Why the Palestinians cheer Saddam
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-08-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
resurgence. The more he is attacked, the more that resurgence will intensify and spread.
If he should survive, he will be the champion of Arab nationalism that Nasser was in the '50s and '60s. If he loses, he will be its martyr, leaving the ground alight under the US Army's feet behind him.
That alone is sufficient argument against what the US is doing. It is doubtful that the US leaders knew what they were stirring up. hussein?
No! Iraq is a sub-imperialist power, competing with its former sponsor the US. Even if the Arab could be united around the 17 million strong Iraqi state (there are 200 million Arabs, 50 million of them in Egypt), it would be like the Prussian unification of Germany in 1871: socialists and democrats would accept it, but fight the political regime. In fact that unity is impossible. Even after facing down Britain and France at Suez in 1956, Nasser couldn't unite the Arabs around Egypt, which already had a quarter of all Arabs.
Not his demagogy about Arab unity, nor even a real leadership of most of the divided Arab people, would make Saddam Hussein and his Ba'athist military regime other than a bitter enemy of socialists and democrats, especially Arab socialists and democrats, The socialist who gives any credence to Saddam Hussein is no longer a socialist.
The only support we owe Saddam Hussein and his regime is support if they fight for Iraqi self-determination against an American imperialist invasion or blitzkrieg.
Such support would not mean any political endorsement for Saddam Hussein, or any let-up in the Iraqi workers' struggle against him (compare Trotsky's argument on the Chinese workers and Chiang Kai-shek, on page 8 of this issue). And even an American blitzkrieg would not legitimise the attempt of Iraqi sub-imperialism to grab control of 56 per cent of the world's oil.
To forget that is to go from opposition to our own imperialism, and support for the right of self-determination of the Iraqis and of the Arabs, to positive support for Iraq's government and its Kuwaiti adventure. It is to transform ourselves into an appendage of Iraqi policy.
it is like the position of Neil Kinnock towards the British ruling class and the US - only inside out. Whereas Kinnock fawns to his masters in London and Washington, we would fawn to the enemies of our ruling class's enemies. • Nevertheless Saddam Hussein is now "objectively anti-imperialist.
That is what Socialist Worker says. But he isn't! And pan-Arab nationalism is not really anti-imperialist either!
Socialists should support the unithemselves wish it. The achievement Arab people if they of such unity would be progressive be forced by events to give specific and limited support to him against, for example, an attempt to occupy Irag. The real anti-imperialist programme in the Middle East today is the programme of working class action, and the real revolutionary unifier of the Arabs is the creation of the Socialist United States of the There is another aspect. Where Nasser and earlier pan-Arabists falists too. Much of the fundamentalists' "anti-imperialism" - that of the Iranian mullahs, too - is a rabid hostility to the modern world for religious reasons. Socialists can only be completely hostile to such an outlook. • Why then givé Saddam Hussein sub-imperialist lraq any support at all, in any circumstances? Socialists do not support one imperialism against another.
A sub-imperialism is an aspirant regional imperialism, usually client or semi-client of a fully-developed imperialist state Argentina and Brazil in South America, Then ira, in the Middle Eastn- and In the course of its overambitious contest with the US in the region, Iraq, so recently a colony, may find itself faced with conquest and subjugation. The sub-imperialist drive can collapse into its opposite.
When Iraq confronts the US, the imperialism in that of the US, whose role may and probably will continue in the region even if it sees off Saddam Hussein; and Iraq has already begun to play a role in the region - however demagogically -of a champion for the Arab masses of pan-Arab nationalism. Socialists have no interest in seeing Iraq subjugated or pulverised.
It is different from the Falklands war. Argentina was not threatened, and was never likely to be threatened, with invasion, subjugation, or a blitzkrieg from the air. • Socialist Organiser supports Israel's right to exist. A united and victorious Arab people would challenge that right forcefully. We cannot be both for Arab unity and for Israel's right to exist.
The right of the Arabs to unite - and to be free from foreign conquest - cannot be conditional on their acceptance of Israel. The question is how the Arabs can unite. Socialists advocate a democratic — and not a "Prussian" -Iraqi' unification, and Arab acceptance of the national rights of minority nations in the region such as the Kurds and Israeli Jews. • What should we do in Britain?
Oppose the war propaganda. Demand that Britain pulls out. Demand that Parliament is recalled immediately. Call Neil Kinnock to account for his belly-crawling to Thatcher and the Tory warmongers who hope to reap an electoral benefit from the Middle East of the sort they got from the Falklands war in 1982. Adam Keller, editor L'The Othor Issee!', -spoke to SO about reactions in the Middle East to the Kuwait crisis There is a big rise in Arab nationalism. The whole idea of pan-Arabism, which has been dormant for the past two decades since the death of Nasser, has suddenly come alive.
I think there are two basic reasons. First of all, there is widespread hatred of the regimes of Saudi Arabia and the Gulf Emirates in the Arab world - especially among the Palestinians. There are hundreds of thousands of Palestinians working as guest workers in those states, where they have been treated as second-class citizens by Kuwait and the other Emirates. There was a spontaneous burst of support for Saddam Hussein because he overthrew the Kuwaiti regime.
Occupation is occupation! The conquest and occupation of a territory against the will of its people is definitely contrary to the internationally accepted norms which have recently been reconfirmed by the UN Security Council.
The occupation of Kuwait by the Iraqi army deserves to be strongly condemned. But such condemnations become ridiculous when voiced by a government which at the same time maintains the military occupation of the West Bank and Gaza Strip.
During the past two years the Israeli government has rejected all peace initiatives and proposals for negotiations; it refused to make even the smallest steps towards a solution. During the past two years, PLO speakers have, again and again, called upon Israel to start peace negotiations; these proposals were all rejected out of hand, and the occupation continued. Among Palestinians despair and fury grew; it was the Israeli governThe Palestinians also feel that the status quo in the Middle East is working against them. The status quo is that they are on the bottom and have no rights.
For the last two years they have had high hopes that they would get something from the Americans. But nothing has come out of the diplomatic process.
The Palestinians feel frustrated. The intifada was stagnating. There was more and more despair inside the occupied territories. And then suddenly comes Saddam Hussein!
Among the Palestinians, the lower down the social scale you go the more support you find for Saddam Hussein. The leadership of the intifada has some reservations about Saddam Hussein, but the poor people are undoubtedly on his side._ The demonstrations in the West Bank and the Arab countries were not spontaneous, but I think that the mood which they captured came from below.
The Hamasq — that's the Islamic movement in the occupied territories, which has made itself the competitor of the PLO - was silent at the beginning because there were rumours that they used to get funment itself that drove the Palestinians into Saddam Hussein's arms.
The Kuwait crisis should be solved peacefully, without a flare-up which could set the whole Middle East on fire. If attacked, Israel has the right to defend itself, but Israel has no interest in supporting dangerous adventures. In particular, Israel must avoid military intervention in Jordan, under whatever pretext; such an intervention would have immeasurably destructive consequences.
At this time of difficult and dangerous crisis we must extend our hand to the Palestinian people; an Israeli peace initiative is more than ever required. Contrary to what Shamir and his ministers would like to believe, the Palestinian problem is not, and will not be, off the regional or global agenda. The unified opposition of the international community to conquest and occupation of territories is a ray of hope, and is bound to have consequences also for the future of Israel and the territories under its occupation.
The Israeli Council Palestinian Peace, ding from Kuwait. Then they got pressure from their grassroots and they suddenly came out also in favour of Saddam Hussein and even declared a general strike in favour of Iraq. -I understand why the Palestinians take this position, though myself I don't feel I could support Saddam Hussein. My position, and more or less the position of the Jewish members of my party, is that we understand why the Palestinians take this position, and we do not join in the wild denunciations of them made by some Zionist leftists, but we ourselves do not share the enthusiasm for Iraq.
My party, the Progressive List for Peace, is in a big crisis because our Arab members are very much in favour of Saddam Hussein.
In Israel there is a strong demand to have gas masks because of the threat by Saddam Hussein to use chemical weapons.
The official position of the army is that they have gas masks ready, but the time has not yet come to distribute them.
Will there be gas masks for the Palestinians? It's not clear, especially in the occupied territories, where the people are not Israeli citizens. But the Palestinians will be hit as well if there is a chemical attack on Israel especially Palestinians who are working in Israeli cities.
The prospects, I think, depend very much on how stable the regime of King Hussein is. As long as King Hussein is more or less in control, I think Israel will not become involved even if the Americans start a war with Iraq.
But the government has declared that the entry of Iraqi forces into Jordan would be a catastrophe for Israel - and they would respond by war on Iraq. This position is shared by a very large part of the left, by the Zionist left you could say.
So if King Hussein is overthrown, or his regime is weakened, or there is a civil war in Jordan, or the Iraqis are called on by some faction in Jordan to intervene, that could lead to warThe US is urging Israel to do nothing, because Saddam Hussein is trying to present the conflict as something involving Israel to help him get support in the Arab world and to discredit the Arab states which support the US.
In fact, what some people in the Israeli government are starting to be afraid of if that this situation will discredit the Israeli claim that Israel is a strategic asset for the US.
Also there are fears in govern ment circles, and hopes on the left that the combined action Turn to page 9
----- pull-quotes -----
of Kuwait! Iraq out Israel out of t of the occupied territories!