The S Atlantic and the Gulf
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-09-07Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Making the oil fields safe feudalism?
**The Saudi Arabian (women) you see" , according to a report in the Economist magazine (8 February 1986), "are 'wrapped up like maize'; their faces, as well as most Fridays"
Migrant workers are a minority of the population in Saudi Arabia, rather then a majority as in Kuwait and the Gulf emirates. But they still fairly stable. Britain withdrew from direct control. Until 1979 the Shah's Iran acted as a 'subimperialism' to police the area (sending troops, for example, to help Most of the Left supportTed Argentina throughout the South Atlantic war, believing that an Argentinian victory would somehow be a blow for "anti-imperialism".
A defeat for the junta, they argued through convoluted logic, would strengthen imperialism, and therefore even strengthen the junta itself.
The most rabid pro-Argentinian current was the American Socialist Workers Party, then linked to the United Secretariat of the Fourth International. The SWP went as far as to publish a speech in their weekly paper, The Militant, by Galtieri's foreign minister, Costa Mendez.
The Militant published an article by Will Reissner, later also published in Britain, comparing the economic development of Argentina and Canada. It argued that the lower level of Argentinian economic development was caused by foreign investment. Quite apart from whether this, in itself, would determine a political attitude in war, the argument ignored the fact that Canada receives more foreign investment than Argentina.
Clearly, foreign investment alone could not explain the nature of Argentinian capitalism, and certainly could not be the more or less sole criterion by which to define Argentina as a semi-colonial oppressed nation which should be supported in the war.
In Argentina itself, the main would-be Trotskyist group, led by Nahuel Moreno, called for national unity and for trade unions to set up recruitment centres for the armyOthers were less crude. But some on the Left did not take the proArgentinian line. The British Militant were unique in making little objection to the war at all. They dismissed calls for the fleet to be withdrawn, arguing that it was a completely utopian demand.
Their alternative was that a socialist federation be established of Britain, Argentina and the Falkland Islands. Militant coupled this slogan with a call for a general election in Britain which would throw out Thatcher, replacing her with a socialist Labour government -which might indeed decide to continue the war on a new, socialist. basis, helping the Argentinian workers to overthrow Galtieri., This, of course, was not at utopian.
Like now over the Gulf, many people who opposed the war were in favour of economic sanctions instead. Militant echoed this call, demanding a trade union boycott of Argentina.
The British Socialist Workers Party did not support Argentina, although they made very little of the theoretical questions involved. Fortunately enough - for them. More recently they have taken extremely crude "anti-imperialist" lines on the conflict between Iran and Iraq, in the closing stages of the Gulf War, and over the current Gulf These positions don't square at all with their stand on the South Atlantic War. But the SWP see no need to explain themselves, and still less to educate their members in their own history.