[that person were given a false name, would…]
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-07-26Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
that person were given a false name, would face heavy scrutiny both from film censors and lawyers. Duncan Campbell recently won such a libel case.
Nevertheless, the film censors were wrong to ban it.
It would surely be the case that if Rushdie sued for libel he would be awarded considerable damages. It would be a pretty cut and dried case. But that is not a matter for censors to decide. Individuals decide whether to sue for libel; courts decide if they have, in fact, been defamed.
Censorship of this kind could set a nasty precedent. Whatever the merits of Duncan Campbell's recent libel suit, against a TV play which he claimed portrayed him as a screwed up homosexual without principles, it would be bad news if the programme had been banned, or if similar films were banned.
And banning the Rushdie film plays into the hands of the fundamentalists. Inevitably, it can be used to suggest hypocrisy on the part of their critics.
It is to Rushdie's considerable credit that he has opposed the ban.
Socialists should in general oppose the banning of films, unless there are very good grounds not to do so. The grounds here are not sufficient.
Labour Party Socialists has denounced the NEC's procedure against Socialist Organiser as a gross denial of natural justice.
LPS states: "In the next General Election, which will be close fought, no-one will believe the Labour Party when it says that it will protect citizens from the overweening power of the state when it treats its own members in this disgraceful way."
The Labour Party Policy Review, 'Looking to the Future', , also states that "Britain has been condemned by the Council of Europe for allowing the security services to invade people's privacy without justification. We will introduce a security services act which will make MIS and MI6 accountable to the House of Commons." LPS calls on the National Executive Committee to state that it will not accept information gathered by the security services in respect of its own members, and refuse to use such information in internal disputes.
LPS calls on the NEC to act fairly and refuse to endorse reports which breach all the rules of natural justice.