Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

THES misrepresents views of the student left

Socialist Organiser no. 458, 23 August 1990 · scan p. 10 · about 612 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

La good thriller, but Hodges never knits the strands together. They're left dangling, leading nowhere. It's all too scattered to make sense.

Martha also goes philosophical on us. Offended by the way her show has been turned into "entertainment" , she is forced to speak the immortal lines: "I know now why we turn everything into entertainment. It's the only way we can handle the random stupidity of it all."

This may be Hodges speaking, aping an existentialist on a bad day, but it certainly isn't Martha, and from this moment, her role collapses. We don't know what she's thinking, or doing, or feeling, at a whole number of points crucial for the plot.

Martha's best moment is when she says if people weren't conned into belief in an after-life, they might get on with making life on earth, their "one more bearable. Yet her whole act perpetuates con. People don't NEC (personal capacity)

Last week the Times Higher Education Supplement (THES) refused to print any letter which replied to a misrepresentation of the views of SO sellers Emma Colyer (NUS National Secretary) and Steve Mitchell (NUS Vice President FEUD).

The rubbish appeared in a THES lead article of 10 August and quoted Emma and Steve as saying "The general view is that we should encourage students to take out a loan" . Emma and Steve (Trotskyists, therefore left of centre were apparently proof of a "new realism within the union" The journalist concerned was THES hack and ex-student "independent" Sian Griffiths. Obviously Griffiths knows that the Left Unity position on loans, passed at Christmas "89 NUS Conference, was mainly written by Emma Colyer and can hardly be described as "new realist" • Our policy calls for demonstrations, direct action and links with workers as part of a mass campaign to defeat loans.

At the same conference Left Unity's 'Don't Pay, Don't Collect Poll fax' policy was also passed.

Both sets of policy were passed despite the opposition of the Kinnockites.

Furthermore, at last week's NUS NEC Left Unity successfully led a challenge to the Kinnockites, proposing a campaign for grants not loans. The defeated position of the new realists was to run a mass take up of loans campaign.

At the same meeting the SWP put a position which concentrated solely on the Higher Education Sector; they did not propose to link the fight against loans to the explosive issues of Poll Tax and housing. The SWP are continuing to focus only on their base among the middle class radicals of the HE sector. observes on TV screens in cafes and bars.

Argentina goes to war with Britain to seize some small islands 2,000 miles away from Veronico's village.

Like the coming of the junta, the war hits the poorest members of society hardest. Just as ordinary workers who oppose the regime's fantastic brutality join the ranks of the disappeared" like Castulo Cruz so too do the children of workers disappear to act as cannon fodder in the war. The despair of parents over their slaughtered sons is everywhere, despite the nationalistic ballyhoo of the regime. The sinking of the General Belgrano alone claimed hundreds of lives.

Meanwhile the teacher frets over Veronico's silence and goes back to Chorcan to find him. He calls in on old Domingo, who had lived cut off from the world since the demise of his old radio. But Domingo has heard from Veronico, who had sent a photo, showing the now grown up with his workmates in his new job. With a sinking heart, the teacher reads the dedication on the picture. The lads from the Belgrano' Veronico had got to sea after all.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 458

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →