A majority for socialism
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-07-26Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
hère is a majority in Britain for the general idea of socialism, according to a recent opinion survey.
In their new book We British Eric Jacobs and Robert Worcester report that "we asked whether people favoured a mainly capitalist society in which private interests and free enterprise are more important' , or 'a mainly socialist society in which public interests and a more controlled économy are portant.
*The socialist society beat the capitalist by an outright eight points, 47% to 39%: by three points with men, but twelve with women; by only two points with those over 55 years, but by twelve with those between 15 and 34; by two with home owners but by thirty-one with council tenants; by two with non trade unionists but by thirty-one with trade unionists."
The researchers checked to see if this response was a quirk of the way the question had been asked. Such quirks certainly exist. The book reports that 60% of people believe in heaven, but only 49% in life after death. 92% say they belong to one religion or another, but ony 75% believe in god.
On a more directly comparable issue, asking whether "we should reduce pay differentials as much as possible" produced a different result from asking whether people preferred "a society which emphasises similar incomes and rewards for everyone" to one which allows people to make and keep as much money as they can". The first question showed a 49% to 24% majority for equality, the second a 52%-40% majority against.
The poll majority for socialism against capitalism was, however, confirmed by other questions. Clear and often big majorities preferred *a society in which the caring for others is more highly regarded" to "in which the creation of one wealth is more highly regarded", and one "which emphasises the social and collective provision of welfare" to one "where the individual is encouraged to look after himself"
They favoured higher taxes to pay for better welfare, protection of the environment at the expense of economic growth, and general education to education geared to what employers want.
Classifying people as *Thatcherists" (ie. supporters of Thatcher's social philosophy, though not necessarily of her personally) or "socialists" , Jacobs and Worcester find a 54% to 34% majority of socialists over Thatcherists.
Socialists are a 64%-24% majority in the manual working class, and a 54%-42% majority among routine non-manual workers; but a 42%-49%o minority in the petty bourgeoisie.
Another finding by Jacobs and Worcester is equally startling for these days when socialism and the working • class are supposed to belong with the dinosaurs. 67 per cent of people describe themselves as "working class" . In 1949, only 43% would so describe themselves.
This result is less solid than the others, because today's question was not exactly the same as 1949's.
If class identification and support for socialist values (however vaguely conceived) are so widespread, why isn't the left stronger? One figure poses the question very sharply: twenty-six per cent of Tory voters said they preferred socialism to capitalism. Why do they vote Tory?
Other opinion poll evidence, and everyday experience of election canvassing, indicate an answer. Large majorities favour the general values which they associate with Labour and socialism over the general values which they associate with the Tories and capitalism. But equally large majorities believe that Labour is vague, ineffectual, and untrustworthy, whereas the Tories at least know what they're doing.
The Labour leaders' panic-stricken retreat to a stance where their most daring social criticism is a jibe about the Tories being disunited or incompetent is not a necessary accommodation to public opinion. It helps to dissipate support for Labour.
Dewsbury 82 Innocent Chapeltown Road, Leeds 7 Workers Association Self-defence is no offence
Scan page 6
Patrick Laffont O fats of the USSR. n 11 July a 24 hour strike coalfields of the USSR.
Around the same time last year, a strike which started in some pits. in the Kuzbass (western Siberia) spread to the whole of that region and from there to the Donbass coalfield in the Ukraine. Faced with 200,000 strikers, the government had seemed to concede most of the strike committees' demands - better supplies, better conditions of work, more money for mining regions, wage rises.
Distrusting the government, the miners did not demobilise. In a number of places, they decided to maintain the strike committees to check on the carrying out of the agreements which had been signed. They were right to do so because, once work had restarted, the authorities were in no hurry to keep their promises.
miners character. It was and demanded the Last autumn, in Vorkuta, the miners of the North went on strike again, accusing the government of continuing the anti-working-class policy started by Stalin. But the other coalfields did not join the Vorkuta miners.
Was it because they feared that the public would not understand, with the authorities and the press accusing the strikers of creating difficulties with heating in the middle of winter? Or because some strike committee leaders in the Donbass and the Kuzbass distrusted what the press called the political extremism of Vorkuta? Such factors probably worked against the extension of the movement.
A little over a month ago, rumours of a strike began circulating yet again. This time it started in the Kuzbass. In Pravda of 4 June, a CP official in that region, A.Melnikov attributed the strike rumours to the lack of supplies in that region (almost no eggs, cooked meat, or poultry, and no fresh meat in the State shops), and blamed it on the authorities of the agricultural regions, who were supposed to supply the Kuzbass but were_conducting a "delivery strike", In the end there was no strike, because no agreement could be reached between the representatives of the Kuzbass miners and the Donbass, who seemed to be waiting for the CP congress.
But discontent remained everywhere, for as regards supplies the North and the East were even worse off than Kuzbass. As for the conditions of work in the mines, they are horrific. A recent issue of Komsomolskaya Pravda puts the figure of workers who have died in mine accidents in the last nine years at 10,000 — almost as many as the number of soldiers who died in nine years of war in Afghanistan!
The strike on 11 July drew in many more coalfields than last year's. According to the authorities, the call by the Donbass strike committees had a massive response.
Out of 250 pits in the Donbass, 140 were halted for 24 hours and 110 for varying lengths of time. Around Kemerovo, in the Kuzbass, 66 mines stopped for 24 hours, and 11 other enterprises also struck. In the Vorkuta coalfield, 11 mines out of 13 were shut down, and some factories and one state farm did the same.
In the Karagana coalfield, in Kazakhstan, 11 pits were totally shut down, 26 were stopped for several hours, and workers in other workplaces showed their solidarity by striking.
Other regions which did not strike last year were also affected. In the Far East, on Sakhalin island, 8 mines and about ten factories struck. There were also strikes in Magadan and Norilsk, in eastern Siberia, and in Novosibirsk, in western Siberia.
This miners' general strike had an openly political character. It was indeed organised to come bang in the middle of the 28th Congress of the CP, and demanded the resignation of the government, and especially of the prime minister, Ryzhkov, who had not honoured the agreements of 1989.
Shortly before 11 July, appeals were published which were said to come from the strike committees. An "appeal to the Soviet people and leadership" from the Donbass strike committee, which had initiated the movement, declared that "in the face of reaction... we can no longer wait while the government and the Party apparatus which dictates to it... lead us into hunger, poverty and ruin".
A communique signed by three leaders of the Donetsk strike committee and sent to Moscow "to be read at the 28th Congress" demanded the resignation of the government and the formation of a "government of national which is the only way... to get the country out of its crisis"
It continued: "The politica struggle between conservatives and reformists, which has gone on for 5 years... is leading the country to economic and political bankruptcy. We can no longer content ourselves with the half-measures of the government and of the Supreme Soviet, which are under the dictat of the party apparatus". It called for the nationalisation of the CP's property, and the suppression of the party in the workplaces, the ar my, the KGB and the police "in order to rule out the possibility of a coup d'etat organised by the party and the generals".
It is difficult to know how far the strikers identified with these declarations. But it is clear that they chime in with themes pushed at the 28th Congress of the CP by the "radicals" round Boris Yeltsin and, to a lesser extent, by Gorbachev's supporters. And that is not surpris ing.
In the Donbass, many leaders of the 1989 strike committees were elected to parliament last spring, under the auspices of the Gorbachevites or Yeltsinites. It was the same in the Kuzbass, and there too a Confederation of Labour was created, whose slogans for the strike took up the declarations quoted above almost word for word.
Clearly workers identify with this Confederation of Labour, since it claims almost a million members across the country" the Officially constituted this spring, this is a sort of trade union independent from the official unions, led, among others, by members of the Democratic Union (an organisation which makes no secret about fighting for the restoration of capitalism), by activists from organisations close to Yeltsin, who openly asserts his desire to see "the market" and "private property" restored, and by Gorbachev supporters. -Clearly workers do identify with this Confederation of Labour, since it claims almost a million members across the country. But its members do not in any way represent the interests of the Soviet working class.
It is revealing that in. summer 1989 they threw all their weight into convincing former strikers in the Kemerovo region that they should not call their paper Workers' Gazette but Gazette of the Working People, on the grounds that the word "worker" was too "restrictive" . At the founding of the Confederation, its president explained in the press that it brought together not only workers, but "working people" of all social categories, though not such a wide range as he would like.
From here we cannot judge to what extent the workers who struck on 11 July identify with the groups which the Soviet press has presented as their leaders. But it seems clear that these Yeltsinites, social-democrat, pro-Western-capitalist and Gorbachevite currents wanted to use the strike for their own ends, if only to tip the balance in the struggles going on at the top of the CP and the State.
We also don't know whether there exist among the miners groups arguing for independent working-class politics, fighting the bureaucracy but in the name of the working class and not of a return to capitalism.
Such an organisation would obviously also have fought for the strike to be "political"' (besides, what strike of that size in the Soviet Union could not be political?) Bu would have tought for the miner: put forward a policy correspond to the interests of the working cl not a policy which put the miner tow to this or that faction of bureaucracy, least of all those openly demand a return capitalism.
would have fought for that de facto autonom of the striking miners become conscious ang political, [for the necessity for the workers to take the political and econom leadership of the country in their own hands"
In last year's strike, it precisely the workers of the bass who showed the wor class's immense possibilities autonomous organisation, if no of autonomous politics. Then, striking miners practically tral: the control and administ the region. They themselves after supplies and Chen duties. The police were
Scan page 7
turn capitali it to ing AsS, he ho to nt unable to operate in the region.
A revolutionary current among the miners would have fought for that de facto autonomy of the striking miners to become conscious and political. It would have fought against the present government and its policy, not in the name of a "coalition government" but of the necessity for the workers to take the political and economic leadership of the country in their own hands. It would have opposed the propagation of illusions about what the police, the KGB and the army would be if they were just rid of their party cells. It would have fought for the workers themselves to take over the duties of the police - as they did to a certain extent last year.
It would have argued that, against the danger of a coup d'etat, the only policy corresponding to workers' interests was to render the general staff incapable of any moves against the working class by splitting away its base, the rank and file soldiers.
It would have sought to convince the miners who were rightly concerned with this question that they must have a class policy in relation to the soldiers, who mostly come from the working class, and that they must use their numbers to build links with them.
And such a group would, of course, have fought among the miners against any idea of the restoration of capitalism, against any idea of the private appropriation of the factories and the miners, and for the replacement of the domination of the economy by the bureaucrats with the running of the economy under the democratic control of the working people. "..most of those who intervene and try to channel the struggle represent not the working class's interests, but those of its class enemies"
In the present situation, these objectives are clearly difficult for the working class. Not because it lacks initiative and human resources, but because most of those who intervene and try to channel the struggle represent not the working class's interests but those of its class enemies.
The concern of those people to pull the working class behind them, or at least to neutralise it (this has been visible in recent months not only in strikes, but also in national conflicts, and, in filigree, in elections and in numerous articles in the press) - that concern shows that they fear the working class may intervene on the political and social scene on its own account.
That fear should give confidence and strength to Soviet revolutionaries.
Translated from the French Socialist weekly Lutte Ouvrière.
Harry Mol ne of the most surprising Oin Eater Burope is how in Eastern Europe is how easily the bureaucrats gave up their monopoly of power and their political privileges.
True, some of them played with the idea of sending in the troops and the security forces to "reestablish order". But, all except Causescu, they saw reason and did not do it.
One of the reasons for this new behaviour is that many of the bureaucrats were convinced that they could save themselves in dividually by finding a niche in the new regime. And for some careerists, the "free market" has advantages: no more need to hide when opening a bank account abroad, no more need of special shops for the "nomenklatura" everything can be done openly. A bureaucrat can adopt to the new situation in many ways. Where possible, he tries to go over to the camp of the winners. He can also, as in Bulgaria and in Romania, change the name and flag of his organisation. He can speculate with state or party property. He can become a businessman.
These possibilities have been tried out in Poland since the end of 1981. After Jaruzelski's military coup, demoralised citizens tried to find individual solutions to their everyday problems. The whole society was converted to self-help. For the majority of Poles, it was a matter of surviving, but for various sections of the nomenklatura, it was a new opportunity to build up real capitalist fortunes alongside their privileges of office.
Often they already had a rich experience of corruption, in the form of bribes, extracted, for example, in return for pushing people forward on the housing list. Under martial law, speculation on provisions gave them new chances to "accumulate capital".
Poland is not an isolated case: in the Soviet Union, too, bureaucrats have built up secret stocks of consumer goods in order to make fortunes on the black But all that is small beer in comparison to the opportunities for enrichment opened up today by the "free market". The East European bureaucrats have not failed to notice that their Chinese colleagues, by playing the capitalist game, have managed to accumulate considerable wealth for themselves and their families over the last ten years.
Obviously, China's new rich have the advantage of a highly-placed patron, while the East European bureaucrats have lost their positions of power. But they still hold other trump cards: connections (including abroad), know-how, and a total absence of ideological scruples for, outside their own interests, these people have no ideology at all.
The apparatchiks of the Czechoslovak CP are in the process of trying out the various possibilities. Of the 11 CP ministers in the coalition government at the end of last year, six left the party at the beginning of this year to put themselves in the ranks of the future rulers, that is, Civic Forum and Public Against Violence.
The ex-prime minister Calfa was candidate of Public Against Violence in the recent elections; vice prime minister Komarekt was a candidate of the Civic Forum; and young Dlouhy, formerly a minister and chief of the State Planning Commission, is considered today to be a rising star of Civic Forum.
Not everyone, of course, is lucky as that. The middle layers of the bureaucracy are trying to base their survival on the extensive property owned by the party.
It is not straightforward, because the CP leaders considered the State as the property of the party to such an extent that they did not even take the trouble to put the State property which they used for their own benefit under the party's name.
Despite that lack of foresight, a government commission estimates the value of the party's property at about 20 billion crowns (about £3.6 billion). Some party cadres have abandoned their dangerous jobs to set up cooperatives which, as if by magic, have bought buildings and equipment from the CP for peanuts.
In other words, these rogues have set up businesses with CP funds which were acquired by the "confusion" of party and state.
Thousands of apparatchiks are thus ready to find a comfortable place in the sun in the privatised economy. In Czechoslovakia as in Poland, this situation causes resentment in the working class. But a Civic Forum sociologist responds: "Why not let them do what they're capable of?' In Poland, Walesa and his advisers are consciously playing on the great discontent aroused among the workers by the spectacle of the exnomenklatura enriching itself for all to see. While the population will see its standard of living go down by an average of 40 per cent this year, tens of thousands of Polish bureaucrats are in the process of laundering funds previously acquired through corruption and speculation into new sectors. And these are not small sums.
In Hungary, the bureaucrats had already, since 1968, been experimenting with a "new economic mechanism" which got into full swChinese bureaucrats are prepared to discipline workers ing in the '80s. Following the Chinese example, tens of thousands of bureaucrats have got rich by "supplementary" activities in commercial or service sectors, or by transforming themselves or members of their families into business people. This social group constitutes the base of the Entrepreneurs' Party, which stood in the recent elections and got good scores in the chic areas of Budapest.
The young guard of the Hungarian nomenklatura is wife of a top official in the Foreign Ministry has set up a language laboratory for candidate diplomats, top managers in State enterprises are establishing consultancies, and so on.
What particularly irritates people is the way in which those State enterprises which are doing well are sold to foreign companies by bureaucrats who save their jobs as part of the deal. The Tungsram electrical goods company, for example, was sold for peanuts, via a banking manoeuvre, to the multinational General Electric. The managers of the best public hotel chain, Hungarhotels, have offered the 50 hotels of the group to a Swedish company at a derisory price... on condition that their jobs are guaranteed!
The Soviet Union is no exception to this tendency for the apparatchiks to profit from the new situa tion.. There too, they try to safeguard their privileges with new tricks.
Moscow had three polyclinics and eleven thermal stations reserved for Party officials. The new city administration just elected in March has decided to open them to the whole population.
But the management still reserves a third of the places for people who have a voucher from the City or party authorities. The only ditferences is that now these bodies have to pay for a privilege which before they took for free.
Translated from the French socialist weekly Rouge.
----- pull-quotes -----
NATIONAL HE SOCIAL SER
ALTH VICES
National Demo Police Brutality
general strike haa openly political
indeed organised come bang in the middle of the 28th Congress of the CP.
resignation of the government..
"A revolutionary among the miners
discovering a whole series of new possibilities for getting rich: the