Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A Vietnam war film with Vietnamese

Socialist Organiser no. 459, 7 September 1990 · scan pp. 10–11 · Liam Conway · about 2,024 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

innocent young lovers, devoted to each other. They're meant to win our sympathy.

But there's a hitch here. At the start we saw Sailor beat a man's orains out in graphic, bone crun ching detail. After that, it's hard to see him as the boy next door.

Lula and Sailor are meant to be super hot for each other, and there is scene after scene of them in bed together. Their talk is supposed to be passionate and wild, but their utterances are so deadpan that it all begins to seem ironic, a send up of passion.

Nicholas Cage as Sailor does at least connect with the audience; there's something pathetically hang dog about him that's winning. But Laura Dern as Lula is less lucky. She tries hard, strutting and posing and arching her back like a cat, but she has nothing, beyond Lynch's one-note, cartoon-sexy concept, to play.

There's something condescending in Lynch's treatment of Lula and Sailor, as if sex were the only bond these "little' people could have. It's only much later that we see tenderness between them, and by then I'd lost interest in both them and the movie.

In Lynch's earlier film, "Blue Velvet', he was lifting the lid on so called 'normal' life to show weirdness and criminality underneath. He probably thinks Hear, Bone But he hasn't. 'Blue Velvet' he's further in "Wild at implied a rejection of criminality and sleaze; there's no rejection in "Wild at Heart', not even in the ending. The violence and sleaze aren't used as a contrast to anything; that's all there is There's no humanity in the characters, and no humanity in the film. The revelations Sailor and Lula make to each other don't add to them as people; they're just there to add shock value of a prurient kind. The treatment of women is also offensive. The camera goes right up into Marietta's face, making us recoil from her, and from her madness, her obsessions, yet without shedding any light on where her madness comes from. It degrades her.

Lula is also violated by Lynch. In one truly repulsive scene, the sleazeball man, Bobby: Peru threatens Lula with rape, and Lynch leaves us thinking she's Lilian Thomson reviews 'Tour of Duty"

• Vietnam war films, the Vietnamese are almost never shown. Why?

The Americans made successful film propaganda about evil Nazis and sadistic Japanese, so why not show the Vietnamese? Is it shame on the part of the Americans? Are they afraid of showing a ragged, peasant army under siege by American technology?

Or does the lack of a Vietnamese presence in films reflect the way many Americans saw the war, and presumably still see it, as one fought against an enemy rarely glimpsed, never understood? Tour of Duty, a television drama series (Saturday evenings, ITV) set in an infantry company in Vietnam in 1967-8 tries to show some of war from the Vietnamese side. It hasn't done it well, but it's made more of an effort than any feature film to date, and the sightings of Vietnamese, though rather The reality of the V soldiers to spare he Saigon 1967 break a long standing taboo. These Vietnamese are not the sadistic Orientals of World War 2 movies, or the more recent, racist Deer Hunter, but are human beings fighting a just war.

Tour of Duty has the obligatory Saigon bar girls but it also has NLF and NVA soldiers, and other civilian Vietnamese, both peasants and town dwellers, trying to live their lives in the cross fire of war.

In one of the early episodes there was an extended section in a Vietnamese tunnel, where Taylor, a captured black soldier, has been taken. Taylor, terrified at being in the hands of the enemy, has his thinking turned round by a kindly Vietnamese doctor who treats his wounds, all the while wondering why he, an oppressed blackman, fights for the US.

Taylor says he was drafted, a form of legal slavery, and the doctor agrees. He then goes on to say that Vietnam is his country, that his people fought the French and then the Japanese, and they'll fight the Americans to the end too, no matter what it takes.

These scenes, which allow us to build up an identification with the Vietnamese balance the story in the way other war films don't. When it's only the Americans we're nam war: a South Vietnamese woman begs US ome during an anti-Communist operation, encouraged to identify with in movies, it's small wonder that audiences cheer to see the Vietnamese blown up. But in the tunnel scenes, the truth of the war was clearly stated, not by an American, but by a Vietnamese with right on his side.

The series hasn't really retreated from that, but it's concentrated much more on the American experience, and the kind of tough realism represented by the battle hardened Sergeant Anderson. Anderson's limited, but he cares about his men; he doesn't want to see them killed. He's meant to represent the ordinary soldier, uninterested in the rights or wrongs of the war, doing the job he was sent there to do, and surviving if he calfour of Duty tries to tackle issues, such as pacifism, war trauma, looting and desertion, but it trivialises them for the fifty minute format. In the firsi episode, Horn, a college educated GI, refuses to fight, claiming the war is wrong. He leaves his weapon behind on the chopper, and keeps his head down in the firefights.

Yet by the next episode, Horn's toting a gun, having learned from Anderson that a war zone is no place for philosophy. Either you kill the enemy, or he kills. you.

It shows the confusion of the GIs when the NVA bombard them with propaganda, claiming the ruling elite who sent them to die aren't fighting by their side, then doesn't take the trouble to work issues through. Solutions like Horn picking up a gun are too pat. The Anderson view, that politics and understanding are luxuries that soldiers can't afford, always prevails.

Glimmers of consciousness get buried in the daily struggle for survival. Yet the struggle seems unreal, because the core characters never get a scratch. Week in, week Anderson and the men escape from upbeat endings, in which impossible situations, undercut what we really know about the war. Their immunity from death is a form of cheating.

The essence of war films is tension; the fear that death can come at any time. Removing that tension, by removing the threat of death, may make the show palatable for television but it robs it of reality.

Continuity is the one thing lacking in real war. People get killed or wounded. The faces change.

of course TV dramas need characters we relate to week after week, so Anderson and Co have to survive. But keeping them alive leaches out the drama and suspense.

The cast is ethnically balanced, with black, white and Hispanic soldiers fighting side by side under the (white, and possibly Jewish) officer, Lieutenant Goldman. The series constantly underlines the cramped, poverty stricken backgrounds of the GIs. Most of them have nothing to look foward to back in the 'world'. The series is anxious to point out that most of the soldiers came from the working class not from middle class familieswith 'connections' and that these men were betrayed by the society who sent them to war.

The Japanese medic in the squad was killed off early in the series, but not before he's given a few insights into American racism. His parents, interned in World War 2, lost everything, so his father advised his son to grab what education he could They can't take that away from you, he told him. Except by sending you to your death in Vietnam, of course.

Tour of Duty's images seem to come from other war films, such as Apocalypse Now, rather than from the war itself, and some of the writing is overly self conscious, cursed as it is by the writers hindsight. Yet the hindsight says the war was wrong. It doesn't try to cop out by claiming it simply wasn't fought right, or that middle class liberals spiked the army's guns, though both complaints have come out of Gl's mouths in the course of the series.

Tour of Duty, plagued as it is by wooden acting, increasingly soapy scripts and unconvincing lungle, isn't as one sided as most of the big war movies. Of course it's a whole lot sorrier for the US soldiers than it is for the Vietnamese whose lives and country they're destroying. But as least the enemy' has a face and a cause worth fighting for, That's a first.

Scan page 11

back to fight Teachers start the new term in T a mixed state of anxiety and confusion. Anxiety over their jobs prospects and confusion over the direction of education in the 1980s.

On the jobs front, redundancies still threaten in many parts of the country. Ironically, in London there are still teacher shortages. Many London boroughs are relying very heavily on supply teachers and recruits from virtually every country in the world, some of whom have been persistently denied "teacher" status in Britain, in order to fill the gaps. Some boroughs have even been saved by the crisis in the Gulf which has prevented teachers taking up lucrative posts in Kuwait. Elsewhere extra incentank), for their continued the GCSE exam. This apparent U-turn on the attributes of the GCSE reflect uncertainty amongst Tory ranks about the direction of education in general. The summer has produced many conflicting pronouncements about the National Curriculum. The use of tests in primary schools has already proved a disaster, taking up too much time with a few bewildered and anxious children whilst «The only antidote to these ailments will be strong union action"

others are left to work on their own in own advisers strongly recommends the extension of "Green education" , with studies of global warming, rain-forest destrution, the advance of the deserts and the extinction of many plant and animal species. However, such education may well be banned as quickly as it is introduced as children discover that the cause of these problems is international capitalism.J Another blow to Tory educational philosophy came this week through the publication of a Swedish report on. creche children. Thatcher's claims that children are better off at home with "their mothers' are disproved by the report which shows that creche children become better performers, are more creative, more self-confident and more popular than their counterparts.

Of course none of these revelations about the bankruptcy of Tory educational ideas should come as any surprise to teacher trade unionists who are increasingly realising that the government does not change its mind even when it's proved to be stupid. Consequently the coming year will mean more of the same (OILC) are to meet national union officials this week to review progress in the oil workers' safety and recognition dispute.

The unions are preparing a ballot for union recognition but are being obstructed by the oil contractors who refuse to provide them with the names. and addresses of workers.

Yet it is the same oil contractors who have refused to negotiate with the unions until they hold a ballot!

Thursday's meeting should immediately go ahead with the ballot and name the day for the start of an all-out North Sea-wide strike. All-out action will quickly bring the employers to their knees. It will cost them 400,000 barrels a day and hit the exchequer to the sum of €2.2 million per day. can be no compromise. That is our demand that the men sacked after taking action should be reinstated."

Ronnie McDonald Chair, Oil Industries Liaison Committee OILC should take firm control of the running of the dispute on the ground and there must be no deals over the heads of the rank and file which leave a single oilworker locked out.

----- pull-quotes -----

disappointed when he suddenly TV

workers: pressure. Name day for action! epresentatives of the rank R and file-based Offshore

keep up "On one issue there

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 459

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →