Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Prisoners of the past

Socialist Organiser no. 455, 26 July 1990 · scan p. 10 · Martin Thomas · about 998 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Belinda Weaver reviews 'Fools of Fortune' Tools of Fortune' is failure, but an interesting one, since its main problem is its reach exceeding its grasp. At least it's trying for something.

Set in the south of Ireland, the story beings in 1920 at Kilneagh, the home of the Quintons, a well-to-do Protestant family. Young Willy and his two sisters live an idyllic childhood, where the biggest excitement is the arrival of a new maid. These family scenes are drawn fairly conventionally: afternoon teas on the lawn in summer, the elegant mother, Evie (Julie Christie), at the piano.

Less usual is the late night visit of an IRA group seeking funds and assistance. Unusually, perhaps, the Protestant Quinton agrees to give money, but then he's a man who does what he likes, regardless of people's opinions. Against all advice, he has given a job to Doyle, a former employee returned from the war. Doyle is outcast by the other workers for his friendship with Rudkin, one of the Black and Tans, the British bands now seeking to crush Irish nationalists. -When Doyle is found hanged on Quinton's land, Rudkin extracts a bloody revenge.

Quinton had tried to live outside of politics, to live and let live. In Ireland in the twenties, this was not really possible, just as it's impossible in Northern Ireland now. Sides are taken for you, whether you like it or not.

As Willy grows up to manhood he cannot escape the past. His mother cannot forget, and she does not suffer in silence. Her bitter memories are brought out again and again, still, fresh in their horror and injustice. There is no forgive and forget. As the defrocked priest Father Kilgareth says, "The past is always there in the present. That's something we all learn in time" Willy learns that not even a love affair with the lovely Marianne can free him from his memories. He is a prisoner of the past.

The film is on the side of the Irish nationalists, not from any romantic ideal, but purely as a way of ending the spiral of violence the Black and Tans have unleashed. Though quite bloody in parts, the film conveys a hatred of violence, not just for its own ugliness and waste, but also for the devastation it inflicts on the living.

It is a plea for an end to violence, not in the name of Catholic or Protestant, but in the name of humanity. Kindness and mercy, pleads Father Kilgareth, kindness and mercy instead of suffering and death.

Though it deals with violent and emotional events, the film is strangely static, more like a series of tableaus than a narrative. The child actors who play the young Willy and Imelda, Willy's daughter, engage us more closely than the adults, with the exception of Mary Elizabeth Mastrantonio who is utterly convincing as Marianne. Christie's performance is a nightmare. Early on, she's quiet and lovely (her speciality) but when she tries to convey the drunken ruin Evie has become, her performance is so strident and busy that she's unwatchable.

The worst though is lain Glen's Willy. The boy Willy was someone we connected with, but the adult Willy is remote, too closed off from us. Glen's performance is all ties; he's as skittish and jumpy as an overbred racehorse. There's no heart in his acting; it's technique with nothing behind it. We need to care for Willy if we're to be drawn into this story. Glen keeps us at arm's length, ain Glenn as Willy For all that, and even allowing for the slightly mawkish spirituality that closes the film, 'Fools of Fortune' is probably worth seeing, especially by people who find the current situation in | Northern Gloucestershire and Bradwell in Essex will probably be the next. By 2020, Nuclear Electric must begin decommissioning eight Magnox reactors (the oldest design) and five Ireland incomprehensible. Ireland's history is a patchwork of private tragedies like this, where no escape from violence seems possible, but where violence only results in stalemate.

Yes, it wa This wasn't capitalism,"

co-author of a book about America's Savings and Loans scandal.

He told Channel 4 TV (*A Whale of a Mess', Tuesday 24 July) that capitalism was about people putting their savings into starting a business, building it up, and then, when they retire with the profits they've drawn in return for their risk and effort, leaving a productive enterprise behind them.

But Charles Keating" — boss of one of the most notorious S&Ls, Lincoln Savings "just left $2.5 billion smoking hole behind him."

The S&L scandal is by far the biggest financial swindle in history. The South Sea Bubble, the Florida land scams before the Great Crash of 1929, all were tiny by comparison.

Sorting it out will cost the US government maybe $500 billion. That's fifty times as much as the total of Marshall Aid; or four times as much as the total money cost to the US of the Vietnam War.

But it's capitalism all right. Pizzo's world of thrifty small businesses has about the SalliC relation modern capitalism as kids kicking a ball in the back alley have to the World Cup.

Capitalism is no longer, if it ever was, about individual reward for individual efforts. It's about the rewards to be gained by ripping off other people's labour.

And, these days, the richest rewards of that sort are to be got not in direct productive enterprise but in the sphere of high finance where the profits of that enterprise are lent, borrowed, and sluiced around The S&L bosses just followed the cardinal rule of capitalism: go for the biggest profits.

The scandal was a product of the Reagan enthusiasm for "deregulation". "Deregulation" was Regan's equivalent of Thatcher's "privatisation" economy with very little nationalised industry. It meant abolishing government controls on business to give the free market more scope.

The S&Ls are America's equivalent of Britain's building societies. Unlike

----- pull-quotes -----

LES HEARN-S COLUMN

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 455

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →