Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Anti-semitism from the '50s to the '80s

Socialist Organiser no. 456, 2 August 1990 · scan pp. 8–9 · about 3,314 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

Stan Crookı his a ccount semi tism in Part 3 next of antiissue.

Stalin's successor Khrushchey memit ie views This own anti-semitic vien on a number of occasions, even if, like his predecessor, he denied the existence of antisemitism in the Soviet Union.

In 1956 he declared: "Should the Jews want to occupy the foremost positions in our republics now, it would naturally be taken amiss by the indigenous inhabitants. The latter would ill receive their pretensions, especially as they do not consider themselves less intelligent or capable than Jews. Or, for instance, when a Jew in Ukraine is appointed to an important post and he surrounds himself with Jewish colleagues, it is understandable that this should create jealousy and hostility towards the Jews. But we are not anti-semites."

In the same year he provided a novel explanation for the absence of Jewish schools and cultural institutions in the Soviet Union (closed down by Stalin shortly before his death): "As far as Jews are concerned, even if Jewish schools were estabished, would be found willing to attend few volunteers them. The Jews are dispersed over the whole Union. One could never establish a university in the Jewish language...If Jews were compelled to attend Jewish schools, there would certainly be a revolt. It would be considered as a kind of ghetto. The Jewish theatre pined away for lack of audiences, in spite of subventions and subscriptions.

In an interview with the French paper Figaro in 1958 Khrushchev claimed that the project of creating a Jewish national state in Birobidzhan failed because Jews were incapable of collective work - they were individualists and not inclined to do agricultural work.

Khrushchev also believed that many of the Jewish intellectuals and writers executed by Stalin in the late forties and early 'fifties had been planning to establish an independent Jewish republic in the Crimea which would have seceded from the Soviet Union in order to provide a base for American imperialism:

*Stalin showed vigilance here. He put a stop to the pretensions of world Zionism and its attempts to create a base in our country in order to struggle against us. This base would have been Zionism, upon which American imperialists would have relied. If such a republic had been created, then it could not be excluded that there might be Zionist penetration into it. In America Zionism is very developed and, without doubt, America would have seized any opportunity to put pressure on us.

In the immediate post-Stalin years the level of state-organised anti-semitism fell sharply in comparison with the years of the anticosmopolitan campaign and the Doctors' Plot. The imprisoned doctors were released from prison, and the surviving Jewish intellectuals who had been arrested and imprisoned in the course of the anticosmopolitan campaign were likewise released. Jewish writers who had been executed in 1952 were re-instated individually.

But discrimination against Jews in employment continued. Jews continued to be excluded either partially or entirely from government departments dealing with countries abroad and from sensitive security jobs, including high army posts. Al disproportionately small number of Jews were present in the party hierarchy and the state administration, and there was also evidence of a re-introduction of a "numerus clausus" for Jews wishing to enter higher education.

Jews were also penalised with loss of employment for 'inappropriate' behaviour. In the aftermath of the welcome given by Soviet Jews to the Israeli delegation to the Moscow International Youth Festival of 1957 hundreds of Jews were declared guilty of fraternisation' and dismissed from their jobs. A number of them were also arrested and exiled to Siberia.

At the close of the 1950s, as part of a broader campaign against religion, the government launched an oftensive against Judaism in which anti-semitism was never very far below the surface.

The tenets of Judaism were condemned as particularly immoral. Backed up by the odd quote from Marx ("Money is the jealous God of Israel, beside which no other God may stand... We recognise in Judaism a universal and contemporary anti-social element"), the government propaganda declared money to be the god of the Jewish faith. Judaism was accused of promoting the idea that Jews were the chosen people and of thereby encouraging Jews to hate other peoples. Judaism was also accused of encouraging allegiance to "At the close of the 1950s, as part of a broader campaign against religion, the government launched offensive against Judaism in which antisemitism was never very far below the surface. another state (Israel) and to a reactionary pro-imperialist movement (Zionism).

The Jewish clergy was accused of a variety of immoralities: improper conduct, robbing the people, drunkenness, and living in luxury at the expense of their congregations. Synagogues were closed down or forced to close down 'voluntarily' In 1917 there had been about 5,000 synagogues throughout the country. By 1941 the number had fallen to 1,011 and to 450 by 1956. The anti-Judaic campaign took a further toll: there were 92 synagogues in 1964, and 60 in 1965. In the *Jewish national homeland' of Birobidzhan there were no officially registered synagogues at all. (There were, in any case, very few Jews living in their 'national homeland': in 1959, over thirty years after the launch of the project, Jews constituted just 8.8% of the population in Birobidzhan.)

There were also reports of synagogues being burnt down: in Malakhovka in 1959 and in Tskhakaya in 1962. Money collected by Soviet Jews to build new synagogues was confiscated by the authorities. Soviet Jews who formed 'dvadtsatki' ('councils of twenty' — Soviet law nominally recognised the right of members of religious groups to form 'dvadtsatki' to petition for the opening of places of worship) and petitioned for the opening of synagoges were victimised by the authorities.

Kosher butchery and the baking of matzos were made increasingly difficult by the authorities. In 1962 the baking of matzos was forbidden throughout the Soviet Union and matzos was denounced as "counterrevolutionary bread". In 1963 three Jews were sentenced to prison for the illegal baking of matzos. Packets of matzos smuggled into the Soviet Union were described as an "ideological diversion". Only after protests from abroad was the ban on the baking of matzos lifted in some towns in the Soviet Union in 1964/5.

The "anti-Judaism' campaign flowed over into an 'anti-Zionist' campaign of an equally anti-semitic nature, albeit on a more modest scale than the 'anti-Zionist' campaen which erupted at the close of the '60s. "Judaic sermons are the sermons of bourgeois Zionists," claimed a Kirovograd radio broadcast in 1959, whilst the Kubishev local newspaper argued: "The character of the Judaic relgion serves the political aims of Zionism and the awakening of a nationalist frame of mind."

In 1963 the pamphlet, In the Name of the Lord Jehovah was published, a sustained attack * Jewish nationalism, Zionism, the spiritual source of year "Communist Moldavia same which is Judaism". In the tacked Zionism asa "bourgeois-nationalist movement which arose at the end of the nineteenth century; this reactionary trend is clusiveness of the Jewish people*. rooted in idea In 1964 Mayatsky's Contemporary Judaism and Zionism was published, giving an initial airing to many of the themes to be taken up in the post-1967 'anti-Zionist' campaige.

The previous year had seen the publication of Yofim Kichko's -Judaism Without fobestepment, following footsteps Kichko's dissertation thesis 'Modern Zionism and its Reactionary Role' and his earlier work of 1957, Judaism: Origin and Essence. 1057, he extreme anti-semitic nature of Kichko's latest work, including anti-semitic cartoons and allegations of collaboration between Zionism and Nazism, provoked a wave of protest in the West which resulted in a vague and half-hearted criticism of the book in the pages of Pravda and Izvestia:

"The author of the booklet and the author of the preface meant to unmask the reactionary nature of Judaism; in so doing they misinterpreted certain questions as to the origins and development of this religion. A number of erroneous statements and illustrations in the booklet may have hurt the feelings of believers and be interpreted as anti-semitic. But it is well-known that there is not and cannot be such a problem in our country...The erroneous statements...only invite anti-Soviet insinuations. That is why Soviet public opinion objected to the erroneous passages in Y Kichko's book."i The 'anti-Judaic' and *antiZionist' campaigning occurred at the same time as the KGB campaign of the early 1960s against economic crimes. This too possessed a clear anti-semitic content. Some 50% of the crimes reported in the press in which the death penalty was kraine, where Jews numbered 2% of the population, 90% of those executed were Jews, and in the Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic (where Jews were 0.2% of the population), 64% of those executed were Jews. In its coverage of the trials the press gave the Hebrew form of the patronymic names of the defendants, as well as detailing references to the alleged involvement of synagogues and rabbis, thus creating an anti-semitic amalgam of fraud, embezzlement, Judaism and Jews.

In August of 1967 the simultaneous publication of the article 'What is Zionism?' in the major Soviet provincial newspapers signalled the start of a major 'antiZionist' campaign which was to continue throughout the 1970s into the eighties. The article portrayed Zionism as an interhational organisation, often operating behind the scenes, which disposed of vast amounts of money. This "Zionist corporation" had deeply penetrated into politics, finance, religion, and trade with the aim, albeit "well camouflaged" , of augmenting its already vast wealth. At the same time Kichko, the former author of "erroneous statements" , launched the anti-Zionist campaign in Ukraine with his article Zionism - Tool of Imperialism' . The following year Kichko was awarded a Diploma of Honour by the Ukrainian Supreme Soviet for services rendered in the dissemination of "atheist propaganda".

In 1969 Yuri Ivanov's Beware: Zionism! was published, with an initial print-run of 70,000 copies. Second and third editions of the booklet were published in 1970 and 1971, with print-runs of 200,000 and 100,000 respectively. Ivanov portrayed Zionism in terms which were to be the stock-in-trade of the 'anti-Zionist' campaign in subsequent years: Zionism as the ideology of the Jewish bourgeoisie, Zionism as the ideology of Jewish network conspiring against the 'socialist camp' and other 'progressive forces' on behalf of American imperialism.

With the appearance of Ivanov's booklet the 'anti-Zionist' campaign "The state of Israel, the creation of which had been welcomed by the Soviet government in the late 'forties, was portrayed in very different terms by the anti-Zionist campaign.

was well underway. In the following years there was a flood of similar 'anti-Zionist' publications by writers such as Bolshakov (Zionism in the Service of Anti-Communism), Davydov (We Pass Judgement on Zionism), Mints (Zionism: Theory and Practice), Skurlatov (Zionism and Apartheid), Brodsky (Zionism — A Tool of Reaction), Kiselev (International Zionism: History and Politics), Mitin (The Ideology and Practice of International Zionism), and Soiter (The Collapse of Zionist Theories).

The essence of the 'anti-Zionist' campaign was that it portrayed "Zionism' and "Zionists' in terms of traditional anti-semitism. "Zionists' were cunning, scheming plotters. They disposed of vast amounts of wealth, acquired through being parasitic upon the labour of others. They controlled the media, the secret services, and institutions of government throughout the world. Just as the Russian Slavophiles of the nineteenth century had believed in the existence of a "World Kabal" based in Paris which directed the activities of Jews in different countries in pursuit of world domination, just as the "Protocols of the Elders of Zion" purported to be an exposé of Jews plotting to rule the world, so too the 'antiZionist' campaign portrayed Zionism as an international conspiracy in pursuit of world power.

The emergence of Zionism was not seen as a response to antisemitism but as part of the plans of "Jewish capital" to expand its influence and power: "In the West, Jewish capital became such a powerful force that it was able to participate independently in the colonial division of the world." Hence the emergence of Zionism at the turn of the century: "The emergence of political. Zionism was a consequence of the struggle of the Jewish bourgeoisie to extend its positions in the economy of the most powerful capitalist states of that time and in the economic system of world capitalism as a whole."

According to the "anti-Zionist" campaign, the existence of antisemitism is welcomed and exploited by the Zionists: "Zionists have used anti-semitism in the political practice of the Jewish bourgeoisle, which emerged as a competitor of the Christian bourgeoisie in the Christian monarchies of the Hapsburgs, the Hohenzollerns, and the Romanovs, or republics which had adopted the principles of freedom of conscience. Any manifestation against the industrialist-Jew, the banker-Jew, the merchant or the middle-man, was characterised as 'antisemitism'; protests of workers and clerics against the most difficult conditions of employment with boss-Jews were also included under the heading of 'anti-semitic manifestations."

Hence the Zionists had repeatedly encouraged and financed antisemitic organisations: in America in the 1930s (In 1930 there emerged more than a hundred organisations, the time and resources of which were spent on propaganda of hatred towards Jews. It is important to note that many of them were covertly financed by secret Zionist funds."), in the Arab countries in the late forties and early fifties (In the course of several years Zionists stoked up and provoked in every way possible 'useful anti-semitic activities' which helped promote the mass exist of hundreds of thousands of believers in Judaism from Arabic countries."), and in Western Europe in the 1970s ("Anti-semitic organisations have been set up with the resources dispensed from the secret funds of Zionism.")

Zionist encouragement of antisemitism even went so far, claimed the 'anti-Zionist' campaign, that the Zionists financed Nazi Germany: "Zionist leaders over the seas made friendly agreements with Hitler and consented to the extermination of hundreds of thousands of Jews...At a time when the ovens of Buchenwald and other death camps were burning hundreds of thousands of Jews, American millionaires and multi-millionaires of Jewish nationality traded with fascist Germany, via 'neutral' middlemen, supplying it with weapons and credit.

Zionist collaboration with the Nazis even went so far as to espionage on their behalf: *In many cases the Zionists served as a 'fifth" column' for Hitler, their international network was used in pursuit of the goal of establishing the world domination of Nazi Germany." In a number of countries they presented themselves as victims of German fascism and "introduced themselves into the state and economic apparatus of the countries of the anti-Hitler coalition and betrayed secret information to the Abwehr."

The state of Israel, the creation of which had been welcomed by the Soviet government in the late forties, was portrayed in very different terms by the 'anti-Zionist' campaign: "The economy of Israel is in reality controlled by the international Zionist corporation SA, England, France, Thus, and a series of Zionist capital the other countries. the nationalistic ruling stratum of Israel is in fact part of the international Zionist concern, based in New York and controlled from the United States."

Zionist plotters were held responsible by the 'anti-Zionist campaign for stirring up unrest in the contries of the "socialist camp': "The tole allotted to Zionism in the strategy of imperialism is to create within the different socialist counpossible revisionist and nationalist conceptions - centres of opposition to the popular order, with the goal of its liquidation by way of quiet counter-revolution."

Scan page 9

The Hungarian Revolution 1956 was portrayed as the work of Zionism: *In 1956 the American Zionist organisation 'United Jewish Appeal' created a special and extremely large fund for supporting the forces of reaction in Hungary, and prepared there its agency for the organisation of the overthrow of people's power." Zionists were held to have played a similar role in Poland a few years later: "Zionists active in Poland collected over a million dollars in support of counter-revolutionary forces and attempted to influence predominantly young students, inciting them to struggle against the nation."

Zionists were likewise held responsible for the events of 1968 in Czechoslovakia: "With the connivance of Dubcek the Zionists obtained control over the sources of information." Zionists "succeeded in deeply penetrating into television, radio, and the press." Czechoslovak television became "a tribune and mouthpiece of Zionism The slogan of democracy without communists' became the leitmotif of performances....of writers and journalists linked not only with Zionism but also with other counter-revolutionary forces."* But the main target of the Zionists, warned the 'anti-Zionist' campaign, was the Soviet Union itself: "The main direction of the struggle of international Zionism against the revolutionary forces of the world is the struggle against the USSR." It must not be forgotten, stressed the campaign, that "the main thrust of Zionism is the strug gle against the USSR, against its Leninist foreign and domestic policies, against Marxist-Leninist ideology and Soviet culture." powerful in the Ported States. I- Zionism was spheres of influence included the CIA (*The interests of the powerful Jewish bourgeoisie and other groupings of finance capital are interlaced in the secret service."), the primaries for the selection of Presidential candidates (*The participation of Zionist capital in the financing of primary campaigns and in working out the platforms in the primaries of the candidates for President - this phenomenon is characteristic of political life in the USA."), and the Mafia (""The leadership of the Mafia [at the time of Al Capone] was closely linked with Zionists and international Zionism, and some Zionists... became its leaders.")

But it was not in the United States along that Zionism wielded such influence: "It is not exaggera tion to say that the system of organisations of international Zionism (which extends throughout the entire world and, at the same time, is strongly centralised) unitec with a powerful financial-economic base in the shape of the monopoly bourgeoisie of Jewish origin...is the main source of strength and activity of Zionist influence on the politics of a series of leading capitalist states.

It seemed, therefore, that Zionism, had achieved the goal of Jewish world domination, as envisaged in the "Protocols of the Elders of Zion": "Too much bears witness to the fact that in the sum of the various factors which determine the course of action of the ruling circles of the leading capitalist states, the cosmopolitan Jewish bourgeoisie and Zionist capital (closely linked with Judaic clericalism) emerge as significantly more organised, more ambitious, and more powerful than any other influential monopoly (family banking, regional) groups and groupings of the financial oligarchy.

This 'anti-Zionist' campaign, in cosmopolitan' in the forties eva which 'Zionist', like 'rootless merely another word for continued throughout the 1970s and was given a fresh burst of life in the early 1980s in the face of campaigning by Soviet Jews to defend their religion and culture and to win the right to emigrate.

More 'anti-Zionist articles appeared in the Soviet press, and another wave 'anti-Zionist? books were published, including books such as The Poison Of Zionism which were specifically intended for use in schools. More closures of synagogues were carried out, leaving Moscow with one svnagogue for half a million Jewish inhabitants. And the number of Soviet Jews allowed to emigrate slumped from over 51,000 in 1979 to 1,315 in 1983, whilst Soviet Jews who campaigned for the rights of Jews in the Soviet Union received lengthy prison sentences: Joseph Begun (7 years in prison, 5 years internal exile); Alexander Paritsky (3 years): Yuri Tarnopolsky (3 years): and Feliks Kochubievsky (2½ years).

In spite of all this, the "Anti-Zionist Committee" set uD in Moscow in 1983 to press home the "anti-Zionist' campaign insisted that the Soviet campaign against Zionism was nothing to do with anti-semitism, and that there was no such thing in the Soviet Union las a "Jewish question"

----- pull-quotes -----

chauvinism, Zionism as a variant of fascism, Zionism as a world-wide

tries — by means of Zionist-minded elements, with the assistance of all

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 456

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →