[For the past four or five years the…]
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-07-26Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
For the past four or five years the British trade union movement has been gripped by merger mania. Every one of the largest 20 TUC affiliates has recently discussed betrothal or been a'courting with one or more partners. The behaviour of certain unions has been downright promiscuous.
So far, however, the urge to merge has resulted in remarkably few marriages. ASTMS and TASS got together, becoming MSF in early 1988; the GMB and Apex tied the knot in 1989; the NUS and NUR followed suit the same year — though that was something of a shotgun wedding brought about by the seafarers' bankruptcy following the Dover dispute.| But the long-running courtship between the AEU and the EETPU came to nothing after rank and file engineers persuaded their national committee to call the whole thing off - for the time being at least.
Presently, romance is in the air between the civil service unions CPSA and NUCPS, the print unions SOGAT and the NGA, and the National Communications Union still has an ambition to get together with ACTT to form a telecommunications union. Meanwhile, NALGO, NUPE and CoHSE are busily engaged in a three-way liaison with a view to forming a giant 1.5 millionmember public sector union.
Most of the prospective mergers make a lot of sense, on paper at least. The creation of a single big union in each industry has always been something socialists are, in principle, in favour of. The problem is that in practice, union amalgamations are usually thoroughly bureaucratic affairs that further weaken the influence of the rank and file and give the top brass the opportunity to cobble together new rule-books that combine all the worst aspects of the old, separate ones.
Even the ASTMS/Tass merger, which was conducted relatively democratically and with quite a high degree of rank and file involvement (on the ASTMS side, anyway) has almost inevitably, it seems, resulted in a structure that owes much more to the bureaucratic, Stalinistdominated traditions of Tass' than to the relatively open, branch-based ASTMS.
Exactly the same process was underway in the EETPU/ABU merger, with Bill Jordan taking the opportunity to jettison his union's highly democratic structure in favour of a new rule book much more closely based on the electricians' police-state constitution - which was why the AEU National Committee called a halt.
All the above examples have at least involved some rank and file involvement and discussion. But recently a furtive little game of footsie has begun between the leaders of the TGWU and MSF that, so far, hasn't involved any rank and file consultation whatsoever, on either side.
"Exploratory discussions" are known to have taken place; Ron Todd and Ken Gill (or, rather, their respective research departments) have joined forces to produce a glossy pamphlet called Making Our Future' which argues for a sort of watered-down latter-day Alternative Economic Strategy; but even activists in the two unions don't know any more about Will Ron and Ken get it together? what's going on...except that something is going on.....
Politically, an MSF/TGWU wedding would make a lot of sense for the semiStalinist 'Broad Left' current within the TUC, especially as the AEU is once again talking about approaching "kindred unions" for amalgamation, putting the prospect of a powerful new right-wing bloc within the TUC back on the agenda. Industrially, an MSE/ TGWU merger would also make a lot of sense. But neither union is exactly noted for the democratic nature of its rule book or for encouraging rank and file participation.
T&G members should tell Ron Todd keep the relationship with MSF strictplatonic.
----- pull-quotes -----
NSIDE By Sleeper