Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[response to Tribune. shanks for defending Soc ialist…]

Socialist Organiser no. 457, 16 August 1990 · scan p. 3 · Eric Heffer · about 1,568 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

response to Tribune.

shanks for defending Soc ialist Organiser's right tr remain in the Labou Party.

But Paul Anderson (Tribune, August) evidently wrote with hi teeth clenched, in defiance of hi prejudices. That combined with hi article's extreme compression te misrepresent both our politics and what we are. (Some of the history i wrong, too).

For sure, we give support to ne nationalism. But we do support th Palestinian Arabs' claim to nationa rights in the West Bank/Gaza state demanded by the PLO, and we de support their intifada. We breal with the conventional left not or that, but on the question of Israel': right to exist and defend itself.

We reject the left's demonisatior of Israel and Zionism. and the com prehensive political hostility te most Jews alive today that goe! with it. This "anti-imperialism o idiots" was until the recent eruptior in Eastern Europe and the USSR the most vocal form of anti semitism. Many neo-Trotskyists are infected with this specifically "lef wing", form of anti-semitism, but there is nothing Trotskyist about it: it originates with Stalinism in the USSR after 1948, as articles in SC have proved.

Against the British state we support the Six Counties Catholics. We are in favour of a federal united united Ireland and still less a socialist Ireland.

The root problem is the relationship to each other of the two sorts of Irish, made worse by British brutality and partition, which has created a second, artificial, minority in Ireland, the Six Counties Catholics.!

When it carried some risk, or seemed to, I stood up for the Provisional IRA. The only socialist group raided by armed British police for many decades has been Workers' Fight, in which I had a SERI necessary to say what is in Treland and what the Provisional IRA is: a communalist Catholic organisation, and not the socialist organisation some fantasise it is and others (hunting Irish votes in Britain) pretend it James Connolly would, I believe, have recognised neither the socialism nor the Republicanism of the Provisionals.

The common root to these positions is that we recognise that all peoples and fragments of peoples have rights, and we deny the view implicit in the prevalent left Zionistand Protestant-bashing that there is such a thing as a bad people undeserving of collective rights. In that framework we do support the oppressed Catholics and the oppressed Palestinian Arabs.

Paul Anderson needlessly concedes the NEC case for banning SO — no, he endorses and reinforces it from the left - when he says that SO is a "Leninist sect" "with its own rules and discipline* , and then opposes the ban on the grounds that SO is so small it isn't necessary. We are, so to speak, a reptile, but only a little one. To which the NEC might reasonably reply: "So far".

Publicly available evidence, the files of our paper for example, shows that we are not organised as a one-faction "Leninist" sect. SO discipline? In what way do SO's "discipline" and "rules" differ in kind from those of other Labour Party factions, including Kinnockite ones, the LCC for example - except that we are much less secretive and conspiratorial? talking sense. He has said that the original argument was madness, and the American response is madness. And as far as it goes that is quite right. - It seems to me that it is an Arab problem and the Arabs should sit down and discuss it. The US and Britain have set themselves up as some sort of international policeman. You can't think of a spot on the face of the globe where America doesn't send troops and ships and god knows what, and has a say in whether or not what is happening is legitimate or not.

To hear President Bush talk about resisting aggression, when you look at the agression America has been carrying out in the last few years makes the mind boggle.

The Arabs should decide some policy that is going to protect their interests. Of course we have to wait yet for the real background, what Mossad is doing, and what the understand the British sects and what makes them what they are: undemocratic one-faction groups with predesignated leaders and unquestionable dogmas to defend, with the psychology ofnarrow persecuting religious cults.

The changes in SO's politics, and the way we made them, publicly, are the proof that SO does not function as such a group. Anderson is too prejudiced, too busy buttressing the NEC "case" from the left, to notice.

By the way, the NEC ban has not rallied the support of the other Trotskyists" to SO, as Paul Anderson expects. Militant and Socialist Worker have had big reports on the new witch-hunt, but have not mentioned the ban on SO, or protested against it, not even through clenched teeth.

