Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Their nightmare, our hope

Socialist Organiser no. 459, 7 September 1990 · scan p. 3 · about 778 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

the US intervention against Israel's. seizure of the West Bank, or Syria's effective takeover of parts of Lebanon?), but that he is acting against the interests of the West". If Iraq gets to control the whole Arabian peninsula, with 56% of the world's oil, then it will be a great economic power, able to dictate terms to the US.

Saddam Hussein is a brutal tyrant, and would-be regional imperialist. The working class has every reason to want him out. But that is a task for the Iraqi people, not for US imperialism - not for the power which has bombed, despoiled and sabotaged across a great swathe of the world, and sustained vicious dictators in countries from Chile through Nicaragua and El Salvador to Turkey and Indonesia.

"The need to cripple Mr Hussein's ability to be a more efficient aggressor next time" sounds reasonable. But it can only mean invading Iraq, deposing its government, imposing a new one, and placing Iraq under some measure of US military control, perhaps even with US troops permanently stationed "The emancipation of the working class is also the emancipation of all human beings without distinction of sex or-race."

Karl Marx Socialist Organiser PO Box 823 London SE15 4NA Newsdesk: 01 639 7965 date for reports: first post MOnday Printed (UK) Ltd (TU).

Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office.

Signed articles do not necessarily reflect the views of Socialist Organiser When Erin has ceasmemory to groan, she will smile through the tears of revival on thine"

Those were the words with which an English poet addressed the Irish Republican Robert Emmett, who, at 22, had been hanged, cut down still alive, disembowelled, and then chopped up by a servant of the then all-powerful British government of Ireland, in 1803.

When the working class has ceased to groan at the memory of the Stalinist tyranny, it will smile on the memory of Leon Trotsky, who defended the working class and the name and principles of international socialism against the Stalinist cataclysm that overwhelmed socialism and Marxism 60 years aghus might Trotsky's followers have expressed their hopes, and neir expectations. Atter Stalinism would come a new restoring working-class rule.

But no. After Stalinism is coming capitalism. Stalinism has discredited socialism; made the workers who have lived at the mercy of the all-powerful Stalinist state tyrants identify socialism with despotism, stark inequality, and needless poverty; and massproduced a sterile, scholastic pidgin-"Marxism" which has settled like a sandstorm over the living roots of Marxism all across the world.

The East European workers -for example, the East German workers, who have not known freedom since 1933! — are having to relearn what millions of European workers already knew at the beginning of this century. That is the price we pay for the betrayals of workers' interests by reformists and Stalinists, and the defeats they brought down on our heads.

But the working class can learn what socialism is, and it will learn, under the whip of the class struggle, with the help of socialists whose ideas embody the memory and experience of working-class history. We can already see that class struggle, rising now even in the USSR.

And Trotsky now, 50 years after his death? Let the author of an antiTrotsky article in last Sunday's Telegraph answer that question.

"It is largely due to the pervasive influence of Trotskyism that the failure of communism has not been accompanied by the instant demise of Marxist influence in British intellectual circles. It is Trotsky, after all, who has been the great hero of the British left"

The article, by Janet Daley (whoever she is), is entitled "Don't let Trotsky save socialism". It is a tedious and clumsy rehash of vintage anti-socialist polemic.

The Sunday Telegraph has a nightmare: that Trotsky did succeed in saving socialism and that now, when the Stalinists are relinquishing their claim to be the socialists and their systems are collapsing, Trotskyism will prove to be the seed for a new growth of unfalsified socialism.

It is the hope and belief translated into bourgeois nightmare - that sustained tiny persecuted groups of Trotskyists through a long unequal struggle. For Daley and the serious, bourgeois press, as for those who have kept Trotsky's cause alive, the name of Trotsky, fifty years after his death, has come to be the name of the real socialism. the name of the real threat looming over the future of the bourgeoisie. It is the name of the hope which inspires us.

When liberated socialist humanimemory of bourgeois and stalinist has ceased to rule, it will recall the name and the memory of Leon | Trotsky with gratitude and love.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 459

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →