Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A different approach

Socialist Organiser no. 454, 19 July 1990 · scan p. 9 · about 585 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

THE FIGHT GOES OR Social STENTHUA LONG naid Wol -Thatcher'S football identity DON'T FI ETTERS am concerned that our approach to the Socialist Workers Party (SO 453) is overly-provocative, which is ultimately wasteful and counter-productive.

What I wish to address is not the question of the SWP's position on the Middle East - the logic of which does undoubtedly lead to a sorry support for Arab chauvinism and by extension anti-semitism -but our approach to the far left and more generally those sympathetic to socialist politics.

It should come as no surprise to anyone who has met with the realpolitik of the SWP that they are hostile to any organised criticism or dissent. 'Marxism 90' (as with their past summer schools), although described as a "week of discussion and debate" is used quite cynically not to discuss and debate with the revolutionary left, but to recruit new people to the SWP.

What discussion and debate does take place, when it is not solely SWP members providing it, comes from either invited academics/ literati or the mainstream left in general - not from revolutionary critics they view as competitors.

Incidentally, we are fortunate to have the Workers' Liberty summer school where there is genuinely the opportunity to meet with, and hear, the views of others on the left, in real, not stage-managed, discussion.

However, whilst noting the above, I am not implying that we should refrain from attempting to get a hearing for our politics from people attracted to 'Marxism 90', arguably the biggest organised annual gathering for those interested in revolutionary politics in Britain, but to consider a different method.

Firstly, we should say that Socialist Organiser stand for real and genuine dialogue between the left, to clarify issues and to build the left. So why doesn't the SWP at 'Marxism 90'? Then we should refer to their day-to-day practice in the class struggle, for example:

1. Their opportunism in selectively jumping in and out of anti-poll tax groups. 2. Their sectarianism in acting as "proxy" agents of the leadership and right-wing of the Labour Party by their siren role of luring the disaffected (rightly so!) from the Labour Party, rather than helping the left to steel themselves to reorganise and fight back inside together.

3. Their incoherence in trade union and broad left politics, for instance in the NUT and CPSA to name but two.

The points above, or others, would obviously be expanded on.

Pinally, we should state that we believe they are at serious error with their position on the Middle East. We are ready to debate them at any time, in meetings or in our press, or both, on the issues raised in the 'Open Letter to Tony Cliff' in the latest edition of Workers Liberty.

Such an approach, I believe, has a better chance of receiving a hearing and making some people stop and think, rather than one that can be readily misconstrued as some odd left group squabble over an abstruse point of doctrine. As a regular reader put it to me, "It just comes across as the latest of O'Mahony's [the editor's] bees in the bonnet!"

Our politics are too important to allow for them to be so easily belittled. We have an obligation to present them clearly to as wide a readership as possible. We should avoid at all costs falling into the role of the left pariah, or giving any ammunition to those who wish to maliciously portray us as loonies.

Bryan Edmands, South London

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 454

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →