We reply to the witch-hunters
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-07-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
60p plus 32p postage from PO Box 823, London SE15 by Socialist Organiser and Workers' Liberty El handbook for trade unionists A handbook for trade unionists. E1 plus 22p post.
Towards capitalism
In September 1983, Socialist Organiser (speaking), Jeremy Corbyn MP (right)
centre socialists were not embarrassed to call wage slavery, under the largely uncontrolled industrial and commercial tyranny of the bourgeoisie, La conference the theme but also a system in which political democracy is stifled, warped and rendered ineffective - if by democracy is meant real self-rule by the majority of the people.
No less a person than Albert Einstein can be cited to sum up our criticism of what some socialists 'How to called "bourgeois democracy". Einstein was writing 40 years ago, but things have not changed for the better in those years. "The oligarchy of private capital cannot be effectively checked even by a democratically organised political society. The members of legislative bodies are selected by political parties financed influenced by private capitalists. Moreover, private capitalists control the main sources of information (press, radio, education)."
To say that is not for us - or for Einstein - to imply that some or other of the existing "socialist" dietatorships are better. They are not. But we need the idea expressed by Einstein if we are to understand the world we live in, including such phenomena as the transformation of the Labour Party over the last few years into what it is now under the incessant pressure of the property owners and their media. With sincere revulsion and contempt I repudiate the antics and the outlook of the pseudo-religious sects, the "Leninist sects" of the document Joyce Gould cites. I do not thereby repudiate the tradition of Lenin and those who made the great working-class revolution in Russia in 1917. On the contrary, 1 believe that I thereby defend that tradition as it really was.
That the outcome in history of the 1917 revolution was - by way of Stalinist counter-revolution - a negative and horrible outcome, was not the fault of Lenin or his "tradition", but of those socialists in the West (those in whose "tradition" the majority of Labour's NEC are proud to stand) who left the Russian workers in the lurch and made their peace with their own ruling classes. Rosa Luxemburg, who was a bitter and forceful critic of some things the Bolsheviks did as well as being their partisan, said it all very well in 1918, in the course of criticising Lenin and his comrades.
•Whatever a party could offer of courage, revolutionary farsightedness and consistency in a historic hour, Lenin, Trotsky and the other comrades have given in good measure. All the revolutionary honour and capacity which western social democracy lacked were represented by the Bolsheviks. Their October uprising was not only the actual salvation of the Russian revolution, it was also the salvation of the honour of international socialism."
Post-Stalinist socialism will have to be rethought, and the elements of socialism recast. It seems to me that Lenin's tradition will and should be part of that process. It must be critically evaluated and assimilated, of course, but with loyal and honest criticism, not with bourgeois propaganda masquerading as socialist criticism.
I believe that the only point of view from which it can be asserted that such a strand of socialism has no place in the Labour Party is the point of view which wants to make Labour a one-faction party.
From that point of view not only Socialist Organiser will be considered intolerable but — if the present trends continue - all who remain loyal to and organise and fight for the basic ideas enshrined in the Labour Party constitution itself.
----- pull-quotes -----
10WL0 BEAT THE
PROBLEMS STRUGGLES