The case for banning SO Clare Short Clare Short
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-09-07Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
Tribune (which opposes the ban on SO) published the following article by Clare Short in defence of the NEC's decision. Short has had some credibility as an independent-minded intelligent leftist. Her lawyerly efforts to defend the NEC's decision to ban SO may well be the best case that can be made for what the NEC has done. I is a very shoddy effort, as. Liz Millward shows in her reply.
disagree very strongly with Paul Anderson's argument (Tribune, August 3) that because Socialist Organiser has only 350 members and an effective presence (I presume this means domination) in two Constituency Labour Parties, the National Executive Committee should not have declared membership incompatible with Labour Party membership.
It is very important that the Left should discuss this issue. We all feel a deep revulsion to the ideal of expulsions because we believe so deeply in democratic debate. But this cannot mean that any organisation, whatever its beliefs and methods of organisation, is free to infiltrate the If fascist groups started to move into the Labour Party, I presume there would be no dispute that membership of such groups was incompatible with Labour Party membership. I presume also that everyone would agree that individuals who engaged in violent or criminal activity should be expelled from the party.
The NEC decided some time ago that membership of Militant was incompatible with Labour Party membership. Painful as I found the whole question, I believe that decision was right.
But, because members of Militant are not honest about their membership, beliefs and organisational methods, we are left with a problem in deciding whether any particular individual is a legitimate member of the party. We have therefore created a procedure for dealing with cases which provides a fair chance for each individual to make his or her case.
It is true that Socialist Organiser was brought to the attention of the NEC through the Frank Field dossier. My view of that dossier was, and is, that many of the complaints were specious. But there were a number of complaints from long-standing members of bullying and intimidation which drove them away from the party.
The NEC has a duty to act against such practices whenever they are brought to our attention. In the case of Birkenhead, the NEC has done this and now plans to hold a fair selection.
The complaint against Socialist Organiser was also investigated. When it was first put to the NEC, there was insufficient documentation and we agreed that we needed more evidence.
At our last meeting we were provided with hundreds of pages of Socialist Organiser's own internal documents which showed without doubt that it is a vanguardist, secretive, central democratic, revolutionary organisation which is "in the party but not of the party". -It is the duty of the NEC/to protect our constitution and therefore to declare membership of Socialist Organiser incompatible with Labour Party membership. Any individual liable to expulsion following this decision will have a right to put his or her case before a decision is made. -I agree with John Stuart Mill that a proliferation of eccentric views is a reflection of liberty. All such groups are entitled to organise and seek support, although I find the dishonest way in which they go about this distasteful and deeply undemocratic.
But they are not entitled to misuse our party for their own ends.
If we allow our distaste for expulsion to leave us open to infiltration by such groups, we are damaging the capacity of the Labour Party to represent the needs and views of Labour voters. ideas Tr cam gath spee