Sectarian whining
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-07-26Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
EFT PRESS
Stemsees as ever so- apporters of Socialist themselves as ever-soreasonable and non-sectarian people.
The also try to present Socialist Organiser as a bitter and sectarian publication.
The realitv, of course, is very different. Take the following. gem from this summer's Outlook:
*It slipped through on the nod: the right wing press will go wild when they see what it says!" exclaimed a jubilant Socialist Organiser supporter, after their "Norkers' Rights Charter' slipped through the NALGO conference.
I hope he didn't hold his breath waiting for the furore. The Charter's generalised formulations against sin and for democratic rights (including unionisation of police and armed forces) have not been the cause of much concern among the ruling class or the labour movement bureaucracy.
It was not so much that it went through on the nod: it just had everyone nodding off!"
So, according to Outlook, the campaign for a charter of workers' rights is a boring waste of time. If this is what Outlook really think about the campaign for a workers' rights charter then a few things need explaining.
Why did Outlook supporters unanimously endorse the charter at the Socialist Movement Trade Union conference last November and agree to campaign for it in their unions?
Why have Outlook supporters shown so much interest in the campaign in Labour Party Socialists coordinating work around the It's difficult to fathom what's going on. It seems that some people in Outlook have at least some feel for the real labour movement and the real balance of class forces and thus understand the value of fighting to change the law to enshrine certain positive rights for workers.
Others in Socialist Outlook, notably industrial 'expert' Alan Thornett and John Lister (whose euphemism is Harry Sloan'), author of the above quoted diatribe, are incapable of' assessing any proposal from Socialist Organiser objectively.
For instance, Thornett originally opposed the idea of the Socialist Movement campaigning for a charter of workers' rights on the absurd grounds that "we don't put demands on Kinnock" and that strike action was the only way to deal with the law". Wiser counsels than his must have prevailed and Thornett eventually, though grudgingly, came round to backing the βIn a similar vein Alan Thornett also opposed as "sectarian" a programme for trade union democracy, including the annual election of officials, put forward by Socialist Organiser supporters at the Socialist Movement Trade Union conference. This was despite the fact that the proposals had come from a charter that he had helped to draw up in the early 1980s!
It seems that Thornett's only response to Socialist Organiser is blind factional opposition. He works out the 'theoretical' justifications later.
Are the rest of Outlook going to follow him down this road or be more constructive?
The issue is where does Outlook stand in the campaign for a charter of workers' rights? Are they for it or against it?
Those in Outlook who are serious about fighting for trade union rights should say clearly and openly that they do not agree with the Thornett/Lister line and that they are prepared to call them to order and to co-operate with Socialist Organiser in a labour movement campaign around the issue.
Finally, if there was no press "furore' over the NALGO conference decision on the anti-union laws, then why did the Guardian comment "NALGO yesterday drove a wedge between Labour and the trade unions"'?