Stalinism and the Bolshevik tradition
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-08-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
Trotsky takes a breather Leon Trotsky was murdered by a Stalinist agent 50 years ago this week. His skull was shattered by an ice-pick or 20 August 1940, and he died on 21 August, Trotsky was the foremost, the most consistent, the most courageous, and the most tenacious leade of the struggle again: the Stalinist counterrevolution in the USSR. He and his comrades pursued that struggle on the basis of the ideas o the Bolshevik party that had made the 1917 revolution.
Yet today many say that Stalinism was not the counterrevolutionary reversal of Bolshevism, but its direct and logical con tinuation. Trotsky responded to those arguments in a 1937 pamphlet, 'Stalinism and Bolshevism' which we reprint extracts. U Bolshevism the first nder the banner of victory of the proletariat was achieved and the first workers' state established. No force can now erase these facts from history.
But since the October Revolution has led to the present stage of the triumph of the bureaucracy, with its system of repression, plunder, and falsification - the 'dictatorship of the lie', to use Schlamm's happy expression — many formalistic and superficial minds jump to a summary conclusion: one cannot struggle against Stalinism without renouncing Bolshevism.
We must return from Bolshevism to Marxism'. How? To what Marxism? Before Marxism became 'bankrupt' in the form of Bolshevism it has already broken down in the form of social democracy.
Does the slogan 'Back to Marxism' then mean a leap over the periods of the Second and Third Internationals...to the First International? But it too broke down in its time. Thus in the last analysis it is a question of returning to the collected works of Marx and Engels. One can accomplish this historic leap without leaving one's study and even without taking off one's slippers. But how are we going to go from our classics (Marx died in 1883, Engels in 1895) to the tasks of a new epoch, omitting several decades of theoretical and political struggles, among them Bolshevism and the October Revolution?
None of those who propose to renounce Bolshevism as an historically bankrupt tendency has indicated any other course. So the question is reduced to the simple advice to study Capital. We can hardly object. But the Bolsheviks, too, studied Capital and not badly either. This did not however prevent the degeneration of the Soviet state and the staging of the Moscow trials. So what is to be done? Is Bolshevism responsible for Stalinism?
Is it true that Stalinism represents the legitimate product of Bolshevism, as all reactionaries maintain, as Stalin himself avows, as the Mensheviks, the anarchists, and certain left doctrinaires considering themselves Marxist believe? •We have always predicted this, they say. 'Having started with the prohibition of other socialist parties, the repression of the anarchists, and the setting up of the Bolshevik dictatorship in the Soviets, the October Revolution could only end in the dictatorship of the Bureaucracy. Stalin is the continuation and also the bankruptcy of Leninism.:
The flaw in this reasoning begins in the tacit identification of Bolshevism, October Revolution and Soviet Union. The historical process of the struggle of hostile Forces is replaced by the evolution of Bolshevism in a vacuum. Bolshevism, however, is only a political tendency closely fused with the working class but not identical with it. And aside from the working class there exist in the Soviet Union a hundred million peasants, diverse nationalities, and a heritage of oppression, misery and ignorance. The state built up by the Bolsheviks reflects not only the thought and will of Bolshevism but also the cultural level of the country, the social composition of the population, the pressure of a barbaric past and no less barbaric world imperialism. To represent the process of degeneration of the Soviet state as the evolution of pure Bolshevism is to ignore social reality in the name of only one of its elements, isolated by pure logic. One has only to call this elementary mistake by its true name to do away with every trace of it.
Bolshevism, in any case, never identified itself either with the October Revolution or with the Soviet state that issued from it. Bolshevism considered itself as one of the factors of history, its 'conscious' factor — a very important but not decisive one. We never Turn to page 6
Scan page 6
Lenin's Ge This grim gallery was compiled by the US Socialist Workers Party in page sinned in historical. subjectivism. We saw the decisive factor - on the existing basis of productive forces - in the class struggle, not only on a national but on an international scale.
When the Bolsheviks made concessions to the peasant tendency, to private ownership, set up strict rules for membership of the party, purged the party of alien elements, prohibited other parties, introduced the NEP, granted enterprises as concessions, or concluded diplomatic agreements with imperialist governments, they were drawing partial conclusions from the basic fact that had been theoretically clear to them from the beginning; that the conquest of power, however important it may be in itself, by no means transforms the party into al sovereign ruler of the historical process. Having taken over the state, the party is able, certainly, to influence the development of society with a power inaccessible to before; but in return it submits itself to a 10 times greater influence from all other elements in society. It can, by the direct attack of hostile forces, be thrown out of power. Given a more drawn out tempo of development, it can degenerate internally while holding on to power. It is precisely this dialectic of the historical process that is not understood by those sectarian logicians who try to find in the decay of the Stalinist bureaucracy a crushing argument against Bolshevism.
In essence these gentlemen the revolutionary party that conin jail after the 1905 revolution tains in itself no guarantee against its own degeneration is bad. By such a criterion Bolshevism is naturally condemned: it has no talisman. But the criterion itself is wrong. Scientific thinking demands a concrete analysis: how and why did the party degenerate? No one but the Bolsheviks themselves have, up to the present time, given such an analysis. To do this they had no need to break with Bolshevism. On the contrary, they found in its arsenal all they needed for the explanation of their fate. They drew this conclusion: certainly Stalinism 'grew out' of Bolshevism, not logically, however, but dialectically; not as a revolutionary affirmation but as a Thermidorian negation. It is by no means the same.
Bolshevism's basic prognosis The Bolsheviks, however, did not have to wait for the Moscow trials to explain the reasons for the disintegration of the governing party of the USSR. Long ago they foresaw and spoke of the theoretical possiblity of this development. Let us remember the prognosis of the Bolsheviks, not only on the eve of the October Revolution but years before. The specific alignment of forces in the national and international field can enable the proletariat to seize power first in a backward country such as Russia. But the same alignment of forces proves beforehand that without a more or less rapid victory of the proletariat in the advanced countries the workers' government in Russia will not survive. Left to itself the Soviet regime must either fall or degenerate. More exactly; it will first degenerate and then fall.
From the clear understanding of this danger issued the Left Opposition, definitely formed in 1923. Recording day by day the symptoms of degeneration, it tried to oppose to the growing Thermidor the conscious will of the proletarian vanguard. However, this subjective factor proved to be insufficient. The 'gigantic masses' which, according to Lenin, decided the outcome of the struggle, become tired of internal privations and of waiting too long for the world revolution. The mood of the masses declined. The bureaucracy won the upper hand. It cowed the revolutionary vanguard, trampled upon Marxism, prostituted the Bolshevik party. Stalinism conquered. In the form of the Left Opposition, Bolshevism broke with the Soviet bureaucracy and its Comintern. This was the real course of development.
To be sure, in a formal sense Stalinism issue from Bolshevism. Even today the Moscow bureaucracy continues to simply using label Bolshevism to better fool the masses. So much the more pitiful are those theoreticians who take the shell for the kernel and appearance for reality. In the identification of Bolshevism and Stalinism they render the best possible service to the Thermidorians and precisely thereby play a clearly reactionary role.
In view of the elimination of all other parties from the political field the antagonistic interests and tendencies of the various strata of the population, to a greater or lesser degree, had to find their expression in the governing party. To the extent that the political centre of gravity has shifted from the proletarian vanguard to the bureaucracy, the party has changed its social structure as well as its ideology. Owing to the tempestuous course of development, it has sutfered in the last 15 years a far more radical degeneration than did the social democracy in half a century. The present purge draws between Bolshevism and Stalinism not simply a bloody line but a whole river of blood. The annihilation of all the older generation of Bolsheviks, an important part of the middle generation which participated in the civil war, and that part of the youth that took up most seriously the Bolshevik traditions, shows not only a political but a thoroughly physical incompatability between Bolshevism and Stalinism. How can this not be seen?
Stalinism and socialism' The anarchists, for their part, try to see in Stalinism the organic product, not only of Bolshevism and Marxism, but of 'state socialism' in general. They are willing to replace Bakunin's patriarchal 'federation of free communes' by the modern federation of free Soviets. But, as formerly, they are against centralised state power. Indeed, one branch of 'state' Marxism, social democracy, after coming to power became an open agent of capitalism. The other gave birth to a new privileged caste. It is obvious that the source of evil lies in the state. From a wide historical viewpoint, there is a grain of truth in BUKHARIN RYKOV Shot. Shot KOLLONTAI URITSKY Missing? Dead LOMOV SHOMYAN Dead this reasoning. The state as an apparatus of coercion is an undoubted source of political and moral infection. This also applies, as experience has shown, to the workers' state. Consequently it can be said that Stalinısm is a product of a condition of society in which society was still unable to tear itself out of the strait-jacket of the state. But this position, contributing nothing to the elevation of Bolshevism and Marxism, characterises only the general level of mankind, and above all - the relation of forces between the proletariat and the bourgeoisie. Having agreed with the anarchists that the state, even the workers' state, is the offspring of class barbarism and that real human history will begin with the abolition of the state, we have still before us in full force the question: what ways and methods will lead, ultimately, to the abolition of the To deduce Stalinism from Bolshevism or from Marxism is the same as to deduce, in a larger sense, counter-revolution from revolution. Liberal-conservative and later reformist thinking has always been characterised by this cliché. Due to the class structure of society, revolutions have always produced counter-revolutions. Does this not indicate, asks the logician, that there is some inner flaw in the revolutionary method? However, neither the liberals nor reformists have succeeded, as yet, in inventing a more 'economical' method. But it is not easy to rationalise the living historic process, it is not at all difSTALIN, THE SVERDLOV Dead KRESTINSK Y Shot BERZIN ficult to give a rational interpreta tion of the alternative of its waves and thus by pure logic to deduc Stalinism from 'state socialism' fascism from Marxism, reactior from revolution, in a word the an tithesis from the thesis. In this do main as in many others anarchis thought is the prisoner of liberal ra tionalism. Real revolutionary think ing is not possible without dialec The political 'sins' Bolshevism as the source of Stalinism As far as the prohibition of othe Soviet parties is concerned, it dic not flow from any 'theory' o Bolshevism but was a measure o defence of the dictatorship in backward and devastated country surrounded by enemies on all sides For the Bolsheviks it was clear fron the beginning that this measure later completed by the prohibition of factions inside the governing par ty itself, signalised a tremendous danger. However, the root of th danger lay not in the doctrine or the tactics but in the material weaknes ot the dictatorship, in the dit ficulties of its internal and interna tional situation. If the revolution had triumphed, even if only in Ger many, the need of prohibiting the other Soviet parties would have im mediately fallen away. It is ab solutely indisputable that the domination of a single party served as the juridical point of departure for the Stalinist totalitarian regime
Scan page 7
LEON TROTSKY neral Staff XECUTIGNER,- ALONE For forty-three years of my conscious life I have remained a revolutionist; for forty-two o them I have fought under the banner of Marxism. If I had begin all over again I would course try to avoid this or that mistake hut the main course of my life would remain unchanged. I shall die a proletarian revolutionist, irreconcilable atheist. My fai in the communist future of mankind is not less ardent, indeed it is firmer today thar was in the days of my youth Natasha as just come up the window from the courty and opened wider so that my room. I can see the brigt 19:38. Alexandra Kollontai was not in fact missing, but a member of Stalin's diplomatic service green strip of grass beneath the wall and the clear blue s above the wall, and sunlight everywhere. Life is beautiful Let the future generations cleanse it of all evil, oppress and violence and enjoy it STALIN Survivor SMILGA NOGIN Shot ead (URANOY Dead Disap The reason for this development lies neither in Bolshevism nor in the prohibition of other parties as a temporary war measure, but in the number of defeats of the proletariat in Europe and Asia.
There remains only the fact that the Bolsheviks from the beginning applied not only conviction but also compulsion, often to a most severe degree. It is also indisputable that later the bureaucracy which grew out of the revolution monopolised the system of compulsions in its own hands. Every stage of development, even such catastrophic stages as revolution and counterrevolution, flows, from the preceding stage, is rooted in it and carries over some of its features. Liberals, including the Webbs, have always maintained that I the Bolshevik dictatorship represented only a new edition of Tsarism. They close their eyes to such 'details' as the abolition of the monarchy and the nobility, the handing over of the land to the peasants, the expropriation of capital, the introduction of the planned economy, atheist education, and so on. In exactly the same way liberal-anarchist thought closes its eyes to the fact that the Bolshevik revolution, with all its repressions, meant an upheaval of social relations in the interests of the masses, whereas Stalin's Thermidorian upheaveal accompanies the reconstruction of Soviet society in the interest of a privileged minority. It is clear that in the identification of Stalinism with Bolshevism there is not a trace of socialist criteria. ZINOVIEY KAMENEV Shot Shot *: TETATY DZERZHINSK Y Dead I STASSOVA ARTEM Disappeared Questions of morals Complaints of the 'immorality" of Bolshevism come particularly from those boastful nonentities whose cheap masks were torn away by Bolshevism.
The moral qualities of every party flow, in the last analysis, from the historical interests that it represents. The moral qualities of Bolshevism, self-renunciation, disinterestedness, audacity and contempt for every kind of tinsel and falsehood - the highest qualities of human nature! - flow from revolutionary intransigence in the service of the oppressed. The Stalinist bureaucracy imitates also in this domain the words and gestures of Bolshevism. But when "intransigence' and inflexibility' are applied by a police apparatus in the service of a privileged minority they become a force of demoralisation and gangsterism. One can feel only contempt for these gentlemen who identify the revolutionary heroism of the Bolsheviks with the bureaucratic cynicism of the Thermidorians.
Even now, in spite of the dramatic events in the recent period, the average philistine prefers to believe that the struggle between Bolshevism ('Trotskyism') and Stalinism concerns a clash of personal ambitions, or, at best, a conflict between two "shades' Bolshevism. The crudest expression of this opinion is given by Norman Thomas, leader of the American Socialist Party: There is little reason to believe,' he writes (Socialist Review, September 1937, TROTSK Y LENIN In Exile Dead BUBNOV SOKOLNIKOV Marxist, a dialectical Disappeared In Prison MILIUTIN JOFFR Missing Suicide рб), "that if Trotsky had won (!) instead of Stalin, there would be an end of intrigue, plots, and a reign of fear in Russia' . And this man considers himself...a Marxist. One would have the same right to say: *There is little reason to believe that if instead of Pius XI, the Holy See were occupied by Norman I, the Catholic Church would have been transformed into a bulwark of socialism' . Thomas fails to understand that it is not a question of to match between Stalin and Trotsky, but of an antagonism between the bureaucracy and the proletariat. To the full be sure, the governing stratum of L Trotsky the USSR is forced even now to adapt itself to the still not wholly liquidated heritage of revolution, Coyoacan while preparing at the same time through direct civil war (bloody "purge' — mass annihilation of the discontented) a change of the social regime. But in Spain the Stalinist clique is already acting openly as a bulwark of the bourgeois order against socialism. The struggle against the Bonapartist bureaucracy is turning before our eyes into class struggle: two worlds, two programmes, two moralities. If Thomas thinks that the victory of the socialist proletariat over the infamous caste of oppressors would nct politically and morally regenerate the Soviet regime, he proves only that for all his reservations, shufflings and pious sighs he is far nearer to the Stalinist bureaucracy than to the workers.
Like other exposers of Bolshevik 'immorality, Thomas has simply not grown to the level of revolu-l tionary morality. Trotsky after the
Scan page 8
being shot by Kuomintang soldiers on the outskirts of Shanghai in April 1927.
When Leon Trotsky died in 1940, the world was divided into rival imperialist blocks, at war to redivide the world. In the first quarter century after his death those capitalist-imperialist blocks were broken up. Colonialism retreated. The sort of questions dealt with by Trotsky in this letter existed mainly as questions about the attitude of socialists to Stalinist-led anti-imperialist movements, for example, in Today, the conflict in the Middle East poses such questions to us again. Plainly a text of Trotsky's, 53 years old, cannot tell us anything directly about the Middle East in 1990 - Saddam Hussein is not Chiang Kai-shek, nor is the USA now in the same position to Iraq and the Arab world as Japan to China in 1937.
But there are, plainly, major elements now of old-fashioned economic imperialism in what America is doing. Trotsky can't analyse this concrete situation for us, we must do it for ourselves. Texts like the following help teach us how to make such an analysis, that is how to think as Marxists... Dear Comrade Diego Rivera:
During the past few days I D have been reading some of the lucubrations of the Ochlertites and the Eiffelites (yes, there is a tendency of that sort!) on the civil war in Spain and on the Sino-Japanese War.
Lenin called the ideas of these people "infantile disorders" . A sick child arouses sympathy. But twenty years have passed since then. The children have become bearded and even bald. But they have not ceased their childish babblings. On the contrary, they have increased all their faults and all their foolishness tenfold and have added ignominies to them. They follow us step by step. They borrow some of the elements of our analysis. They distort these elements without limit and counterpose them to the rest. They correct us. When we draw a human figure they add a deformity. When it is a woman they decorate her with a heavy moustache. When we draw a rooster, they put an egg under it. And they call all this burlesque Marxism and Leninism.
I want to stop to discuss in this letter only the Sino-Japanese War. In my declaration to the bourgeois press, I said that the duty of all the workers' organisations of China was to participate actively and in the front lines of the present war against Japan, without abandoning, for a single moment, their own program and independent activity. But that is "social partriotism""! the Effelites cry. It is capitulation to Chiang Kai-shek! It is the abandonment of the principle of the class struggle! Bolshevism preached revolutionarv defeatism in the imperialist war. Now, the war in Spain and the Sino-Japanese war are both imperialist wars. "Our position onthe war in China is the same. The only salvation of the workers and peasants of China is to struggle independently against the two armies, against the Chinese army in the same manner as against the Japanese army." These four lines, taken from an Eiffelite document of September 10, 1937, suffice enrirely for us to say: we are concerned here with either real traitors or complete imbeciles. But imbecility, raised to this degree, is equal to treason.
We do not and never have put all wars on the same plane. Marx and Engels supported the revolutionry struggle of the Irish against Great Britain, of the Poles against the Tsar, even though in these two nationalist wars the leaders were, for the most part, members of the bourgeoisie and even at times of the feudal arıstocracy... at all events, Catholic reactionaries. When Abdel Krim rose up against France, the democrats and Social Democrats spoke with hate of the struggle of a "savage tyrant" against the "democracy" . The party of Leon Blum supported this point of view. But we, Marxists and Bolsheviks, considered the stuggle of the Riffians against imperialist domination as a progressive war. Lenin wrote hundreds of pages demonstrating the primary necessity of distinguishing between imperialist nations and the colonial and semi-colonial nations which comprise the great majority of humanity. To speak of "revolutionary defeatism" in general, without distinguishing between exploiter and exploited countries, is to make a miserable caricature of Bolshevism and to put that caricature at the service of the imperialists.
In the Far East we have a classic example. China is a semi-colonial country which Japan is transforming, under our very eyes, into a colonial country. Japan's stuggle is imperialist and reactionary. China's struggle is emancipatory and progressive.
But Chiang Kai-shek? We need have no illusions about Chiang Kai-shek, his party, or the whole ruling lass of China, just as Marx nd Engels had no illusions about the ruling classes of Ireland and Poland. Chiang Kai-shek is the executioner of the Chinese workers and peasants. But today he is forced, despite himself, to struggle against Japan for the remainder of the independence of China. Tomorrow he may again betray. It is possible. It is probable. It is even inevitable. But today he is struggling. Only cowards, scoundrels, or complete imbeciles can refuse to particpate in that struggle:
Let us use the example of a strike to clarify the question. We do not support all strikes. It, for example, a strike is called for the exclusion of Negro, Chinese, or Japanese workers from a factory, we are opposed to that strike. But if a strike aims at bettering - insofar as it can - the conditions of the workers, we are the first to participate in it, whatever the leadership. In the vast majority of strikes, the leaders are retormists, traitors by profession, agents of capital. They oppose every strike. But from time to time the pressure of the masses or of the objective situation forces them into the path of struggle.
Let us imagine, for an instant, a worker saying to himself: "I do not want to participate in the strike because the leaders are the agents of capital". This doctrine of this ultraleft imbecile would serve to brand him by his real name: a strikebreaker. The case of the Sino-Japanese War, is from this point of view, entirely analogous. If Japan is an imperialist country and if China is the victim of imperialism, we favour China. Japanese patriotism is the hideous mask of worldwide robbery. Chinese patriotism is legitimate and progressive. To place the two on the same plane and to speak of "social patriotism" can be done only by those who have read nothing of Lenin, who have understood nothing of the attitude of Bolsheviks during the imperialist war, and who can be compromised and prostitute the teachings of Marxism. The Eiffelites have heard that the social patriots accuse the internationalists of being the agents of the enemy and they tell us: "You are doing the same thing. " In a war between two imperialist countries, it is a question neither of democracy nor of national independence, but of the oppression of backward nonimperialist peoples. In such a war the two countries find themselves on the same historical plane. The revolutionaries in both armies are defeatists. But Japan and China are not on the same historical plane.
The victory of Japan will signify the enslavement of China, the end of the economic and social development, and the terrible strengthening of Japanese imperialism. The victory of China will signify, on the contrary, the social revolution in Japan and the free development, that is to say unhindered by external oppression of the class struggle in But can Chiang Kai-Shek assure the victory? I do not believe so. It is he, however, who began the war and who today directs it. To be able to replace him it is necessary to gain decisive influence among the proletariat and in the army, and to do this it is necessary not to remain suspended in the air but to place oneself in the midst of the struggle. We must win influence and prestige in the military struggle against the foreign invasion and in the political struggle against the weaknesses, the deficiencies and the internal betrayal. At a certain point, which we cannot fix in advance, this political opposition can and must be transformed into armed conflict, since the civil war, like war generally, is nothing more than the continuation of the political struggle. It is necessary, however, to know when and how to transform political opposition into armed insurrection.
During the Chinese revolution of 1925-27 we attacked the policies of the Comintern. Why? It is necessary to understand well the reasons: The Fiffelites claim that we have changed our attitude on the Chinese question. That is because the poor fellows have understood nothing of our attitude in 1925-7. We never denied that it was the duty of the Communist Party to participate in the war of the bourgeoisie and . petty bourgeoisie of the South against the generals of the North, agents of foreign imperialism. We never denied the necessity of a military bloc between the CP and the Kuomintang. On the contrary, we were the first to propose We demanded, however, that the CP maintain its entire political and organisational independence, that is, that during the civil war against the internal agents of imperialism, as in the national war against foreign imperialism, the working class, while remaining in the front lines of the military struggle, prepare the political overthrow of the bourgeoisie. We hold the same policies in the present war. We have not changed our attitude one iota. The Oehlerites and the Eiffelites, on the other hand, have not understood a single bit of our policies, neither those of 1925-7, nor those of today.
In my declaration to the bourgeois press at the beginning of the recent conflict between Tokyo and Nanking, I stressed above all the necessity of the active participation of revolutionary workers in the war against the imperialist oppressors. Why did I do it? Because first of all it is correct from the Marxist point of view; because, secondly, it was necessary from the point of view of the welfare of our friends in China. Tomorrow the GPU, which is in alliance with the Kuomintang (as with Negrin in Spain), will represent our Chinese friends as being "defeatists" and agents of Japan. The best of them, with Ch-en Tu-hsiu at the head, can be nationally and internationally compromised and killed. It was necessary to stress, energetically, that the Fourth International was on the side of China against Japan. and I added at the same time: without abandoning either their program or their independence The Eiffelite imbeciles try to jest about this "reservation" "The Trotskyists" they say, "Want to serve Chiang Kai-shek in action and the proletariat in words." To participate actively and consciously in the war does not mean "to serve Chiang Kai-shek" but to serve the independence of a colonial country in spite of Chiang Kai-shek. And the words directed against the Kuomintang are the means of educating the masses for the overthrow of Chiang Kai-shek. In participating in the military struggle under the orders of Chian Kai-shek since unfortunately it is he who has the command in the war for independence — to prepare politically the overthrow of Chiang Kai-shek.. that is the only revolutionary policy. The Eiffelites counterpose the policy of "class struggle" to this "nationalist and social patriotic" policy. Lenin fought the abstract and sterile opposition all his life. To him, the interests of the world proletariat dictated the duty of aiding oppressed peoples in their national and patriotic struggle against imperialism. Those who have not yet understood that, almost a quarter of a century after the World War and twenty years after the October revolution, must be pitilessly relected as the worst enemies on the inside by the revolutionary vanguard. | This is exactly the case with Eiffel and his kind!
Leon Trotsky
----- pull-quotes -----
tament forty-three years conscious life I have
and consequently an days ot my youth. has just come up to
freely int air may enter more treely into n see the briaht