Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Out of sight, out of mind!

Socialist Organiser no. 455, 26 July 1990 · scan p. 10 · about 973 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

The final boot in the gut for the privatisation of nuclear power in Britain was probably the calculation by City analysts of the costs of "decommissioning" , or shutting down and disposing of, old nuclear power stations.

This is certain to run into billions, if not tens of billions, of pounds, though there are suggestions of ways to save some of this moneyAt present, the state-owned Nuclear Electric plans a three stage decommissioning process. In Stage 1, all the fuel is removed from the core of the reactor. This could take five years from the date the plant ceases to generate electricity.

In Stage 2, the parts of the station outside of the reactor block will be removed piecemeal. Some of these parts will be radioactive. This could also take five years.

The third stage, dismantling the reactor block inside its massive concrete "biological" shield, would be delayed for up to 100 years, during which time the block would have to be guarded and monitored. This would allow some of the more short-lived radioactive products of nuclear fission to decay, thus reducHinkley nuclear power station ing the exposure of workers to radiation. Finally, the reactor block would be cut up and cleared away (though where to remains an unanswered question at present).

Decommissioning has just started on the Berkeley Magnox reactor in Advanced Gas-cooled Reactors (a later design which was dogged with difficulties and cost over-runs). The total cost of this may (and therefore probably will) exceed £7.5 billion.

Not surprisingly, Nuclear Electric are looking at alternatives that could save them some of this politically embarassing cost. One possibility is simply to delay the stages, thus allowing the cost to be spread out over more years. NE are considering delaying Stage 2 by 30 and Stage 3 by 130 years!

Another alternative, called "safestore" , is to clear part of the plant and construct a "box" around the reactor.

The third, perhaps the most interesting and controversial, is to "simply" bury the whole lot under a huge mound and leave it. This is euphemistically termed "in situ decommissioning"

According to the manager of waste and decommissioning for NE, studies show that sand could be pumped trom nearby sea or river beds, and shaped into a stable mound over the reactor and other buildings. The buildings would have to be filled with sand, too, to avoid subsidence, and the whole lot could then be landscaped.

Friends of the Earth regard this as a "picnic site approach" which does not answer the problems of long-term safety of radioactive remains. The Countryside Commission, however, believe there are many sites where an additional hill could blend in quite nicely, though perhaps not in the flat lands around the Bradwell station.

It seems to me that the burial mound approach is just another form of the type of long-term surface storage of nuclear waste called for by groups such as FoE. It would have the important advantage of reducing to a minimum the exposure of workers to radiation.

It is perhaps little different to the practice of abandoning worked-out or "uneconomic" coal mines, except that these are not filled up and cause problems of subsidence for decades after.

We would not be the first society to leave mysterious mounds for future societies to puzzle over. Of course, these would be somewhat more dangerous to interfere with and this is a factor that should be considered. Perhaps the mounds should be made of concrete to discourage 25th century uranium diggers.

Mark Lindsay was very sad to learn of the untimely death of Mark Lindsay recently. He was very interested in science and was particularly keen to gain science qualifications and work in a science or health environment.

We had many conversations on a wide range of scientific topics during which he suggested several topics for Science Column articles.

I shall miss his lively mind. British building societies, they had mostly stayed small and local, taking deposits from small savers and making small loans for house-buyers.

The US government guaranteed the small savers their money back if an S&L went broke, and supervised the S&Ls fairly closely.

Then, in 1982, most of the controls were scrapped, but the guarantee for depositors remained. The S&L bosses went on a spree, lending cash for vast speculative property developments and borrowing more at high rates of interest.

They took huge salaries and bonuses for themselves, too. Charles Keating of Lincoln Savings, for example, together with his family, took S42 million from the company in just two years. —In order to keep the few government officials still with some powers to regulate the industry off their backs, the S&Ls bribed Congressmen lavishly. As one Congressman ruefully told us, the problem with the US Congress these days is not that Congressmen break their pomises, but that they keep their promises — to the people who provide cash for their election campaigns, not to the voters.

But the bubble eventually burst. The US government is left with the obligation to pay off the small savers, and also holding vast collection of whiteelephant office blocks, shopping malls. luxury hotels, etc, and worthless "junk bonds".

The US taxpayer will pay $2000 for every child, woman and man in the country and most of the S&L bosses will get off scot free!

The fiasco may have implications on the world scale. too. It has vastly increased the US government's problems with its budget deficit, confronting it with a sharp choice: raise taxes and risk sending the economy into a downturn, or see the balance-of-payments deficit spiral out of control and risk the dollar slumping in the foreign exchange markets. Either way it gravely weakens the US in the scramble for position in the new international capitalist order now taking shape after the collapse of Stalinism in Eastern Europe.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 455

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →