. That has been brought out a bit. A couple of years ago in Algiers 1 met a former Egyptian Foreign Minister who told me that there had been a seminar in Cairo about the crusades and that during thé crusades European arms manufacturers supplied arms both to Richard Coeur de Lion and to Saladin. Nothing has really changed.
Arms manufacturers have made billions of pounds from selling instruments of mass destruction, partly to hold down these colonial people so that the sheikhs will supply cheap oil, and partly because it is highly profitable to sell arms. I shall not try to differentiate between Governments because the Labour Government did it too.
The arms trade is a corrupt trades If our troops have to fight those of Saddam Hussein — and I hope that that does not happen - they will be fighting against modern weapons in part sold by Britain, France, America and Russia for profit. That is a major issue.
If we go to war, and there are those who think that we might -what will be our war aims? That is not an unreasonable question. Will it be to free Kuwait, to topple Hussein or to destroy Iraqi weapons? My right hon. Friend the Leader of the Opposition went further than the Prime Minister in setting the objective. She said that it was to arrest Saddam Hussein and to bring him before an international crimes tribunal: The Prime Minister said that on television. Are British troops to be sent in to fight before their objective has been clarified? The Government have never made clear what is their aim. However, it is clear that the United States, having helped to arm Hussein is determined to bring him down and to establish a new base.
I do not need to dwell on the consequences of war. They include a massive loss of life and possibly an air attack on oil installations. In the peculiar circumstances, we would to some extent, if not in every sense, be taking on Islam. Stalin is remembered for asking a very silly question. He asked how many battalions the Pope had. • We should ask how many divisions the prophet Mohammed had. There are 105 million Muslims in India alone. We have some here, too. I am sure that the BBC World Service will explain that that has nothing to do with the situation, but there are people who will see our action as an attempt to reimpose a white, rich control over an area once dominated by the British empire.
The Prime Minister courteously gave way to me when I asked what I hope was a relevant question. She said three times - so she must have meant it - that she already has the legal right to attack Iraq and that no further stages are necessary. The only consideration is that that will be done not at her discretion but that of President Bush. I say that anyone who goes into the Lobby with the Government tomorrow night will be endorsing the view that no further action is needed to legalise an attack on Iraq. Those who vote with the Government tomorrow will be voting for giving the Prime Minister a free hand or a blank cheque.
Those who vote against the Government will be accepting the view expressed in my early-day motion, which calls on the Government "to make a clear and unequivocal statement that it will not commit British Forces to offensive military operations against Iraq that have not been explicitly authorised by a Resolution passed by the Security Council, and under the provisions of the UN Charter, which deal with the use of force by the United Nations, and under its military command."
I referred to two points of view, but others may think that it is better to reserve judgement and not to vote at all. Even those who cannot go with my view may not want to give the Prime Minister a free hand between now and 15 October.
Yet another view has been constructively touched upon by other speakers. I refer to the belief that peace is possible, but that one must take a broad view of the factors involved.
One must look both at the withdrawal of Iraqi troops from Kuwait and UN resolutions relating to the West Bank. One cannot pick and choose between Security Council resolutions. One must have both a Palestinian state and security for One must deal also with the oil companies that are busy exploiting the situation as much as they can. There has been a 7 per cent fall in oil production worldwide but a 100 per cent increase in its price. How is that justified? Thank God for Winston Churchill who, in 1914, when he was First Lord of the Admiralty, nationalised the AngloIranian i Petroleum Company for £2 million. His speech on that occasion made the strongest case for public control and ownership of oil companies that one can find. Winston Churchill said that countries were being squeezed by the oil companies.
If there is to be a peace-keeping force, it would be better if it were Arab, but I turn to the longer, postcold-war perspective to which our attention has been properly drawn by a number of speeches. One cannot have a new order for the Middle East based on the redeployment of white power in the form of a permanent American army in Saudi Arabia. That will not work.
One is no longer dealing with the natives who featured in Rudyard Kipling's poems but with a quite different world. For me, the United Nations is the General Assembly, not the bigwigs, permanent and rotating members who sit on the Security Council. 1 personally would like to see direct elections to the General Assembly. They might only return one British Member of Parliament, but I would certainly be a candidate, if that were possible.
We are always being told that we must come to terms with reality and that we must not live in the past. The fact remains that we live in a very small world of many religions. There are fundamentalist Christians. When President Reagan spoke of an evil empire, he was declaring a Christian jihad against communism. Anyone who has visited America and listened to those Christian fundamentalists, who have not got into trouble and been removed, will know that they make their reputations out of their religious wars against communism. However, as right hon. and hon. Members know very well, the Americans stimulated Islam to defeat communism — but when communism changed, fundamentalism remained.
We shall have to plan and share the world's oil. America has only 2 per cent of the world's population but uses 25 per cent of the world's resources. That situation cannot be allowed to last, even if America has a big army. The real function of the United Nations is to act as the custodian of social justice. It should not serve just as a policeman.
Those members who support the Government's interpretation of the law, and their readiness to use their discretion without referring back to the House again, will vote with the Government in the Lobby tomorrow. Those who oppose the Government will vote with us while others should abstain. I urge caution because many other western European nations are being very cautious and have not sent troops. Pamphlet:
Socialist Organiser Workers 21.00 Arabs, Jews socialism The debatè on Palestine, Zionism and anti-semitism (including "Trotsky and Zionism"
A Workers' Liberty pamphlet : 1.80 plus 24 pence p&p £1.50 plus 24 pence p&p (£3 solidarity price)
----- pull-quotes -----
stand for workers lihero