"I do not see any justification for the NEC to ban Socialist Organiser and expel supporters of Socialist Organiser "Socialist Organiser is a paper wit! a very wide and tolerant view. It seems to me this is one further example of what we said at the begining of the witch-hunt: if you begin with one organisation, in the end you attack all of the left." Eric Heffer MP "I want to express my solidarity with those comrades around the Socialist Organiser newspaper at this time when there are attempts to drive you out of the Labour Party. I do not agree with all the views put forward in Socialist Organiser but I recognise principled socialists when I see them. All of us on the left of the Labour Party and in fact all Labour members who want a democratic tolerant broad based Labour Party must unite to resist the expulsion of socialists from the Labour Party." Eddy Newman MEP conquer Israelis intend to do. It is an Arab problem and I don't think we should be involving ourselves.

We have cast off the Empire and those people that have picked the mantle up should be left to sort it out.

t's nice to see that the NUM President is going back on the campaign trail. Our branch at Manton has invited Scargill to address them and he's coming on the 25th of this month. He's got several meetings organised around the coalfield.

The message has to be got over to the membership that they must hear it from the man, and not from the I think it can only do good at this time, when we are facing decisions about a pay rise and possible industrial action.

Paul Whetton is a member of Manton NUM. S. Yorkshire with international affairs - so long as certain requirements can be met, viz:

1. British interests and/or pride at stake.

2. Loony foreign dictator to be reviled and/or ridiculed.

3. Dusky-hued foreign hordes running amok J 4. Mrs Thatcher showing firm grasp and natural leadership qualities while. Kinnock, foreigners etc in blue funk 5. Our Boys (preferably SAS) Going In.

The present Gulf crisis, of course, fulfils all the above criteria beyond Mr McKenzie's wildest dreams; there is even a good domestic price of eggs (or, rather, price of petrol) angle for Sun readers who simply cannot be persuaded to take an interest in funny furrin parts. So for the past week or so the likes of Ms Mandy Smith, Paul "Gazza' Gascoigne, and even the ubiquitous Ninja Turtles, have been ousted from the Sun's front page leads, to be replaced by Iraq and its mustacheod dictator.

But first, the villain of the piece had to be clearly established for Sun readers who up until a week or so ago had probably never heard of Saddam Hussein and who might still labour under the misapprehension Inal Libyan leader Muammar 200211 still occupied the Number One spot in the world's Dangerous Despots charts.

So the Sun helpfully listed, 'in order of evil and madness" the present Top Ten Terrible Tyrants: at Number One, Hussein, "better known as the Butcher of Baghdad. He is stark, staring bonkers, and believes he is a reincarnation of Hitler"; Gaddafi (guarded by commandos and believes Shakespeare was an Arab called Sheikh Speare") drops down to the Number Two spot; at Number Three, "Potty" Pol Pot... and on to Kim Il Sung, Manuel Noriega, Fidel Castro ...with blast from the past Idi Amin just scraping in at Ten.

Hussein's credentials thus established, the Sun felt able to concentrate on details of war preparations (including a fascinating description of the marvellous rubber suit that will protect Our Boys from Hussein's chemical weapons; the only draw-back seems to be that "at temperatures above 70°F the suit can only be worn for up to an hour... the normal summer temperature in the Gulf area is between 110°Fand 115°F").

Then there were other foreigners to be abused: the cowardly French, Germans, Italians and the Japanese; "All this talk about a great European ideal, of friends and allies bound to a common cause is so much codswallop... our only constant friends and reliable allies in the world are the Yanks", raged Friday's By the end of last week, the front page headline was "OUR BOYS GO IN"; how long before the Sun is able to re-live its finest hour with "GOT CHA*?

viSi E1.20 plus 24p posta from SO, PO Box 823 _ondon SE15 ANA.

----- pull-quotes -----

hand, in 1973. But it is also SOCIALL

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 457

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →