Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Support UN sanctions!

Socialist Organiser no. 458, 23 August 1990 · scan p. 9 · about 1,185 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

From page 4 superpowers based on the principle that they don't accept the acquisition of territory by force will be applied to Israel after the Kuwait crisis is over in one way or another.

The conflict is causing big problems for the Israeli left. Many of the more moderate Zionist left are very frightened and disappointed by the fact that the Palestinians are mostly supporting Saddam Hussein, and have denounced the Palestinians in a very negative way.

The crisis is not completely general - for example the Peace Now movement is withstanding it better than I expected, and still maintaining their contacts with the Palestinian leadership in East Jerusalem.

The Trotskyists - the RCL organised a demo last week outside the defence ministry with the theme that Israel must not be involved in the war — it is not our war, and it is against the interests of the people of Israel. Rather than giving a big analysis of who is right and who is wrong in the war, the Americans or the Iraqis, they tried to tell the people in Israel that it's not our war and we should not get involved in it. They also raised the slogan of giving 'anti-Zionist' coin for Socialist Worker? gas masks to the Palestinians.

There is no-one backing Iraq on the Jewish side as far as I know, except a few individuals perhaps. Some individuals feel that whatever we say about Saddam Hussein, it is a sort of anti-colonialist war, but as far as I know there is no organised group on the Jewish side saying that.

hope the outcome will be democratic elections in Kuwait; that annexation to Iraq will not remain, but that there will not be a restoration of the old regime. In fact that is the official position of the PLO. Yasser Arafat has been trying to mediate and to offer some such solution via an inter-Arab force going into Kuwait, but that has been very much obscured.

When people are holding a demonstration on the street, and especially when the demonstration is brutally dispersed by the Israeli army, they want quick answers, and they find a new champion in Saddam Hussein.

In several places in the West Bank and Gaza there were demonstrations where they had pictures of Saddam Hussein and Yasser Arafat and the Palestinian and Iraqi flags.

There is a very interesting in the Golan Heights. Those people have been resisting the annexation of the Golan Heights by Israel for many years. They have always maintained that they are Syrian citizens and want to be part of Syria. They hve demonstrations with Syrian flags.

Usually they got much encouragement from the Syrian side of the border, and there were government-organised demonstrations on the Syrian side of the border.

Now in those villages there are pro-Iraqi demonstrations with Iraqi flags — and without encouragement.

The massive entry of American forces has aroused in the whole Arab world the memory of the big struggles against colonialism, for example in the struggle against British colonialism under the slogan of 'British bases out of Egypt' . For a whole generation of Egyptian nationalists that was the most important thing in their life.

I think that Arab nationalists feel that they struggled for two generations to get rid of foreign armies in the Arab world - they seemed to have won the struggle - suddenly there are again hundreds of thousands of Western soldiers on Arab soil.

am writing to express my disagreement with the position adopted in the pages of your paper on the fragi invasion of Kuwait.

Despite all of your lengthy analysis, you do not advance any course of action leading to an Iraqi withdrawal. Apart from vague references to "workers solidarity" and the leaving of the situation up to. "the Arabs" to resolve (the PLO? the Iranian mullahs? Hussein of Jordan?), you offer no concrete course of action that could possibly achieve your correct aim of driving the Iraqi armies out of Kuwait.

-The correct course of action is to support the demand raised by Tony Benn in your pages for UN imposed economic sanctions.

The arguments used by Tom Rigby against this are unconvincan McCalman's letter on the Gulf crisis is surprising. Surprising in three ways.

Firstly, for the assumption he makes that the UN can really function as some kind of coherent world government, separate from, independent of, and if necessary against, the imperialistic ambitions of the big powers.

There is little to suggest that the unanimous UN stand in favour of sanctions against Iraq is the precursor of a deeper and more sustained unity. No informed commentator in mainstream media seems to think ling. His idea that the result of such sanctions would be to lead to the rise of a "new Hitler" is unwarranted and derogatory of the people of Iraq. Naturally we have no direct control over what might be the internal effects of successful sanctions but that is the case whether the sanctions are imposed by the UN or by the international labour movement.

The more telling argument is that concerning the extent to which the UN is a fig leaf for the self interest of the USA and Britain. No-one on the left would deny the imperialist ambitions of either of these two countries, but surely that is the strongest argument for strengthening the extent to which the whole operation is brought under UN control.

Your articles on the situation are long in analysis but short on solutions. Could you please try to be more explicit.

McCalman • Glasgow He makes little attempt to face up to the fact that effective sanctions necessarily imply a military blockade, which if imposed rigorously is likely to be taken by Saddam as an act of war. Nor does Ian face up to the argument that etfective sanctions would inescapably mean grinding down and economically pulverising the people of Iraq. In effect lan must want to see a mediaeval-style seige of Baghdad or for him sanctions have a purely symbolic value. It the latter is true then surely lan 'has no concrete course of action that could possibly achieve the current aim of driving the Iraqi armies out of Kuwait'?

Finally, Ian's letter is surprising for his discovery that the Iranian. mullahs are Arabs. No, lan, they are not.

In conclusion. Ian asks us to be more explicit as regards solutions. The short answer to that point is that there is no easy, or immediately obvious 'solution' to the lraq occupation of Kuwait. The UN Is no such solution; the American and British expeditionary forces will make things an awful lot worse. The working class in the Arab world is very weak ideologically and organisationally; the best contribution we as socialists in Britain can make to overcome that problem is precisely to analyse the situation, to understand it and build a powerful movement in our own country calling for an end to the imperialist intervention. It's better to be long on analysis than long on daydreams Tom Rigby Southwark

----- pull-quotes -----

phenomenon in the Druze villages

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 458

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →