Iraq and Israel
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-08-16Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
The hard left will naturally oppose the US occupation of Saudi Arabia. But many -the SWP for example — will go from that to positive support for Iraq.
And beyond that they will go on to uncritical cheerleading for Arab nationalism, especially if, as seems likely there is a big upsurge of nationalist feeling.
It is already normal for large sections of the left to sport the most extreme of Arab chauvinist attitudes to Israel, calling for Israel's destruction long after the PLO has acknowledged Israel's right to exist. But any idea of Arab unity which does not include the right of minorities - like the Jews an Kurds — to self-determination, is the vilest chauvinism.
Israel's right to exist must be *The emancipation of the working class is also the emancipation of all human beings without distinction of sex or race!
Karl Marx Socialist Organice:
PO Box 823London SE15 4NA NEwsdesk: 071-639 7965 Latest date for oporte: first defended; so must the right of the Palestinian Arabs to a state in the West Bank and Gaza. The most telling of Saddam Hussein's demagogy has been the damning contrast he has pointed to between the West's concern for Kuwait and its lack of concern for the Palestinians. Of course, the Iraqi butcher does not add to this list the West's lack of concern about his own repression of the Kurds!
Widespread gas attacks that could devastate Israel are a serious possibility; so is an Israeli nuclear retaliation. The ultra-right in Israel could seize on a war to attempt to drive out the Palestinian Arabs from the West Bank.
All of this stems from the chronic antagonism between Israel and the Arabs, The only solution is Arab recognition of Israel, and Israeli acceptance of the Palestinian Arabs' right to their own state where they are the big majority, in the West Bank and Gaza.
post Monday.
Published by WL Publications Ltd PO Box 823, London SE15 4NAPrinted by Press Link International (UK) Ltd (TU)
Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office Signed articles do not necessarily reflect the views of Socialist Organiser
Scan page 5
Sanctions are not an alternative to military action, but just another Many people who the hypocritical double standards displayed by Bush and Thatcher and who oppose military interven tion against Iraq, are nevertheless looking to economic sanctions as way of solving the Gulf crisis.
Tony Benn MP gives voice to that view in this week's SO.
Very often the impulse to support UN sanctions comes from the understandable desire to see that something is done to redress the injustice of the Iraqi occupation of Kuwait. But sanctions cannot be supported.
It is not possible in the current crisis to separate out military action and sanctions as two distinct and different options.
As we go to press (on Tuesday 14 August) the US and Britain are set to use military measures, the boarding of Iraqi tankers and other shipping to enforce economic sanctions. Such actions could quite quickly lead to military retaliation from Iraq.
In fact, part of the US's tactics in the Gulf are to corner Saddam -through sanctions and military encirclement - in the hope that he will lash out, thus presenting the US, Brien't side of the same coin tain and the allies with an excuse for full scale military intervention.
A unified, post cold war, United Nations sanctions campaign is not, in reality, an alternative to Thatcher, Bush and Mitterrand's gun boat diplomacy in defence of oil supplies.
The two are two sides of the same coin. Sanctions are not at all the peacetul solution that many imagine. Either they are futile gestures, or the! imply the threat of military action to enforce them.
And even if it were possible to separate out sanctions from war, the human consequences of effective economic sanctions for the people of Iraq would be bad. Thatcher and Bush's sanctions are an attempt to starve the entire Iraqi people into submission, to make 18 million Iraqis pay nswer for the actions of Saddam's totalitarian regime.
How many people would have of starvation before Saddam capitulated? Is the 'new Hitler' going to roll over and die as soon as the first hunger marches and protests start in Iraq? Of course not.
Even if sanctions dislodged Saddam, any successor who came to power in circumstances controlled by the great powers Is unlikely to care much for the interests of the Iraqi people, or to be much less rapacious than Saddam.
Genuine concern for the fate of the people of Kuwait must be separated out from Thatcher and Bush's drive to economically pulverise the people of Iraq. Like fire and water, imperialist sanctions and workers solidarity do not mix.
Tony Benn MP
The sanctions against Iraq, introduced unanimously by the United Nations Security Council, are likely to be effective in forcing Saddam Hussein to withdraw from Kuwait, and should be maintained and tightened, by international action, to compel him to do so.
By contrast, the decision, taken by President Bush and supported by Britain, to send troops to Saudi Arabia, was motivated by his determination to defend United States oil supplies, and American forces will almost certainly stay there long after the immediate crisis has passed, These parallel military operations have not been authorised by the Security Council and may well against the West, and destroy the unity which has been achieved at the UN., The Gulf crisis therefore faces us all with a choice between internationally agreed action, and national military expeditions, and, now that the Cold War is over, we have to decide what sort of a new world order we want to create.
It looks as if there are those, in NATO, who want to go back to the old imperialist days of "gunboat diplomacy" and "colonial wars" under which the rich industrial nations in the north used military force to gain control of the raw materials and the world markets to strengthen their own position.
The alternative is to strengthen the United Nations and use it actively to resist aggression, to campaign for democracy and human rights, and to divert resources from weapons to peaceful development.
This is why the war hysteria which is now being whipped up is so