[Of the US does invade or try to…]
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-09-07Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
Of the US does invade or try to bomb it into submission then socialists should support Iraq" SO 458).
In articles in Socialist Organiser the conflict has clearly been assessed as a battle between the imperialist US and the sub-imperialist Iraq for control of the oil fields and for power in the region.
Would the landing of US troops in Iraq change the nature of this conflict? Would the predatory, reactionary "oil war" be transformed into a just war for Iraqi self-determination?
To both these questions answer has to be no.
The conflict which was sparked by the Iraqi seizure of. Kuwait's oilfields could well escalate into war and spill over into Iraqi soil. But these actions. would not on their own change the nature of the conmct. The war would remain a reactionary conflict between rival powers.
Our view on the character of the war cannot be ruled by the mere transgression of borders and boundaries. The crossing of a border does not, in and of itself, make the conflict primarily about national self-determination, During. World War I some Russian socialists such as Plekhanov used the issue of Belgian self-determination to justify supporting their own ruling class's war effort US and Egyptian troops on exercises against Germany. Lenin rightly denounced this attitude.
He explained that socialists had to look at the fundamental issues at the core of the conflict.
*The most widespread deception of the people perpetuated by the bourgeoisie in the present war is the concealment of its predatory aims with national liberation' ideology." (Lenin, 1915)
The right of the Belgian people to national self-determination was an important concern for socialists. But this issue in World War I was subsumed in the inter-imperialist war for domination and control of colonies. The war was reactionary on both sides.
The landing of US qi soil would not be sufficient to transform the character of the war.
Articles in Socialist Organiser rightly condemn the present conflict in the Gulf as reactionary on both sides. This view should be maintained.
The escalation of the Gulf showdown into a full-scale war will not make the conflict a war of liberation to force the Iraqi people from US oppression.
"But picture to yourself a slaveowner who owned 100 slaves warring against a slave-owner who owned 200 slaves for a more 'just' distribution of slaves. Clearly the application of the term 'defensive? war or war 'for the defence of the fatherland' in such a case would be historically false and in practice would be a sheer deception of the common people of philistines, of ignorant people by the astute slaveowners." (Lenin, 1915))
Lenin may well have been writing about another war, in another place, in another time, but these words ring true for today's conflict in the Gulf.
Finally, again to paraphrase Lenin - it is not the business of socialists to help the younger robber to rob the older and overgorged robbers. Socialists must take advantage of the struggle between the robbers to overthrow them all.
Tony Dorman Manchester