A cooked-up case
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-09-07Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
Leading Clare Short's hypocritical screed in Tribune dishonestly defending the ban on Socialist Organiser reminds me of the headmaster's words before the cane falls on some defenceless behind: "This will hurt me more than it hurts you."
The knowing, understanding adult revolted at violence suffers far more mental anguish than the foolish child who will just have to put up with a sore bum. All total nonsense, of course, but acceptable in a world of stiff upper lips and children being seen and not heard.
In the modern Labour Party, similar patent nonsense is common currency. Clare Short wants us to believe that she really suffered when Militant was proscribed. She does not believe in principle in expulsions, and consequently suffered "deep revulsion" at the wholesale abandonment of "democratic debate" . The reality is that her mental torture lasted as long as the proverbial headmaster's - just long enough to wipe the blood off the cane and call "Next!" Next, in this case, is Socialist Organiser - banned from democratic debate in a secret hearing, without formal charges or bourgeois rules of evidence. SO's "trial" brings shame on the Labour Party, but I do not suppose Ms Short has had many sleepless nights.
For the record, it is worth stating what SO is before comparing reality with Ms Short's conscience. Basically, SO is a weekly newspaper, supported by the people who sell it in terms of money and labour. More than that, it is a forum for socialist ideas - which are discussed on paper and in meetings. Quite apart from the fact that everyone on the left knows these things from their experience, the paper, openly sold in public places, says what we are every week!
As a Labour Party member of long standing, Ms Short has had plenty of contact with SO and has been involved with SO supporters in many labour movement and women's campaigns.
So she can hardly claim SO is "secretive" • She cannot be surprised to learn that SO is "revolutionary" . Given SO's openness, not only during the period of the current witchhunt but generally, Clare Short has no grounds for her claim that we are "dishonest" in our dealings with other labour movement bodies. During the FAB campaign Ms Short worked closely with SO supporters, rank and file Labour Party women who needed her parliamentary voice.
Similarly SO supported the Time To Go initiative, and held a wide-ranging debate around her attempt to ban "Page 3" topless nodels. Is Clare Short asking us to believe that she was unaware of these activities, or did not notice that speakers at Time To Go or FAB events had bags full of the paper, and began by introducing themselves as "from SO". The activities she finds so "distasteful" now are the same "secretive" activities she was happy to be associated with 12 months ago. For "infiltration" read "by invitation"* Ms Short also raises the popular spectre of "bullying" , "intimidation" and "violence" in the certain knowledge that even the NEC could not and did not substantiate those charges. Yet they remain, proclaiming guilt by association.
In her two paragraphs about Frank Field's dossier, she says that many lof its| complaints were "specious". That admission is shown by what follows to be hypocrisy. "But there were a number of complaints...of bullying and intimidation which drove" members away from the Party.
She doesn't say that the NEC upheld none of those complaints, and in effect declared them all "specious". • Yet she manages to leave the impression that some were justified and that the complaints all concerned SO (which they did not).
"The NEC has a duty to act against such practices whenever they are brought to our attention" Even when it finds against the charges?
And when she justifies banning SO by reference to "fascists" and to "violent" and "criminal" activities, it is inescapably a scandalous amalgamation, albeit a sneaky one.
Such trickery and dishonesty!
Clare Short refers to the "100s of pages of SO's own internal documents" with which the NEC was "provided". • (There were about 80, all openly circulated.) Does she know she could have had hundreds more pages, all provided by SO, as per our offer? Or does she prefer to sustain the myth of "secretive sects" by getting an incomplete set via a circuitous route? The documents from which she draws such damning conclusions were marked "Confidential for the first time by the Labour Party NEC! They contain minutes of meetings and continuations of discussions held in the paper. Contributors' real names are used throughout. The veneer of secrecy was added later, by the likes of Ms Short.
Right next to Ms Short's letter in Tribune is a box advertisement which reads: "Going to Labour Party conference this year? Tribune needs volunteers to sell copies of the paper and help at the Tribune rally. if interested contact.." No doubt those helpers will be given pieces of paper with arrangements on, they will hand out leaflets which carry suggestions as to how delegates should vote, and will undoubtedly become part of a network of people who regularly support, sell and contribute to the paper...There is nothing distasteful and secretive about that process and Ms Short will not institute a witchhunt against Tribune's many supporters (I hope).
The words "in the party but not of the party" are a tendentious paraphrase of a note of an individual contribution to an EB discussion, not anything we would acknowledge as our collective view. A secretive and conspiratorial, "central democratic" (sic) grouping, made up of people of average intelligence, simply would not pur such material into circulation as we do.
SO has been just as open as Tribune. It is the likes of Clare Short who have invented a conspiracy where there is none, and who sustain the lie by devious writing. With one hand on her heart, and her fingers crossed behind her back, Ms Short asks for our sympathy over her hard decision. Ms Short would be entitled to support had she stuck up for her "democratic" principles and demanded a fair, open hearing for SO. But Ms Short has learned that principles are cheap compared to the sordid joys of power so she will have to suffer her anguish alone.
Like lawyer like client! To justify the new twist in the spiral of Labour Party authoritarianism, the ban on Socialist Organiser, Clare Short uses exactly the NEC's own mixture of sloppiness, dogmatism and false amalgamation.
Clare Short's letter is itself data for a study of the growth of authoritarianism in the Labour Party. By Mark Osborn disagree with almost everything I've ever read in Socialist Organiser. But I defend your right to publish the. paper, and the right of Labour Party members to read it, sell it, and raise funds for it", said Phil Kelly, editor of Tribune, at the 'End the Ban' rally last Saturday 1 September.
200 Labour Party activists attended the rally in London's Conway Hall.
It was organised by 'End the Ban!', the broad campaign set up to fight the ban imposed on Socialist Organiser by Labour's National Executive on 25 July.
"End the Ban!' is supported by the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy, Labour Party Socialists, Labour Left Liason, Women for Socialism, Labour Briefing and Socialist Outlook. Bill Hamilton, speaking on behalf of the 'End the Ban!' committee at the end of the rally, stressed that the campaign's no. 1 priority in the next four weeks, up to Labour's Annual Conference in Blackpool, must be to get in emergency motions against the ban.
The Labour leadership will attempt to get the ban endorsed by conference with little or no debate. Our chances of stopping them depends entirely on how many emergency motions we get in.
The proceedings which led to the ban on SO began with Birkenhead CLP's decision to deselect Frank Field MP. Field blackmailed Labour's NEC into an 'investigation' by threatening to resign, force a sudden by-election, and stand against Labour. He presented a huge 'dossier' with a blunderbuss of allegations against all sorts of people, including SO. (None of these