Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Why won't the SWP debate?

Socialist Organiser no. 457, 16 August 1990 · scan pp. 10–11 · about 1,065 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

am alarmed by the increas ingly anti-democratic practices of the Socialist Workers' Party.

Supporters of other groups are barred from their meetings and events, or left forlornly waving their hands as the chair crassly ignores their right to speak.

Less than a month before Neil Kinnock banned Socialist Organiser from the Labour Party, the SWP had expelled SO supporters from "Marxism '90" I have even seen young, or new, SWP members told by their "seniors" not to buy the publications of other groups or to talk to their members!

They refuse resolutely every challenge to debate with other left groups, arrogantly pretending that theirs are the only socialist ideas and that everyone else is "irrelevant". Studiedly avoiding clear and comradely debate, their political discourse with groups such as Socialist Organiser is confined to one-sided rants. If you are not the sort of person who practises that aggressive, confrontational style, and try in vain to get a word in edgeways, then tough you are waved aside in self-satisfied triumph.

Many who come across the SWP are put ott socialist ideas, while those who join are trained in narrow-mindedness, dogma and sectarianism.

The SWP would do well to study the way in which Stalin destroyed the Bolshevik Party, before they suffer a similar fate themselves. And they should heed warnings about "substitutionism" before they convince themselves that they are the labour movement, and that socialism will be created by the SWP alone. - find it genuinely frightening that one of the largest avowedly Marxist organisations in Britain is stifling ideas and democracy in this way. It is potentially very damaging to the left, and to the prospects for socialism. They are pulling socialists out of the labour movement just when it needs them most.

Janine Booth, "Işlington.

Scan page 11

ick to the future with orman, Alan and John A difficult to predict the simple soul like me finds it impact of Saddam Hussein on the next British general Has he done Mrs Thatcher a big favour, handing her a heaven-sent opportunity to demonstrate the need for resolute leadership and a tooled-up "defence' capability; or will he send oil prices and inflation rocketing, thus sabotaging John Major's pre-election economic miracle?

Either way, the Gulf crisis can only confirm the strategists at both Walworth Road and Congress House in their view that a crucial factor at the next election will be the public's perception of Labour's ability to run the economy 'responsibly", hold down inflation better than the Tories and keep union militancy in check.

In this context, it may be a coincidence that two documents, 'A New Agenda' and 'Managing the Economy: Towards 2000' appeared just as Hussein was barging into Kuwait. But it was not a co-incidence that both these snappilytitled pamphlets have come out in the run-up to this year's TUC Congress and that both propose virtually the same solutions to Britain's economic ills: words like 'partnership' , 'consensus'; and even "tripartite' abound.

To those of us who remember the "70s and the glorious Wilson/Callaghan administrations, talk of a 'National Economic Assessment', a 'National Wages Accord' and a National Economic Development Office' will also sound very familiar. We've been here before, haven't we? Only last time they called it the "Social Contract'.

These exciting new proposals come to you courtesy of the TUC economic committee ('Towards 2000') and the dynamic duo of John Edwards and Alan Tuffin ("New Agenda'). Both pamphlets are full of the usual guff about the need for better training, "investment in people', R and D, joining the ERM and all the other standard catch-phrases of "modern' trade unionism. But at the heart of both lies the idea of pay negotiations being determined by 'a public discussion between the government, CBI and TUC of Britain's economic prospects' ("New Agenda') or if your prefer, a National Economic Assessment involving trade unions, employers and the government' ("Towards 2000").

Edmonds and Tuffin go on to invoke the centralised bargaining systems of Japan and West Germany with the twist that, "our fight against inflation could be strengthened if more of our major negotiations were concentrated in the first three months of the year" , with the government then stepping into directly determine wage settlements for certain very low paid sectors, at the end of the pay round.

The Financial Times was very impressed by both documents ("some of the phrases they use... would sit well in a company report") but warned of a difficulty: "to persuade their colleagues in the labour movement that their plans are different from the incomes policies of the 1970s which brought so much opprobrium, and arguably electoral defeat on the Labour government"

Precisely l Meanwhile, with the Hussein wild card likely to send inflation spiralling past that magic 10% mark, how will rank and file trade unionists react to proposals for a re-run of the Social Contract? Alan Tuffin's members in British Telecom, for instance, have just turned down an 8.8% offer and seem unimpressed by talk of "Britain's need to stay cost competative with leading European partners... with unavoidable consequences for bargaining and pay levels"

But, like me, they are simple souls who may take a little persuading before they appreciate the benefits of The New Agenda.

Job McLoughlin, branch RACO, S of Bury NALGO, is beins 1 witch-hunted by right wingers inside the union.

He has been accused of sexual harassment by the full time Branch Ad ministrator. The accusations have been used by the press and political opponents inside the union to smear him without a fair hearing.

Around Bury Town Hall a bulletin entitled 'NALGO members beware' has been using the issue as part of an organised campaign against Rob McLoughlin.

The accusations of sexual harassment coincided with the launch of a campaign by a section of the branch executive against Rob McLoughlin and other branch officers over their opposition to the poll tax.

Bury NALGO have consistently opposed the national union leaders position on the poll tax. They have helped organise support for a 'Don't Pay, Don't Collect' position. Bury NALGO has been in dispute over the pay and editor boa impi ball ar ardian y cure tri Middle not do be very s can be ffairs -n dictato ,ed. foreign adership gners ete Gulf : above wildest d mestic se of pr o simply e past interest

----- pull-quotes -----

NSIDE By Sleeper

in Bury Tony

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 457

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →