The workers' alternative in Eastern Europe
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-07-26Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
Mark Osborn, National Secretary of the Campaign for Solidarity with Workers in the Eastern Bloc (CSWEB) writes a personal comment on the reaction on the left to the visit of Soviet miners' representative Yuri Budchenko who, while in Britain, sided with the scab UDM against the NUM Last time I wrote to Sociali Worker, my letter was so badly doctored the only possible sense which could be made of it was the opposite to the one I intended.
So, I will not be replying in th SW letters page to their recent remarks about Yuri Budchenko.
Budchenko is the Soviet independent union representative who recently appeared on TV alongside UDM-er, Roy Lynk.
Budchenko went to the British press to demand the return of money taken from Soviet miners by official "unions' for the welfare of British miners during the 1984-85 strike. He was incensed that the money ended up with the iMo, which includes many of the Stalinist state "unions", , which he and other Eastern Bloc workers know to fakes and to be the tools of management and the anti-working class Stalinist states.
Budchenko's claims were used in the press witch-hunt of Scargill.
It would seem that the left's denunciations of Yuri Budchenko are motivated by two factors: his association with scab leader Roy Lynk and his association with the claims that Scargill is corrupt.
In addition, the British labour movement is riddled with Stalinist sympathisers, and mar activists are searching for fault: Is Budchenko "pro-capitalist'? Has he got horns?
Socialist Worker ought to know better. But they will do anything to get a few recruits. it means avoiding a difficult argument about Stalinism's effects on the emerging Russian labour movement, so be it.
SW claim that Budchenko denounced the strike committees formed during last year's strikes" and "made no criticism of the official trade unions".
An independent observer might think this a little careless - for the representative of an independent union based on the strike committees of last year's miners' strikes, which was set up in opposition to and in order to replace the official unions.
And SW goes on: Budchenko "condemned" the socialist unior that is what SWP members ha been saying. He told me the of posite.
It is true that many Soviet workers are influenced by Yeltsin and representatives of the new miners' union (not, as SW states, the Kuzbass Worke Union) met Yeltsin, who tried t persuade them not to strike. However, Yuri Budchenko left Britain before the strikes of 11 July saying he was going back to help organise them.
Is Budchenko a scab? He spent 9 years in a labour camp for giving out leaflets, and has been a leader of independent, militant unions. He is no scab or Soviet workers' struggles.
Is Budchenko a scab for meeting the UDM? Even assuming Budchenko is a cynic and a fake, what he says has some force. It is what other Soviet workers are saying, and will say He has lived under totalitarianism and been put in labour camp. He wants democracy. He wants to hear everyone's viewpoint, and decide for himself. He does not want to take anyone's word for anything. He does not want to be "given a line".
The UDM sent the striking miners in the USSR a message of support and have presumably given them "practical'' help, too. On the evidence before them, Soviet miners see the UDM as their friends.
Arthur Scargill is a friend of the anti-working class Soviet state and their fake miners "union". : Scargill was a guest the official miners' conference held in Moscow over the winter.
The 20% minority of worker delegates at that conference walked out in disgust. Scargill has denounced the independent union.
To a Soviet worker, Scargill looks like a scab; Lynk looks like a friend.
On top of Scargill's basic attitude to the "socialist states" is the Soviet miners money which now rests with the IMO. The basic issue here is: don't you think Budchenko has a right to be angry that funds donated for the miners' strike have gone to a Stalinist union international? The leaders of the Soviet official miners' "union" are members the ruling class who have oppressed Soviet miners for decades.
Finally, Budchenko has a lot less information about the UDM/NUM than Scargill has. about the Soviet scab-state unions.
The British labour movement needs to understand that these are the reasons that Soviet workers will meet the UDM. If we abandon them because they do so, the right will have an easy monopoly.
Budchenko is not "untypical"
The chaos and crisis created by the bureaucrats plan in the East European economies is clearly illustrated For workers to obtain basic day to day goods they must become hunters of goods, spending many hours queuing. It is no wonder in such circumstances that the Western market system has had a new lease of popularity among Eastern Bloc workers.
Will the market reforms and privatisation plans gear production to human need? No, my letter (SO 449) attempted to show why the reforms won't deliver the goods.
The Eastern Bloc economies are dominated by state monopolies. Privatising these monopolies will result in the domination by privately owned monopolies. An increased role for the market in such circumstances will and has led to rising prices.
How should socialists respond? Duncan Chapel SO 450) *socialists oppose the • reintroduction of the market...defend the nationalised economies against the imperialist profiteers" Does this mean a united front with Ligachev to defend the "plan" against the USSR market reformers?
The problem for the Stalinist planned industries is that workers are now voting against them with their feet.
In East Germany the shoe industry faces collapse. Is this because the "imperialist profiteers" are asset stripping? No, it is because East German workers want to buy West German shoes and not the inferior, unpopular models produced by the East German state factories.
Now, the 40,000 East German shoe workers are facing an uncertain future. It is not primarily monetary union and market competition but mismanagement by state bureaucrats which threaten their future. The state bosses failed to gear production to what consumers wanted - now the workers may have to pay for it with their jobs.
How should socialists respond? Duncan Chapel concludes his letter with a call to "defend and control the planned economy"
The first question to be asked is whose "planned economy". By implication Duncan clearly means the already existing planned economy which produces shoes no-one wants.
Obviously, Duncan calls for democratic reforms. Maybe he would agree with Ernest Mandel's model for how shoe production would be organised by a democratic workers' plan: "the product mix would flow from previous consultation between the workers' councils and consumers' conferences elected by the mass of the citizens. Various models, for example, different fashions in shoes would be submitindustry to buy.
We will need some form of planning to direct resources and decide on society-wide priorities. But the plan would not cover the myriad of details envisaged by Ernest Mandel. There must be room for some market mechanisms.
Do we support the state bureaucrats' economic reforms? No. The reforms are aimed at making workers pay for the bureaucrats' mismanagement of the economy. Their goal is the wholesale privatisation of major enterprises. The privatisation plans should be opposed. The bureaucrats' rule in the economy must be ended - but by workers? control through workers' selfmanagement.
In addressing ourselves to the East German shoe workers do we say defend jobs by ending market competition from West German imports? This would seem to be the logical position of the "defenders of the planned economy" who blame the market for all the ills facing the East European economies.
Our response instead should be no job losses, rights to redeployment and retraining on full pay, sliding scale of wages, and a shorter working week.
Articulating workers* demands and helping them organise must be the starting point for a programme of genuine socialism. The strikes which have swept the USSR, East Germany and Poland indicate that workers are fighting back to defend their interests as workers; workers should not have to pay for the bureaucrats' economic/crisis.
We need to look at how we can help the emerging independent workers' movement develop. A movement is needed which can struggle for workers' interests on the political as well as the economic front.
Workers' self-management must be posed as the alternative to the economic rule of state and private bosses. The demand for workers' self-management must be broadened from individual factories and industries.
Our goal has to be workers' selfmanagement on a society-wide level. Through this a movement of the immense majority in the interests of the immense majority can be created.
Tony Dale Manchester