Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

I WITCH-HUNT School for slander

Socialist Organiser no. 456, 2 August 1990 · scan p. 4 · about 1,637 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

GRAFFITI t will come as no surprise to many that most of the so-called evidence used in Joyce Gould's report to the NEC for justifying Socialist Organiser's proscription should originate from the student move ment.

SO has been a regular target for libellous attacks in the pages of the student Clause Four and Democratic Left publications for several years.

Compared to their student equivalents, the Kinnockite leadership clique has been slow in clamping down on SO supporters. Two years ago, the National Organisation of Labour Students (NOLS) leadership sent a dossier to the National Constitutional Committee (NCC), focused on the activities of "Socialist Student' (in which SO supporters were central), calling for expulsions.

At the time Socialist Students was challenging Labour Students' domination of NUS, and the limited witch-hunt was device to frighten off potential support. In the end, nothing came of it; there were no grounds for excluding Labour Party members contesting elections against NOLS in NUS No doubt the present Labour Students leaders will be enthusiastically supporting the NEC's actions.

The hypocrisy is, of course, credible. Let's look at the charges. Firstly, that SO is a Leninist sect - these arguments have been taken up elsewhere, but the "anti-Leninists' of Clause Four and the LCC operate on the basis of a highly bureaucratic and centralised structure. The "invitation only" meetings of the Kinnockite student cliques are legendary. The annual round of secret deals and agreements in the run-up to NUS and NOLS elections negates the democratic structure of the student movement. Who are the secret conspirators here?

The second charge, although not part of the NEC's evidence, is the real motivation of those ir Labour Students. It revolves around the growth of Socialist Organiser and in particular Left Unity in NUS. Specifically, it involves the issue of SO supporters contesting NUS elections against NOLS. In a perfect world, in which NOLS was an open, democratic organisation, the left wouldn't need to bypass NOLS. But that's not the world we live in.

Essentially NOLS is a tight fac tion, loyal to the Labour Party leadership and hostile to the left. Its conferences are rigged, its internal structure inherently undemocratic, now, with its membership and influence shrinking, it is the laughing stock of NUS.

Of course NOLS have never acted against those rightwingers who challenge them, and have a history of supporting "independents" and Liberals against left-wing Labour candidates in student union elections;

• Labour Party members who stood on Left Alliance slates were never referred for disciplinary action.

• in 1986 a 'Labour Solidarity' candidate had a nomination in for NUS President against the official NOLS candidate.

• NOLS have Tories (1982), the SWP (1985), and Communist Party candidates against other Labour Party members.

• In 1984 NOLS attempted to trade votes with the Union of Jewish Students in return for support against the banning of Sunderland Poly Jewish Society.

• In 1988 they stood Geoff Davidson, an ex-Tory councillor for NUS Finance Committee. He was only withdrawn when his past become public.

• NOLS NC member supported a Liberal against the Labour candidate at Sheffield University.

• At Easter 1990 NUS Conference, the NOLS candidate for Treasurer had previously stood as an independent against Labour in his college, whilst an ex-NOLS chair openly supported anti-Labour candidates in the same election.

The list is endless. What these examples do show is that the real culprits in bringing Labour into disrepute in NUS is the LCC, Clause 4/Democratic Left NOLS leadership. Charges should be brought against these miserable excuses for socialists.

NOLS has not always been loyal to the Labour Party leadership. The trajectory of NOLS from Bennism to Kinnockism is a good index in the development of the soft left over the last ten years. During the struggles of the early 1980s, NOLS fully supported the left in its attempts to introduce mechanisms to hold the movement's leaders to account.

Although "'anti-Trotskyist" (Clause 4 was set up to wrestle: power away from Militant in NOLS in 1974), they became involved in the Rank and File Mobilising Committee (RFMC) and supported Benn for deputy leader in 1981.

Confused and demoralised by the defeats of '83 and the consolidation of the Labour bureaucracy, they quickly fell in to line. Gone was the talk of working class struggle, in was the "dented shield strategy, which now means do nothing, wait and hope, The student movement is a conveyor belt for the young aspiring Labourite careerist. The Labour Party machine is littered with ex-NUS hacks. Many of them have started out with good intentions, with an idea of struggle and socialism, but the bureaucracy's tentacles pull them in and the logic of their self-advancement leads them to abandoning any principles and tc attackina their own left wing. Moreover, the real struggles of those they 'represent' become a nuisance, an irritation that gets. in the way of the endless round of expenses-paid lunches in the House of Commons and beyond The reason those in NOLS have plotted to get Socialist Organiser proscribed may feel it assures them some short-term personal gain. The framework for NOLS' hatred of SO derives from our success in NUS. In a short period SO has grown to be the most influential revolutionary group in the student movement. We have managed to combine militant rank and file action with an assault on the NUS bureaucrats themselves.

These people set their sights no higher than a career and a Labour government that will shackle the unions, attack workers' living standards, and bow to the demands of the bosses. We set our sights muc higher.

Paul McGarry All statements in a personal "'The NEC's decision of 25 July 1990 to declare Socialist Organiser ineligible for affiliation to the Labour Party is indicative of how far the Party has travelled on the road to intolerance.

"In 1982 the then NEC found that the Militant Tendency 'as presently constituted' would not be eligible for inclusion on 'the register of non-affiliated groups of Labour Party members'. At the time it invited the Militant Tendency to apply for inclusion on the register. It asked Militant to 'indicate the changes' it was prepared to make 'to implement the NEC's decision to conform to the constitution of the Party'.

"The NEC listed 8 rulings with which an organisation had to comply to qualify for inclusion. One of these was that 'any group found to be in breach of these rules should be given a period of not more than three months in which to put an end to such infringements' . This was in 1982.

'In 1990 no such latitude is being extended to supporters of Socialist Organiser, even though the editor of the newspaper is prepared to comply with NEC requirements. The NEC did not think it necessary even to rep ly to SO's offer. Without so much as a hearing, it declares SO ineligible for affiliation to the Labour Party. This means that Party members associated with the distribution of the newspaper will have failed to conform to the constitution of the Party and will face disciplinary charges.

"It is a sad reflection that at a time when Communist Parties in Eastern Europe are widening internal party should be moving in the opposite direction."

"I am appalled at the ban Socialist Organiser. It is another turn in the screw against internal political debate in the labour movement. The strength of the labour movement ought to be the ability of all to express views freely. Instead we have the serious curtailment of free speech in the Labour Party. I am totally opposed to all bans and proscriptions in the Jeremy Corbyn Tam against expelling people from the Labour Party on grounds of their political views. If there is anyone who thinks it will make the Party more attractive to the electorate - they are mistaken. It will simply in a list of demands for expulsions."

Mulli "We both condemn the proscription of Socialist Organiser. Freedom to organise and build support for the ideas of the left within the Labour Party should be a fundamental right. We will be urging our delegations to this year's annual conference to support the reference back of the report dealing with SO." Tony Kearns and Tom McGee UCW National Executive "Labour Women's Action Committee believes that ideas cannot be stamped out by banning or expulsions. But this is what the NEC is trying to do. They are attempting to censor ideas."

Labour Women's Actio Committe *When a party starts opposition by attempting to ban it, something is far coming from people who in the past have quite correctly criticised this kind of undemocratic behaviour in the East. I hope that ordinary members of the Labour Party will refuse to accept this ban."

Callum Macrae - Chail Edinburgh Trades Counc *The witch-hunt has already done massive damage to the Labour Party. The attacks on Socialist Organiser are not only unjust - in that once again they have proscribed against people with socialist ideas - but there is also the pragmatic considerations that they will provide a field day for our enemies in the media, and distract from the task of defeating the Tories.* Bob Clay MP *We deplore the decision to witch-hunt Socialist Organiser from the Labour Party. It seems that NOLS played a part in getting the paper proscribed. It's not surprising really, they've lost all the big political arguments in the student movement for the last few years. Socialist Organiser has played a central role in organising and mobilising the left in NUS whilst at the same time making revolutionary socialist ideas popular amongst students. We will fight the ban."

Emma Colyer - National Secretary, National Union of Janine Booth - Women's Officer, NUS Mitchell - Vice President FEUD, NUS Mark Sandell - National Executive Member, NUS

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 456

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →