Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Why support Arab unity?

Socialist Organiser no. 459, 7 September 1990 · scan pp. 4–5 · about 2,825 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

The editorial in Socialist Organiser no.458 raised more questions than it answered.

The creation of a unified Germany did not result in the oppression of cohesive national minorities within its borders. This would not be the case in the event of an Iraqiunified Arab state. Even within the existing borders of Iraq the Kurds are an oppressed national minority. An Iraqi-unified Arab state would generate, rather than resolve, a wave of questions of national oppression, If one believes that socialists and democrats should "accept" an Iraqi-unitied Arab state, then why not "accept" the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait? After all, Iraq could "unite" the Arab world only through a series of wars of conquest sanctions on Iraq, he argues against sanctions that they will cause economic hardship to the people of Iraq. That is surely true of all sanctions, whoever imposes them. 21 •Why then did SO support sanctions in several instances in the past, as when martial law was imposed on Poland in 1981? If we supported Tom's argument we would always be against sanctions in all cases and that is a ridiculous position.

- His other argument is that we oppose them in this case because "few of the third world governments would now be prepared to back military action needed to impose effective economic sanctions against which repeated in a rather more bloody form the Iraqi annexation of Kuwait.

In fact, if socialists and democrats are obliged to "accept" an Iraqi-unified Arab state whilst fighting its political regime, then surely in the 1940s socialists and democrats should have "accepted" the German "unification" of the bulk of Europe whilst fighting the Hitlerian political regime. Hitlerian Germany "united" most of Europe through military conquest, which is the method Hussein would have to employ in order to "unite" the Arab world.

Seperate from the specific issue of Arab unification under Hussein, the editorial also argues in more general terms that "socialists should support the unity of the Arab people if they themselves wish it. The achievement of such unity would be progressive, in part Saddam", Surely that is contradicted by the 13-0 vote at the Security Council on the resolution to use all means necessary to impose sanctions? How far that vote will be replicated at the General Assembly we cannot say at the time of writing, but it would not be surprising if it was fairly overwhelming.

And that must surely be in line with the view of the SO editorial: *The idea of a UN regulated world order is a good one." Tom Rigby and other members of the Editorial Board will therefore surely welcome all moves which tend to curb the power of the US and bring its acnons imposition of economic sanctions against fraq.

McCalman Glasgow because it would clear the minds of the Arab working class and help them to deal with their own ruling classes"

Why should Arab unity help Arab workers deal with their own ruling classes? The editorial itself makes the point that it is the Arab ruling classes that control the (Arab) states today". • Given that this is indeed the case, surely the class-against-class divisions are clear enough already, in the absence of any supplementary re-jigging of national boundaries in the name of "Arab unity"

Indeed, the emergence of a pan-Arab supra-state (even one not under the political regime of Hussein) would confuse rather than clarify societal class divisions, if, as is likely to be the case, it created new instances of national and ethnic oppression and discrimination and thus provoked heightened inter-ethnic conflicts at the expense of class-based confilcts.

There is therefore no basis for assuming, in the manner of the editorial, that the creation of a unified Arab state would necessarily be progressive. The editorial itself points out that "pan-Arab tionalism today is an ideological system which ties the working class to the petty bourgeoisie and sections of the bourgeoisie." To passively declare that "the achievement of Arab unity would be progressive" merely gives undue credence to the pan-Arab rhetoric of anti-working class forces. The editorial seems to be looking both ways at once.l The editorial rightly calls for the withdrawal of the Iraqi occupying forces, and yet rejects the slogan of "self-determination for Kuwait' Why?

It is true that less than 50% of the population are Kuwaiti. It is also true that only 36% of the population of Kazakhstan ate Kazhaks, and only 48% of the population of Khirgizia are Khirgiz. But I have yet to hear anyone suggest that these Soviet republics should not be allowed to advocate self-determination for themselves on the grounds that the original indigenous population is in a minority.

As socialists we are in favour of full civic rights for migrant workers, and therefore in favour of migrant workers being entitled to an equal say in the right of the country in which they are working to self-determination. The general right of self-determination surely applies to the entire population of a country, not just to its 'indigenous' population.

The editorial speculates about possible scenarios in which socialists might feel obliged to rally to the detence ot Iraq, in the event of a struggle for "Iraqi self-determination against an imperialist invasion or blitzkrieg" . The basic argument seems to be that sub-imperialist Iraq may find itself faced with "conquest and subjugation" in a situation where its sub-imperialist drive "collapses into its opposite"

This is less than coherent. In 1918 Germany's imperialist drive "collapsed into its opposite" (loss of territory, imposition of reparations, the later occupation of the Ruhr, etc) and so again too in 1945 (foreign occupation, division of Germany, etc). No socialist, however, suggested defending Germany in 1918 or 1945 because the country faced conquest and subjugation.

Surely it is in the nature of an expanding sub-imperialist power (in this case, Iraq) to come into conflict with an ageing imperialist power (in this case, America) at a certain point in its development. Why back one side against the other? Whatever the level of conflict, or whatever the location of the fighting, the nature of the confliet would remain unchanged, ie. a struggle for regional hegemony.

Stephen Ryaptis Liverpool

Scan page 5

This year the first student mobilisation will be the Leeds anti-poll tax march, on 24 October NEC (personal capacity)

The NOLS leadership of the National Union of Students has a tradition of ignoring democratically decided conference policy.

Any policy that involves organising a fight back, campaign, taking on the Tories, working alongside the trade unions, or calling for a mid-week demonstration in London is usually (a) formulated by Left Unity, (b) totally ignored by the NOLS leadership.

NOLS have made a bit of a break from this tradition they're still breaking mandates, the odd thing is they've now started to break policy mandates they argued and formulated themselves. If it wasn't so serious it would be highly amusing.

The Central Funding of Areas was discussed and debated over a two-year period. The NOLS leadership, together with Joe Marshall, ex-CP student organiser and NUS NEC, hatched a form of Central Funding that would give total political control of Areas to NUS NEC.

NOLS mustered support in their Areas and convinced the membership that such moves were vital to save Areas from "imminent collapse". Unfortunately for NOLS, a year later they lost control of their Areas (mainly to Left Unity supporters) and the Areas network came up with a mechanism to block NUS NEC's political control of Areas.

As a result of this, NOLS have decided that to implement any form of democratically decided Central Funding policy would be unconstitutional! Various necessary schedules went unchanged when the policy was passed by 75% of conference, they say.

Rather than ensure that such schedules are changed at the coming conference, NOLS have decided to The crisis of political will amongst the majority of the leaders of NUS is set to continue during the next academic year. -The right-wing Kinnockite bloc at the top of NUS is determined that there will be no big campaigns against poll tax, the housing shortage and benefit and course cuts. Now the Gulf crisis demands an active, campaigning, anti-war response from NUS, which it is hardly likely to get from the careerists in Labour Students (NOLS) who do what Walworth Road tells them to.

The last thing the NOLS clique want is big student mobilisations against the war, the poll tax, the loans scheme, and the benefit cuts. Firstly, the Kinnockites oppose the mobilisations politically (they are paying their poll tax, they are for a mass campaign to take out loans).

Secondly, they are embarrassed about any mass movement. Any action terrifies them and disrupts the real business of chatting to the ministers and grabbing a good Fortunately, in the colleges and Areas, there is a different mood. Many of the new layer of Area convenors are supporters of Left Unity. One Area - West Yorkshire - has taken the responsibility of organising the first major mobilisation of the year: their anti-poll tax demonstration will be massive and is set for 24 October.

The basic job for the left is to translate the activity in the colleges into one movement which can both take on the Tories' plans to wreck student living standards and educa be Guardians of Democracy! The truth is they've searched desperately for a get-out and the best they can come up with is that lack of change to various constitutional schedules. The fact that many Areas have a left profile and a political will to organise and defend students is surely nothing to do with the NOLS decision.

And, of course, NOLS have conveniently forgotten their fears about the "imminent collapse" of Areas. Or have they? After all, they have agreed to put £25,000 into the CADF, which in real terms represents a huge cut.

Left Unity supported, and still supports, Central Funding, though it actively opposed the NOLS proposals. Central funding could provide a basic level of funding to all Areas regardless of whether or not there is a rich and willing Higher Education college in a particular Area. Areas have an important political role to play within the structures of the national union and the student movement, yet many suffer from serious underfunding and their work is hampered by one financial crisis after another.

The NOLS leadership have once again shown contempt for the democratic procedures of NUS but more than this they have put at risk the whole student movement. Areas will become further weakened if starved of more cash at a time when they have a vital role to play in building and developing unions, organising campaigns against loans, and for a decent living grant, linking up such fights to the fight against the poll tax, and turning the national union into a fighting, campaigning union.

We have to fight to defend Areas, to demand Central Funding and forcing the NOLS leadership to make a financial committment to all Areas, and not just the ones in antitina conchronication with з LAMAA themselves.

tional opportunities and take on right wing at every level in NUS.

To do that we will have to overcome the rabid sectarianism amongst the NUS left. We will also have to spell out a strategy which the left can get together to fight around.

With this in mind, Left Unity has produced the Campaign. for a Fighting Union. The campaign aims to pull all NUS activists together who broadly agree with:

• fighting the poll tax;

• an affiliations drive tied to policies which develop the strength of the working-class FE sector;

• a more democratic union with an accountable leadership.

This campaign has already met with a fantastic response. During the next year the campaign will help to break down the barriers on the NUS left and pose a real threat to the right-wing careerists on the NUS NEC.

Anti-poll tax dem 24 October 12.00 Woodhouse Organised by West Area NUS. Backe National Uni Dn STOP er. 11CRANTS Janine Booth (NUS Women's Officer - at that time MANUS convenor) leads last October's MANUS anti-loans demonstration.

uca By Steph Ward Further Education students Fihis week only to fid that this week only to find that over the summer the council has decided to cut the maximum discretionary grant from £625 to £412.50, and the free travel for students who live more than three miles away has been abolished.

This is the latest in a long series of education cuts which have included the loss of 24 jobs in the education department and the redeployment of hundreds of teachers and lecturers.

Once again the implementa Wendy Robson ast Friday, 31 August, women relatives of the Hillsborough football disaster mounted a 24-hour demonstration outside the headquarters of the South Yorkshire police, who were responsible for policing the match.

The women were protesting at Thursday's decision by the Director of Public Prosecutions that no charges should be brought against anyone responsible for policing the ground or for safety standards.

This has surprised many who see the disaster as the tragic conclusion of years of heavy-handed policing and profiteering by clubs.

Many of the relatives of the victims of the disaster are waiting for compensation for the loss and trauma caused by the disaster. But what the relatives want most of all is justice and a guarantee that nothing like this will happen again, and feel that this has been set back by the decision.

Chief Superintendent David Duckenfield, the officer in charge of policing Hillsborough that day, has been quoted as saying: This ¡ill One booth CO VENOR of the poll tax is to blame, with the Labour Council going out of its way to make cuts to avoid being capped, rather than leading a fight against the Tories.

South Yorkshire Area NUS is responding to the cuts by sending a petition tu the education committee, holding a meeting for all FE students with Steve Mitchell, NUS VP FEUD, and picketing the education committee on 19 September.

Samm Dextor, president of Castle College, said: "If we don't fight these cuts then who knows what will happen. Grants may be cut altogether and colleges could be closed. It's vital that students get organised now to defeat the poll tax.

decision takes a great weight off my mind." It is obvious that the police feel exonerated by this decision.

Socialist Organiser spoke to two of the women demonstrating in Sheffield last week. Jenni lost two daughters in the disaster and Terri lost a son.

"We can't bring our own families back but we didn't want anyone to ever be in the same situation again. Because of yesterday's decision not to prosecute, they have just been given a licence to do whatever they like, not just the police, but the local authority who are supposed to check the safety at the ground, the FA and all the rest. "That really was a set-back for us because we hoped to get better facilities at grounds, so you don't have to worry about things like that, you can be treated like human beings, not herded in like cattle.

"1 brought my children up to find a policeman if they were ever in trouble. I wouldn't do it now. It's the last thing I'd suggest. I'd suggest every other alternative now, knowing what I know and what we have seen and what we have been through ourselves.

It was mainly young people who died, and they do not come under the compensation laws. They don't

MACCI

FOR 13 YEARS MARTIN HAS PROTESTED HIS INNOCENCE AND FOUGHT FOR HIS DIGNITY. HE NOW SERVES EXTRA YEARS AS FURTHER TORTURE.! have to care about the deaths because all that bothers most of the people is money - the clubs, the FA and the police.

"In everything the police do they should be more accountable. There has got to be a separate authority. The South Yorkshire Police Authority is next to useless because they only tell you what they want you to know. If you want to cover up, you get your mate to do it for you, and that's what happened. It's 'ask my mate if I'm a liar' . It stinks.

"As regards football matches, I don't think that they should be policed. Football supporters are not criminals. There is an element of hooliganism, but an awful lot of it automatically treat anyone who goes anywhere near a football ground like a criminal.

The only ones who aren't treated like criminals are those in the VIP boxers. The average person is treated, first and foremost, as a public nuisance and secondly as a football supporter. Being a human being doesn't enter into it, And that is the thing that has been forgotten at Hillsborough, that there were 95 human beings killed.

----- pull-quotes -----

Always aga sanctions? n Tom Rigby's reply to my letter regarding economic

Don't Pay, Don't Collect Wednesday

Leeds Yorkshire

THE ROT REMAKE

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 459

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →