Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

From Thatcher to Thailand

Socialist Organiser no. 455, 26 July 1990 · scan p. 2 · about 568 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 2

Press event of the week, overshadowing even a firebomb' attack on Princess Di, was the arrest of two young women for drug smuggling in Thailand.

In a way, the case says more about the | 'British Family' than Thatcher's latest family policy speech.

Thatcher says she believes that the family is the bedrock of our society'. She says she believes it is the best environment in which to bring up children. Her approach is classical - she notes that the family provides sustenance, education, social training, company, childcare, nurture.

What she doesn't say is that all these things are provided at no direct cost to either the state or industry - which is of course the key point. Families are primarily an economic convenience for capitalism — the ideology comes Marxists do not oppose family ideology simply because it props up capitalism. We know that it can be replaced with something better. For though the family can be a 'haven' from the outside world, it also represents female drudgery and a set of power relations which blight many lives. The economics of family life are wasteful, primitive and divisive.

The two young women who look set to spend the next 20 years in Thai jails are a case in point. Their actions were, it seems, partly (if not wholly) prompted by a desire to get away from their families.

The women wanted travel, excitement, adventure. They probably had an idea of what they were getting into, but they went ahead anyway. Ordinary life could not offer any of the excitement they craved. Apparently their parents "couldn't do a thing with them" Family life was the problem for the two.

Both families had provided everything Thatcher favours. Yet both the accused women turned into "bad 'uns"

The problem is not tamily life, it is society. The problem was not with the young women's expectations, it was with the society which could only fulfil those expectations through crime.

Options for young women, even from wealthy families, are limited. The 'biological clock' is a restriction on how much can be achieved even by the most determined women. The pressure is always on to get married and have kids, despite recent changes in the way 'society' thinks. Until then, young women are expected to get a nice job and be good. Only the most privileged girls are encouraged to experiment, to have adventures, and see the world.

Thatcher's ideas about family life are flawed through and through. They are motivated by employers who won't pay the price for liberating ordinary women from the drudgery of family life. The claustrophobia of family life produces alienation in millions of young people, and offers a horrible vision of the future for thousands of girls.

A society based on 'family values' is acceptable when the alternative is chaos. The sight of tens of thousands of hopeless and abandoned Rumanian or Brazilian children shows what can happen when the family breaks down. But Britain is one of the world's richest nations. In the Western world it is possible to move away from the claustrophobia and drudgery of the family, while ensuring that there will always be enough to eat. Britain (and the rest of the world for that matter) has the resources to give every person a safe, well fed, loving upbringing with the opportunity to have a fulfilling life after childhood.

All it needs ferently.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 455

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →