Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The issues in the Gulf

Socialist Organiser no. 458, 23 August 1990 · scan pp. 3–4 · about 1,936 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

EDIITIORIAL From page 1 American leaders are openly preparing for war!

The British government continues to pretend that it believes that there can be a peaceful victory. Its talk may indicate private differences with the Americans; but when war comes Britain will be in the thick of it — and without even a pretence at a prior democratic decision in Parliament. The Labour leaders are too busy echoing Mrs Thatcher and President Bush to even demand the immediate recall of Parliament!

The British working class is being subjected to an immense barrage of blatant war propaganda about new Hitlers, hostages, Arab madmen, and gallant little Kuwait. With war on a scale not known since Vietnam looming, socialists should be clear about what is happening and why. In this as in all wars and build-ups to war, truth is the first casualty • Is it a matter of the UN acting to deal with an aggressor before he gets too powerful?

No, it isn't. The ideal of a world government that can act to stop wars and to right wrongs is an attractive one. The UN isn't it; and if it is, there are wrongs far worse than the invasion of Kuwait for it to deal with. The plight of the Kurdish nation, which has been butchered for decades by Iran and Iraq, is a case in point. So is the Palestinian Arabs' demand for Israel to get out of the West Bank and Gaza. The UN rightly condemned the Iraqi annexation of Kuwait. It then declared an economic boycott of Iraq. Then the US turned the economic boycott into a naval blockade, and started a build-up of forces in Saudi Arabia.

Economic sanctions, to be effective, need military and naval force. But the UN did not decide on force. The US did. The US seized on the UN vote and turned it into something else.

The idea of a UN-regulated democratic world is a good one. In practice the UN has just served as a stepping stone for US aggression. • Why did the US move as it has done?

Because of oil. Because it wants to keep as much control as it can of the oil supplies of the Gulf sheikhdoms, of which Kuwait was one, and of Iraq.

It felt able to act as it did, with brutal old-fashioned imperialist vigour, because the collapse of the USSR's empire and of the USSR's international pretentions gave the US a freedom of action it has not had for decades; and because the militant expansionism of the Iraqi state so alarmed many other Arab states that they are, for now, willing to invite the US to help them put The emancipation of the working class is also the emancipation of all human beings without distinction of or race?

Karl Marx Socialist Organiser PO Box 823 London SE15 4NA Newsdesk: 071-639 7965 Latest date for reports: first post Monday blished by WL Publications Ltd Box 823, London SE15 4NA Printed by Press Link International (UK) Ltd (TU)

Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office Signed articles do not acessarily reflect the views of Socialist Organiser Iraq, the Arabian Prussia.

Many of those Arab states are client states of the US even the biggest of them, Egypt — and many of them depend heavily on subsidies trom Saudi Arabia.

Why did Britain and the other big powers support the US?

sufficient now, but not for longel East And because the US has increased in world status and weight after the collapse of the USSR's empire, and can exert pressure on them. • Why did Iraq invade Kuwait?

Because Iraq is almost bankrupt after waging an eight-year war against Iran for territory and prestige. In that war the West. and Kuwait and Saudi Arabia helped to arm and finance Iraq.

Iraq seized the oil wealth in Kuwait as a means of escape from bankruptcy. • Should we call for Iraqi withdrawal from Kuwait?

Yes. *Self-determination for Kuwait" is a different question, Apart from Egypt, all the Arab states are artificially drawn, including Iraq. For centuries their area was united within the Turkish Empire. The Arabs have a common language, culture and identity. The existing states were created after World War 1 by France and Britain, the controlling imperialist powers which replaced defeated The Gulf sheikhdoms were deliberately fostered in the 19th century to enable Britain to control the seas, and have been nursed into the late 20th century to allow the imperialist powers to have safe access to the oil in the area. They are ruled by feudal relics out of the Middle Ages Iraq has a long-standing claim to Kuwait. In 1961 British troops landed there to forestall a threatened Iraqi invasion. And Kuwait is an artificial unit not just historically.

The Kuwaitis are less than half the population. They form a sort of rentier caste, while the work is done by migrant workers. Many of those migrant workers are Palestinians, who hate the Kuwaiti elite as exploiters. The exploited workers are reported to have looted the shops in Kuwait City after the Iraqi invasion.

That does not give the Iraqi dictatorship the right to invade. But opposition to the invasion does not legitimise the old order in Kuwait, or make the old regime there, which the Americans and British propped up and now want to restore, other than a grotesque anachronism.

We would not necessarily be against a democratic Iraq - let alone a socialist Iraq — annexing Kuwait. But not this murderous Iragi regime!

A parallel is the Saarland in western Germany, cut off from Germany against the will of its German people after World War Socialists opposed and denounced that cutting off. In 1935 a referendum was held to decide whether the Saar people would "go back" to Germany.

But this was Hitler's Germany; where the labour movement was pulverised. Trotsky, who had denounced the original Franco-British cutting off of the Saar, argued that something higher than the German national principle was at stake, the rights of the Saar workers, and callled for a no vote in the referendum.

And in this case there is no special national principle between Kuwait and Iraq as distinct from other Arab states. •Why is the USSR, Iraq's ally and armourer, almost silent?

The USSR is in a tremendous crisis. It suffered collapse in its competition with the US. Its rulers Iraqi tanks in attitude the conflict?

are now trying to restore capitalism there and hope for aid from the West. The USSR has dropped its pretentions to a world imperialist role, for now.

Was its previous role therefore a good thing? No! Ask the napalmed victims in Afghanistan, or the people of Eastern Europe! But one imperialist bloc may inhibit another, and the USSR's collapse has given the US an immense new freedom. • Why shouldn't the US stop Iraq cornering 56 per cent of the world's oil?

Why not indeed! Equally, in a world of power politics, why shouldn't Iraq try to corner it? Why shouldn't Japan resent the fact that the landing of US forces in Arabia gives the US a tremendous hold on much of the world's oil supplies?

The point is that the US acts here despite all its pious words — as a player in the naked competition of states for power and resources.

US control of Saudi Arabia and Kuwait is a great deal more artificial and against the grain of the local, Arab, people's wishes, than control by Arab Iraq. That is why Saddam Hussein has been able so successfully to appeal to millions of Arabs against the US landings. • But the US is not "occupying" Saudi Arabia. It is engaged in a limited policing operation. It will soon withdraw.

Not so. Even George visers openiy taik about US troops continuing in Saudi Arabia into election year, 1992, and beyond. Even if the US brings down Saddam Hussein, the signs are that the Saudi regime has already been destabilised. There is great Arab resentment at those Arabs who invited in the 'infidel imperialists" • Pan-Arab nationalism, dormant for 20 years, is already a force across the jigsaw of Arab states.

Even if Saddam Hussein is toppled, the forces of Arab nationalism unleashed by the US occupation will be a threat to those regimes on which the West depends to control the oil areas. Whatever happens to Iraq, the forces unleashed by the US landing may make continued occupation necessary to secure America's interests.

In 1984 the US was driven out of Lebanon by such militant Arab tactics as suicide bombings. Continued US occupation would evoke such things again. This time the US could not retreat, because the economic purpose the military occupation serves is central to US interests.

Widespread open war is possible. The combination of the political situation in the Arab world, the effect on its Arab allies of the US landing, and the vital nature of the economic interests involved, could involve the US - and its allies - in a new, protracted, Vietnam-type war in the years ahead.

Even on the most optimistic scenario, this is no quick in and out police operation. • But the hostages...

Saddam Hussein is a murdering tyrant in the Hitler-Stalin mould. He will use any weapon he can find. His use of civilian hostages to inhibit US attack is business as usual for the man who gasses his own people (with the silent acquiescence of the West, which supported his regime!)

But we should not fall for war propaganda about the hostages. Saddam Hussein is trying to use the hostages to stop devastating air attacks which would kill and maim countless Iraqis. It is not for those who are even now preparing such attacks to be so self-righteous about Saddam Hussein's barbarous treatment of the foreign hostages. • Saddam Hussein claims to represent Arab nationalism. Does he?

Yes and no. The Arabs across 20 states claim to be one nation. They blame imperialism for their division. They see the imperialistprotected feudal entities like Kuwait and Saudi Arabia as part of the imperialist carve-up of the area.

The Arabs have been unable to unit. The attempted unification of Egypt and Syria in 1958-61 proved Turn to page four

Scan page 4

low difficult Arab unıty Is b chieve. Yet the Arabs have thi right to aspire to unity, and to have the support of socialists against any obstruction by the imperialist powers.

Saddam Hussein has appealed to that aspiration with great success. It especially the disaffected, the poor and the dispossessed Palestinians who rally to the call of Arab nationalism. They see Arab unity as something almost mystical which will solve all their social problems (it wouldn't!).

Saddam Hussein acted as a pirate, aggrandising the Iraqi state. The US response has made him the champion of an Arab nationalist n part because it would clear the ninds of the Arab working clas and help them to deal with their own ruling classes. But popular ban-Arab nationalism today is an deological system which ties the working class to the petty bourgeoisie and sections of the bourgeoisie.

The crimes of the imperialist powers against the Arabs are many and they are great. But it is the Arab ruling classes that control the Arab states today, and it is the Arab ruling class that perpetuate division.

To accept as even provisional good coin, for now, the anti-imperialism of Saddam Hussein is to betray the Arab workers and peasants, especially when we may Palestinians with portrait of Saddam

----- pull-quotes -----

The issues in th page three

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 458

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →