[reviews 'Reunion' eunion' is a puzzling film, of…]
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-08-02Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
reviews 'Reunion' eunion' is a puzzling film, of gaping holes.
Director Jerry Schatzber never gets the tone quite right. It's uneven. We can generally tell what each individual scene is meant to convey, but they never add up to a whole. The film is full of loose ends.
The scriptwriter Harold Pinter may be the problem. Pinter's skill lies in stripping the fat from other people's work, paring it down to the bone. But in 'Reunion', he has removed the connective tissue too. We can't tell what the director was striving for, what message, if any, he wanted to get across.
Most big films these days signal everything; our responses to each scene are orchestrated. 'Reunion" errs the other way; too much is left open and ambiguous. It's frustrating, amorphous.
It's a flashback movie, beginning with the elderly Hans Strauss (Jason Robards) in New York, planning a trip to Stuttgart. These early scenes don't 'place' Hans for us. We don't know why he's going, or what the trip means for him. Robards seems exhausted, enervated, jet lagged before he's even left the ground. Once he's in Stutgart he wanders around, accosting people in English, and we still don't ‹now what he's doing.
Just in time, we flash back to his youth, when Hans, then a 16 year old Jewish schoolboy, meets the aristocratic Konradin von Lohenburg and they become friends. Konradin is still and rather prissy, but the budding friendship is nicely done. The two edge towards each other tentatively, but we can see what the friendship means to each. Luckily for the movie, we can relate to these two, the way we can't to Robards.
The year is 1932, Hitler is soon to come to power, and attacks on Jews are becoming more common. Hans. first feels uneasy about it, then frightened. Konradin sticks by his friend, despite considerable criticism of these differing nationalisms or any perspective on how Hitler could have been opposed; the tone is fatalistic. There is one brief view of a strike, but otherwise the rise of the Nazis is seen as inevitable. In Schatzberg's view the Jews, as represented by Jakob, bury their heads in the sands; the non-Jews, like Konradin, can only gain from a restoration of German supremacy.
Presumably, the tilm is meant to show the bewilderment and confusion the boys felt during that troubled time, when they could not foresee the results of Hitler's rise. But the film is made with hindsight; has the director nothing to say? Is he, almost sixty years later, still as muddled as the boys were then? It's as if nothing has been learned from the Holocaust or from the war. To Schatzberg, Nazism is like a malignant plague; nothing could have stopped its outbreak.
By the time we realise is in Germany to find out what happened to Konradin, we're alert for a big revelation. Did Konradin become a Nazi? If not, did he survive the war? What will Hans find?
But even here, Schatzberg and Pinter fumble the ball. The revelation begs more questions than it answers, and we're cheated of Robards' reaction. Worse, we're still in the dark about why Hans is even trying to find out. Did a vital reel go missing somewhere, or are Pinter and Schatzberg simply incompetent?
The film does have good moments, mostly when the young Hans and Konradin are on the screen. The period detail is nicely done; the film strives to capture the feel of pre-Nazi German life. But this isn't enough to outweigh the very great omissions of plot, motivation and denouement. Schatzberg and Pinter should go back to film school, and take a course in history on the side.
ig The young Hans St