Soviet Anti- Semitism 9
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-07-26Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
An anti-semitic White Russian poster depicting Trotsky as the ogre of the Kremlin. The Soviet bureaucracy later revived these and were anxious not to be seen as responsible for "bringing back the Jews" . As Khrushchev, then First Secretary of the Communist Party n Ukraine, put it: "It is not in our interest that the Ukrainians should associate the return of Soviet power with the return of the Jews."
"In 1948 the infamous 'anti-cosmopolitan campaign was launched. This was straightforward anti-semitism, albeit with the word 'cosmopolitan" serving as a substitute for 'Jew'. The campaign began with the publication of an article in Pravda and, on the eve of its demise, in the paper of the Jewish Anti-Fascist Committee denying the existence of Jewish people...
traditional themes.
With the war over, the Soviet had been killed in a traffic accident. government quickly forgot about the contribution of "Brider Yiden" to the wartime mobilisation. In the official histories of the war, especially the definitively official History of the Great Patriotic War in the Soviet Union, the Jewish con- the execution. tribution to the Soviet war effort and the attrocities committed against Jews in the Soviet Union during the war were largely passed over in silence.
Between 1945 and 1948 a mere four to seven books per year dealing with the heroism and suffering of Soviet Jews during the war were published. In 1949 just one book on this theme, itself a reprint of an already published book, appeared. mand."
None of the books were ever reprinted again. In the period 1950-55 not a single book on the theme of Jews and the war was published.
Government statistics on the victims of the war defined them as Soviet, Ukrainian, Lithuanian, etc, but not Jewish. In Babi Yar, where 33,000 Jews were massacred, the monument erected at the scene of the massacre was dedicated to "Soviet citizens" . Attempts by Jews to erect their own monuments to the memory of Jews murdered during the war were frustrated by popular anti-semitism and the authorities.
Jews were effectively imprisoned within the Soviet Union. Although the Soviet government had officially welcomed the creation of the state of Israel ("'Hearty good wishes on the establishment of the Jewish state... With all our hearts we wish you and the working people in the state of Israel a victory over the aggressors" read the telegram from the Jewish Anti-Fascist Committee to Weizmann, the first Israeli President), It was certainly not prepared to allow its Jewish citizens to emigrate there (or anywhere else); between May of 1948 and the close of 1951 only four elderly peo- perialism.
ple and one disabled ex-serviceman were permitted to emigrate to Jews now faced a mounting tide of anti-semitism, instigated, sanctioned and encouraged by the government. Amongst its first victims were the members of the Jewish Anti-Fascist Committee.
In 1948 Mikhoels was killed by the Soviet secret police. The official version of his death claimed that he tionalism, and describing Israel as a But Stalin's daughter wrote in her bourgeois state which was a tool in memoirs: "He was assassinated, the hands of Anglo-American there was no accident. The traffic capitalism. accident was an official version sug. was fully underway. Pravda carried By January of 1949 the campaign gested by my father when told of a major article entitled 'A Certain Her version of events was endors- Anti-Patriotic Group of Theatre ed by Khrushchev: "To kill him Critics' which attacked a group of [Mikhoels] brutally, to kill him in predominantly Jewish theatre secret, and then decorate his "cosmopolitanism": "Shameless critics allegedly guilty of killer and bury the victim with cosmopolitanism is not only anticonceivable! They said that he had honour this is intellectually in- social but also sterile. It is as harmfallen under a car and been killed by ful as the parasites that gnaw at the a lorry, but he was thrown under a roots of useful grains. It is a conlorry. It was an artistic perfor- ductor of reactionary bourgeois mance. But who did this? Stalin did influences hostile to us. An anti- patriotic group of followers of this, this was done at his com- bourgeis aestheticism has arisen in wave of arrests of the other theatre criticism." An article in Izvestia the followFascist Committee followed. Most figureheads of Jewish Anti- ing month ('Wipe Out the Antiof them, including Lozovsky, the Patriotic Group of Drama Critics') chairperson of the committee and continued in the same vein. The arformer head of the Profintern, were ticle "exposed" the "anti-patriotic activity in the Leningrad chapter of leading member of the committee, shot. Zhemchuzhina, another the All-Russian Theatrical Society and also the wife of Molotov, was of S Dreiden, I Schneiderman, I sentenced to exile, but not before Berzark, M Yankovsky, S Tsimbal, Stalin had circulated a document and other rootless cosmopolitans, alleging that she had been un- conscious followers of the Yuzovfaithful to her husband and listing skys and Gurviches." her alleged lovers. In 1948 the Com- '"For many years," Izvestia sudmittee itself was formally dissolved cosmopolitans have disseminated denly discovered, "these rootless and its paper ceased publication.
Government departments dealing deleterious bourgeois ideas, while sharply criticising everything new, emptied of Jewish officials, with foreign governments were everything Soviet...Dreiden, specially in the Foreign Office. cosmopolitans heaped slander and Schneiderman, and their fellow zhan (supposedly "national 'he Communist Party in Birobic abuse on Soviet plays, besmirched homeland" for Jews in the Soviet our art and socialist realism. Union) was purged. Leading Yid- Spiritually wasted, hostile to the dish writers were executed. The Soviet people and homeland, these Moscow State Theatre was closed cosmopolitan devotees of down, along with all Jewish aestheticism enjoy reviling Soviet publishing houses, magazine, plays." schools, and other educational and ...state anti-semitism social institutions. Jews working in the "Stalin" car factory were ar- continued... with the "Zionist agents" of American im- rested and charged with being execution of Yiddish writers and the closure cosmopolitan" campaign was laun- In 1948 the infamous anti- Jewish cultural ched. This was straightforward institutions...
anti-semitism, albeit with the word The campaign was still in full "cosmopolitan" serving as substitute for "Jew". The cam- flight in March. According to an arpaign began with the publication of ticle in Vechernaya Moskva, 'it is a an article in Pravda and, on the eve well known fact that the "Soviet of its demise, in the paper of the Writer' Publishing House has harJewish Anti-Fascist Committee, de- boured people without kith or kin, nying the existence of a Jewish peo- anti-patriotic Levins, Danins, and ple, condemning Jewish na- the like.In his so-called book Isbakh openly propagandises for Zionism, writes about the Zionist organisation...and even reproduces the words of the Zionist anthem... Aleksandr Isbakh wrote a loathsome book indeed! And who helped him publish it if not the already denounced rootless cosmopolitan F Levin, who appears, as the editor of the book."
Cosmopolitans were discovered everywhere - in the theatre, in the cinema, in literature, in art, in publishing houses, in historical science, hydraulics dare economid architecture, pedagogy, physiology. Piatokov and Trotsky were posthumously declared a cosmopolitan spy and a notorious cosmopolitan respectively. Sergei Vasiliev gave a poetic dimension to the campaign, listing the social spheres into which the rootless cosmopolitans had "wormed" themselves:
In science, in philosophy, In the radio and in art, In music and in sport, Gurewitz after Sutyrin, Cherniak after Hoffensheffer, Smulson after Katsnelson, They follow their brothers, Abraham and Elijah." (Without Whom It Is Good To Live in Russia)
New editions of earlier literary works were appropriately expurgated. Lev Kassil's The Land of Shvambraniia was re-published with all references deleted to the author's childhood refusal to read Gogol's Taras Bulba because of its anti-semitic stereotyping. Aleksei Svirksi's The Story of My Life appeared in a new edition minus its monologues of an Odessa Jew after a pogrom. And the re-published version of Bill-Belotserkovsky's The Frontier Guards lacked its earlier references to the hero of the work being a Jew.
Although the anti-cosmopolitan campaign itself had abated by the close of 1949, state anti-semitism continued throughout the following years with the execution of Yiddish writers and the closure of Jewish cultural institutions, and then ran rampant again in the "Doctors' Plot" of 1953.
At the centre of the Doctors' Plot was the accusation that a number of Jewish doctors had plotted, in some cases already successfully, to kill leading members of the Soviet elite.
"Among the members of this dious gang of murderers are pro. tessors of medicine Vovsi, Vinogradov, M Kogan, Yegorev Feldman, Etinger, and Greenstein and the physician Mayorov. Comrades AA Zhdanov and AS Shcherbakov died at the hands of these cruel monsters disguised as doctors and scientists...These villains and wreckers tried their hardest to undermine the health of leading military cadres, to put them out of action and weaken the country's defences, claimed Pravda in January 1953.
The doctors were denounced as agents of British and American imperialism. According to Izvestia, "most of the terrorist group were connected with the internationalist Jewish bourgeois-nationalist organisation, the "Joint', created by American intelligence...(which) under the guidance of American intelligence, conducts extensive espionage, terrorist, and similar subversive activities in a number of countries...Other members of the terrorist group were long-standing members of the British intelligence service."
Variously described as "monsters of mankind" intelligence "hired agents of i villains and wreckers" foreign 'monstrous poisoners' and 'contemptible hirelings of foreigr intelligence services who sold out the doctors had "under the cover of for dollars and pounds sterling" the noble medical profession trampled the sacred banner of science underfoot and defiled the honour of science".
Novoye Vremya (a political magazine launched just after the war by Stalin, and also the name of a well-known anti-semitic paper published for several decades in Tsarist Russia) denounced the doctors as "Zionist hirelings of American imperialism" and took the opportunity to answer the question which it claimed public opinion was now asking "What do Zionism and its organisatons represent? What part do they play in the warmongers' plans?"
Its answer was: "Zionism is a bourgeois-nationalist movement..
Present-day Zionism is at the service of American aggression and the imperialists in preparing for a new world war. Zionist propaganda serves the same interests. Specifically, the Zionist organisations are a breeding ground for corrupt cosmopolitan ideas...The Zionists reveal themselves not only as enemies of peace and democracy, but also as enemies of the Jewish working classes."
The attacks of the Soviet press broadened out from the doctors themselves to other Jews, variously accused of divulging state secrets, embezzlement, fraud, falsification of state records, dissipation of state funds, and a range of other crimes.
Like the "cosmopolitans" of 1948, these "hidden enemies" were discovered everywhere.
The ground was being prepared, as Khrushchev later revealed, the mass deportation of Soviet Jews to Siberia and Kazakhstan. At the close of the war a number of national minorities had been uprooted from their homelands and scattered across the Soviet Union, accused of collective collaboration with the Nazis. Now Soviet Jews too were being fitted up for the same fate.
accused of disloyalty to the Soviet Union, and of being agents of American and British imperialism via the medium of Zionism.
How many tens, if not hundreds, of thousands of lives such a mass deportation would have cost remains a matter for speculation.
Stalin died in 1953, and his successors dropped both the propagancampaign centred on spurious Doctors' Plot and also the plans for the mass deportation of Soviet Jews.