Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[pressure from peers and parents. But things will…]

Socialist Organiser no. 456, 2 August 1990 · scan p. 10 · about 985 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

pressure from peers and parents.

But things will soon change.

Hans's father Jakob is a doctor who fought in the first world war. He has assimilated as best he can; he sees himself as German. When a Zionist comes to his home to ring alarm bells Jakob throws him out. He puts his faith in the Germany of Goethe, Schiller and Beethoven.

But the film belittles Jakob by making him ridiculous. This is partly the curse of hindsight; any Jewish character of 1932 who denies the Nazis are a problem is going to seem like a fool to us. However tragic his fate, Jakob is not a real character for us; he's a plot device to underline how the Jews were betrayed by the very German naDifferent versions that lationalism are on show here. There is Jakob's idealistic (and misguided) one. Hans and Konradin subscribe to a pastoral nationalism, following in the steps of the German romantic poets who celebrated the beauty of nature and the German countryside. Konradin later switches to the nationalism of his aristocratic class, who follow Hitler in the hope that he will make Germany great again, that he will exact revenge for the humiliations at Versailles. Konradin regrets what will happen to the Jews, but his belief in Hitler is not shaken by it. The later Hans, played by Robards, will have no truck with anything German. What his father saw as all good, he sees as all bad. ( What lacks COLUMN recent letter to New A Scientist from a scientist in Fiji explains the importance of palaeobotany, the study of prehistoric plants and their environment, to modern society.

The author, curator of the South Pacific Regional Herbarium, writes that palaeobotany provides information about different climates and patterns of vegetation in the past. Remains of long-dead plants may provide a local perspective on the effects of the wider climactic changes known to have occurred as carbon dioxide levels and temperatures varied.

Palaeobotanical studies are likely to be crucial as scientists try to detect and predict the effects of increased COz levels now. This conclusion seems uncontroversial, so why write the letter?

It was, in fact, a protest against recently leaked plans to slash research into palaeobotany at the Natural History Museum (or British Museum (Natural History)). And institution for research on the natural world". According to the museum's five-year "corporate plan" , 20% of the research scientists employed there, up to 100, are to have their jobs cut. These include, for example, ten palaeontologists, seven researchers each from botany and zoology, and nine in mineralogy. Entomology, the study of insects, will lose 17.

For over 100 years the BM(NH) has held a leading place in the natural history of living and extinct plants and animals, Its job of describing and classifying living things, the science of taxonomy, is described by a German critic of the cutbacks as "basis for all biology" He points out that if we don't identity the organisms that exist, we won't know the full extent of the damage being done to the diversity of life on earth.

A Polish woman, now a professor of palaeontology in Norway, sees taxonomy as the basis of genetics, biochemistry and other biological disciplines. And a letter of protest from the curator emeritus at the American Museum Natural History states that the cuts in staff and research, in addition to past cuts (because this is not the first time the BM(NH) has felt the unwelcome attentions of the Tories) museum of its kind in the British Commonwealth".

The corporate plan has unleashed a storm of scientific protest, in the form of letters like the above, petitions, editorials in the science press, and even a protest strike by museum scientists, action not seen since the museum introduced entry charges under pressure from the government (they cost about as much to administer as they raise and have led to massive drops in numbers of visitors).

Readers will realise that an institution of world renown would not voluntarily mutilate itself and, of course, the corporate plan is a direct result of a famine of funds. The museum's grant-in-aid from the government, some f25 million per annum, is to rise by only 4% per annum over the next five years. With inflation at about 10% and unlikely to fall signficantly, this is equivalent to a sizeable cut each Museum director Neil Chalmers estimates a shortfall of f4.4 million over the five years, assuming that wage costs, nearly three-quarters of expenditure, rise by only 6% per annum. This shortfall assumes that some money will be raised from private sources. Chalmers draws the conclusion that, rather than protest at the size of the grant and even resign, he should implement the cuts in the research programme that have now been publicised.

The only alternative he sees is to raise more private sponsorships but, as he points out, the t4 million so far raised is earmarked for exhibitions rather than research. Companies want 'tangible evidence" of their generosity, ie. they want their names to be seen in the best light by millions of visitors, rather than by the thousands who read scientific journals and books.

BM(NH) exhibitions have been successful over the past few years but some have been criticised as aiming for popularity rather than scientific value. Whether true of past exhibitions, the news of the visit of 16 representatives of museum management to Disneyland does not inspire confidence for the future.

Chalmers talks of restricting the museum's research to areas where the science and its human applications are "most important" . But any scientist will tell you that it is impossible to know in advance if a particular line of research will be important. As New Scientist says, the decline in interest in taxonomy, of which the BM(NH) cuts are a symptom, "can only diminish our increasingly important ability to understand the natural едvironment".

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 456

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →