Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Socialist Worker backs Saddam's demagogy

Socialist Organiser no. 458, 23 August 1990 · scan pp. 9–10 · about 1,009 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

In a situation like that now shaping up in the Gulf, there are two great dangers for socialists.

The first is a temptation to throw our hands in the air and shout "A plague on both your houses", faced as we are with a conflict between one of the most disgusting and savage regimes in the world, that of Saddam Hussein, and the US acting like an old-fashioned gunboat-imperialist power.

Such a position amounts to a collapse into world-weary uncomprehending pacifism. In a situation where the Iraqi-US conflict is igniting a new upsurge of long-dormant Arab nationalism, and thus raising far bigger questions than the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait, such weary pacifism can quickly become a weary disdain for the Arab mobilisation against the US's occupation of Saudi Arabia and its preparations to blitz Iraq, and thus a sort of passive support for imperialism as events unfold towards war.

The second danger is the mirrorimage of the first - a temptation to take sides with any enemy of US and British imperialism, with uncritical enthusiasm and mindless glorification of the "anti-imperialists" or those who are said to be playing "an anti-imperialist role"

That second phrase comes from Socialist Worker. SW has shifted dramatically as the crisis in the Gulf has unfolded. Former supporters of "anti-imperialist" Iran against what they called "imperialism's stooge" Iraq, they have had to make an undignified leap to support iraq. But they have managed it, as they always do in situations like this.

They can barely contain their enthusiasm for the new and unexpected upsurge of anti-imperialism. They ju love Saddam Hussein's demagogy!

SW (18 August) says that Saddam Hussein's "proposals this week for a negotiated end to the Gulf crisis went further. They included demands with which every socialists would be happy, for example, that Israel get out of the occupied territories of Palestine". The SW article does not risk dampening its readers' enthusiasm for the great anti-Zionist Saddam by mentioning the "demand" for Hussein's murdering, army to stop shooting and gassing Kurds.

(There is another twist, too. Saddam Hussein calls on Israel to evacuate the West Bank and Gaza. SW, of course, calls for the complete destruction of Israel. SW's vague formula about "occupied Palestine" is, so to speak, their way, of hiding from the reader Saddam's lack of "radical anti-Zionism"!)

If the US does invade Iraq or try to bomb it into submission, then socialists should support Iraq, despite the butchering demagogue Saddam Hussein. The nitwits who run SW support Iraq for different reasons, as enthusiastic consumers of his demagogic anti-imperialism.

"His call for Israel to 'get out of the occupied territories of Palestine'... will increase his standing among those Arabs who have supported the intifada... So, the more US pressure builds up, the more Saddam will play an anti-imperialist role... This means he will increasingly have to rely on on of his few remaining strengths, the Arab masses' hatred of imperialism. li all of this Saddam should have the support of socialists" • So socialists should endorse as good anti-imperialism the demagogic attempt annex the Arab nationalism of the masses to the interests of the Tragi SW then says that Saddam is no "genuine leader" of Arab liberation. They recall that Saddam Hussein claimed that Iraq's attack on Iran would "pave the way for the liberati of Palestine". That was faking, "sin the Iranian regime was clearly the bi gest threat to US imperialism". Now things are different; though, they add, if Saddam survives he will revert to his old ways. "Socialists must hope that Iraq gives the US a bloody nose and that the US is frustrated in its attempt to force the Iraqis out of Kuwait..."

What? Socialists should feel we had suffered a defeat if Saddam Hussein were now to withdraw from Kuwait, without war? In retrospect we should endorse the invasion of Kuwait? Why? Because the US reaction magically turns the nasty little oil grab of the Iraqi sub-imperialist state into a good anti-imperialist action? Because if Iraq is now defeated, it will be a "victory= for imperialism"? But peaceful retreat would mean the collapse of the brutal Saddam Hussein dictatorship!

Make sense of all that if you can! The explanation for SW's nonsense is quite simple, though. They know what's what in Iraq and the Gulf as well as we do. Rightly, they oppose US and British imperialism. But SW also believes in bending before and reflecting waves of militancy - any militancy, industrial, "anti-imperialist", you name it! They bow to the success of Saddam Hussein's Arab nationalist demagogy. And then they think of "arguments" and reasonings to square off and justify their position.

The SWP is super-Leninist. They are 'the Party" above all other parties. Yet Leninism is above all about the ideological struggle against bourgeois and petty bourgeois ideas — for example, against the sort of nameless, classless, nebulous "anti-imperialism" which Saddam Hussein exploits. SW bends before such ideas. It endorses them rather than fighting them, appealing to "militants" on their existin consciousness.

This is only the latest example. Whatever they call themselves, there are probably few groups of socialists more distant from Leninism than is the SWP! this.

Already there is considerable division and differentiation within the UN over this issue. Jordan and Iran have moved considerably. Paradoxically, for lan, few of the third world governments - whose influence in the UN lan would presumably like to see strengthened - would now be prepared to back against Saddam.

Ian doesn't tell us how the UN could overcome the conflicts of interest between the world's divided ruling classes. The UN reflects these divisions, just as it also reflects — in it's central activity -the hegemony of the US and its allies.

If lan believes this is no longer the case then he should at least provide us with some evidence to back up his hopes.

This brings us to the second prising feature of lan's letter.

sanctions?

Scan page 10

An Argentine

----- pull-quotes -----

the military action needed to im- pose effective economic sanctions

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 458

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →