8 SOVIET ANTI- SEMITISM Anti-semitism under Stalii
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-07-26Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Igor Sychov, leader of the anti-semitic organisation, Pamyat One of the most frightening by-products of the disintegration of totalitarian one-party rule in the USSR has been th growth of virulent Stan Crooke takes a look at the history of Russian Part 2 next week The current wave of antisemitism in the Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic and other republics belonging to the Soviet Union continues a centuries-long tradition.
Until the latter part of the 18th century, Jews were forbidden to take up residence in Russia, even temporarily. In the 19th century most Jews remained banned from Russia proper (where the main industrial and cultural centres emerged) and were confined to the Pale of Settlement, one of the poorest parts of Russia.
Waves of murderous anti-Jewish pogroms swept through the Tsarist Empire on more than one occasion, especially in the opening years of the 20th century, when the government encouraged the formation of the Union of the Russian People (popularly known as the Black Hundreds).
The opening years of the century also saw the production in Russia of the most notorious anti-semitic publication of the 20th century: the forged "Protocols of the Elders of Sychov, Zion", supposedly the records of the first World Zionist Congress of 1897 in which Jews were portrayed as mapping out their plans for world domination.
In the First World War Jews were held responsible for the early military defeats suffered by Russia. Correspondence and publications in Yiddish and Hebrew were banned. Jewish community leaders were falsely accused of aiding and abetting the enemy and summarily executed.
In the aftermath of the February and October Revolutions of 1917 there was a new upsurge of antisemitism. The "Protocols of the Elders of Zion" were re-published by the Whites, who claimed that the Bolshevik Revolution had been financed by a Jewish banking firm acting on behalf of world Jewry. Anti-semitic pogroms, costing the lives of between 180,000 and 200,000 Jews, were systematically carried out by the Whites.
Popular anti-semitism remained a powerful force throughout the 1920s. New laws introduced by the post-1917 government scrapped all discriminatory legislation against Jews. Professions and occupations from which Jews had formerly been barred were opened up to them. For the anti-semites this was "proof" that a Jewish takeover was under way in line with the "Protocols of the Elders of Zion" The New Economic Policy of the early '20s likewise generated antisemitism for the same reason: it benefitted those social groups in which Jews had been concentrated in pre-revolutionary times as a result of Tsarist discriminatory legislation. It was interpreted as further "evidence" of a Jewish takeover.
Anti-semitism in the Soviet Union today continues such a tradition. Nothing could be further from the truth than to suggest that recent years have seen a sudden resurgence of anti-semitism in the Soviet Union after decades in which it had been virtually non-existent: under Stalin and his successors anti-semitism was a state-sanctioned policy just as much as it had been under the Tsars.
Socialists in this country need to acquaint themselves with that tradition of anti-semitism under Stalin and with the manifestations of antisemitism in the Soviet Union today.
As Soviet society continues its spiral of decline, the ground is becoming increasingly fertile for the politics of anti-semitism and outright fascism of a Western European variety.
Labour movements are hot immune to anti-semitism - in the opening years of the century sections of the British labour movement campaigned for immigration controls to exclude Jews. It would be a tragedy if the labour and trade union movement now re-emerging in the Soviet Union from the shadow of Stalinism were to fail to challenge this powertul tradition of anti-semitism head on.
Socialists in this country must provide support for the victims of anti-semitism in the Soviet Union today, and support those fighting to eradicate anti-semitism from the new Soviet workers' movement and from Soviet society as a whole.
Anti-semitism flourished A in the Soviet Union in the late 1920s. Communist Party agit-prop workers cited as typical questions with which they were confronted: "Is it true that Jews avoid physical labour?", "Is it true that there are no Jews at the Unemployment Exchanges?", "Is it true that there are excessive numbers of Jews in educational institutions?", "Do Jews avoid military service?" and "Do Jews govern the Soviet Union?"
In 'Jews and Anti-Semitism in the USSR' published in 1929, typical questions which had been raised in discussions with members and sympathisers of the Communist Party included: "Won't Jews be traitors in the event of war, and don't Jews avoid military service?" "Why did Jews lead an easy life earlier on, and still do now?" "Why did Jews constitute 76% of the party opposition?", and "Why do Stalin, Bukharin, and other members of the Politburea never write in Pravda about antisemitism?"
One reason why Stalin failed to write in the Soviet press in opposition to anti-semitism was that he was anti-semitic himself, and became increasingly so as time went on. As Khrushchev recalled in his memoirs: "Stalin also cultivated this anti-semitic 'bacteria' and did not set an example of how to liquidate it. Within himself Stalin was unconditionally subject to that shameful inadequacy which bears the name 'anti-semitism'."
When Stalin's eldest son, Yakov, married a Jewess, "that displeased father," recalled Stalin's daughters in her memoirs, "he never liked Jews, though in those days he was not yet as blatant about expressing his hatred for them as he was after the war." And when Stalin's daughter married a Jew herself, her father's response was equally • hostile: "He was Jewish, and my father did not like that."
In public Stalin formally condemned anti-semitism, in line with the official tenets of the Communist Party. In an interview of 1931 with a correspondent of the Jewish Telegraph Agency, Stalin describec anti-semitism as "an extreme form of racial chauvinism and the most dangerous survival of cannibalism" . It was "a phenomenon profoundly hostile to the Soviet regime and is sternly repressed in the USSR." In practice, however, Stalin's politics were riddled with In the faction fight munist Party in the mid-1920s, Stalin appealed to anti-semitic prejudice. Initially he did so cautiously and covertly, referring to his opponents as "small-town pett bourgeoisie" , a social grouping 1r which Jews had traditionally been well represented. But when Zinoviev and Kamenev left Stalin's faction and openly lined up with Trotsky, Stalin took this as an opportunity to denounce his opponents as "dissatisfied Jewish intellectuals""
In the later stages of the faction fight Stalin's use of anti-semitism became even more overt: "Not only in the countryside but even in Moscow factories the baiting of the Opposition back in 1926 often assumed a thoroughly obvious antisemitic character. Many agitators spoke brazenly: "The Jews are rioting'. I received hundreds of letters deploring the anti-semitic methods employed in the struggle with the Opposition...In the second half of 1927 the anti-semitic agitation assumed a thoroughly unbridled character. The slogan Beat the Opposition' often took on the complexion of the old slogan 'Beat the Jews and save Russia' (slogan of he Tsarist Black Hundreds)," wrote Trotsky.
"In the course of the 1930s Jews were removed by one means another from the Communist Party Central Committee, higher governmental organs, the army, and other leading bodies in the Party and As Stalin consolidated his grip on Soviet society, the level of repression of Jews and Jewish organisations and institutions rose in tandem. In the late 1920s a wave of persecution of rabbis and 'magids' (travelling preachers) was unleashed, while synagogues were closed down en masse after they had been portrayed in anti-religious propaganda as meeting places for "profiteers' and 'parasitical anti-Soviet elements' In 1930 the Communist Party "Yevsektsii' (Jewish Sections, set up in 1918 within the framework of the Bolshevik Party in order to promote the struggle against antisemitism and to increase Jewish recruitment to the Party) were shut down, although they were already defunct in reality; they had not been able to hold a conference since 1924.
In the course of the 1930s Jews were removed by one means or another from the Communist Party Central Committee, higher governmental organs, the army, and other leading bodies in the Party and state. The Stalinist purges of the mid-1930s took a particularly heavy toll amongst Jews, who tormed a disproportionately large percentage of the Old Bolsheviks and the higher army ranks. The 'fact' that so many Jews were among the "saboteurs' intent upon overthrowing Soviet power reinforced popular Jewish cultural institutions and schools began to be shut down throughout the country in the late 1930s. The persecution of rabbis was stepped up; just at a time when the persecution of Jews in Nazi Germany was about to reach its peak, the Soviet authorities hunted down rabbis as alleged spies for the fascist secret services. The Soviet Jewish press (what was left of it) reported a growing number of incidents of anti-semitic violence and discrimination in jobs.
Although such incidents continued to be officially condemned, this did not prevent an article in the Soviet Atheist newspaper, written just after the signing of the Stalin-Hitler Pact, arguing that the Nazi attack on the Jewish religion was the principal achievement of the Third Reich, and that it was the duty of Soviet atheists to assist their "allies" in the fight against religion.
With the invasion of the Soviet Union by Hitler in 1941 the Soviet government adopted, on the surlace, a more conciliatory attitude towards Jews, anxious to mobilise them, like every other national minority of the Soviet Union, in the "Great Patriotic War": in August of 1941 Moscow Radio broadcast an appeal to "Brider Yiden"
(Brother Jews) calling for a united struggle against fascism in order to defeat the threat to Jews posed by Erlich and Alter, two leaders of the Polish Bund awaiting execution in the Soviet Union, were selected by one of Beria's henchmen to head "Jewish Anti-Fascist Committee". But Stalin remembered the two as Mensheviks who had opposed the October Revolution and had them shot before they could play their allotted role. Their place was taken by Solomon Mikhoels, a leading Jewish actor, and Izik Feffer, a Red Army colonel and poet laureate who had glorified in verse the attacks of the Mufti in Jerusalem on Jews in Palestine.
The Jewish Anti-Fascist Committee was never anything other than a small group of selected people acting as a public relations agency for the Soviet government. Although it published a Yiddish periodical and its leaders (ie. its only members) toured the allied countries to make the appropriate noises (on one such trip to London Mikhoels described Zionism as a "great idea", , though, of course, entirely irrelevant to Soviet Jewry, given its deep attachment to the Soviet Union), it was never anything other than a mouthpiece for the propaganda of the Soviet government.
In areas of the Soviet Union occupied by the Nazis in the early 1940s, Jews were rounded up and deported to concentration camps or killed on the spot. Sections of the local population, influenced by the older tradition of Tsarist antisemitism the more recent. Stalinist Jew-baiting, co-operated with the Nazis in such activities or even staged their own pogroms before the arrival of the Nazis.' In the non-occupied areas of the Soviet Union, and also amongst the Red Army in the front line, antisemitism continued to thrive. In hospitals, labour camps, jails and the army, anti-semitic expressions and comments were common. too were the traditional anti-semitic aceusations: Jews were avoiding the call-up, they were afraid of hard work, they were cowards, they were making a living by exploiting the wartime shortages, etc.
Jews returning to their homes in the closing period of the war after the Nazis had begun to retreat faced continuing anti-semitic persecution. In Ukraine in particular, where anti-semitism had been especially virulent for centuries, returning Jews were often treated with open animosity. In Kharkov Jews had to stay indoors at night for fear of attack. In Kiev a series of attacks, including one virtual pogrom in which 16 Jews were killed, was carried out against returning Jews.
The authorities remained largely indifferent to such events, attributing them to the local population having been infected by the anti-semitism of the Nazis and declaring that such a disposition could be eliminated only gradually. In any case, the authorities pandered to popular anti-semitism