Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Defend the right to socialist dissent

Socialist Organiser no. 454, 19 July 1990 · scan p. 7 · about 1,455 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

south - Socialist Africa: go back EE VICTINS SIMF SUSHIRE SACKED Election special SOLVARITYORGANISE FOR I GENERAL STRIKE!

Fight the Toriest Rebuild the Left!

cond HEALTH EMERC "Socialist Organiser is a small body, loosely organised around a newspaper. Its socialist credentials are beyond reproach. Its sympathiser - like many other socialists in the party -may hold minority views. But they are loyal members of the Labour Party, an asset to it, and they will, I understand, be happy to make any adjustments to their activity which the NEC may require.

This, however, would rather interfere with the NEC's likely plans of disqualifying Lol Duffy.

Hence the NEC may deem it necessary to build up Socialist Organiser into a Merseyside bug-bear, and on this basis proceed against it.

These methods are alien to Labour's democratic tradition and should be condemned. Members must be alerted to the drift away from party democracy and towards intolerance and must mobilise against it."

Vladimir Derer With yet other peoj sle I was expelled in 1971 when the IS/SWP decided to shut down its internal democracy and move towards the Stalinist concept of a one-faction most of those who thought the best course was high rates had parted company with Socialist Organiser, the discussion continued.

We have had the only debates on the left in the '80s on the European Community. The same with Ireland: in no other paper has there been a wide-ranging discussion - a discussion involving particpants from the full range of the left — on Ireland's long war. We have discussed the Arab-Israeli conflict at length, and, more recently, the nature of the old systems in Eastern Europe.

In those discussions the people who are assigned the roles of high priests and gurus in the document Joyce Gould uses have had to participate "on the floor", arguing their case with the same rights as other participants and no privileges. I am SO's pope according to the document: the pages of the paper show me arguing in democratic debate - and not infrequently being abused - on questions ranging from Ireland through Europe to the Middle East. I have been in the minority in some of those debates - on the Middle East, for example - for a long, long time.

li Socialist Organiser were in fact organised like the cults and sects I have described above, then it would

"I've read Socialist

Organiser for many years, and I believe that such papers are an important -part of building a broad movement for socialiam I think the purpose of the new moves is to coparate the electoral machine from any interest in politics.

I used to think the target was the left, then the unions, then the party, but now I just don't think they want any 1-- of any kind at all.

They think that people on the left have nowhere else to go so they're going to vote Labour, and there aren't many of them anyway, so they're raiding deep into the Owen/Heseltine territory - that's what they think.

It isn't trama-daly In avnoive. As a strategy it's disreputable. But I think that's the explanation for what the Labour leaders are doing now.

Every time they clobber the left they seem to go up in the polls. That's the beginning and end of it.

They'll do fund-raising outside the party, get the support of Robert Maxwell, and hope this u carry them in. I don' tink they're 14-- 1i politics, let alone socjalium. Politics, for them, are a subsidiary of advertising."

Tony Benn party. The SWP's experience with that concept should not encourage the Labour Party to follow suit now.

3.6. Workers' Action was not produced by the I-CL, nor was, or dissolve when its alleged gurus and leaders were subjected to such rules and such treatment, when the freedom in the pages of the paper exercised by Socialist Organiser supporters challenged the leading Ideas with argument, scorn, irony or denial. In fact Socialist Organiser has thrived on such discussion because we are a democratic collective, committed to rational democratic working-class politics, not a cult with gurus and disciples.

The indisputable evidence of what Socialist Organiser is, is there for the examining in the files of the paper. A sect like, say, Militant could not survive if it ran an open paper like Socialist Organiser.

In short, the attempt by the author of Joyce Gould's document to identity Socialist Organiser with the "Leninist" cults shows simply that the author does not understand the nature of the thing he or she wants to denounce. The author gets all the detail of how Socialist Organiser functions wrong, but even if some of it were accurate he or she would still be like the small child who notices that matches are red and then tries to make matches by dipping sticks in red paint. The author simply does not understand the nature of the things being compared and analysed, does not understand why they are what they are and how it all fits together.

could have been, the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory "controlled" by the I-CL.

3.7. Nobody was, has been, or (in the nature of our structure can be expelled from the SCLV or the Socialist Sumber of supanisters of the SCLA did break away from it in early 1980, some to launch Labour Briefing, others in other directions; but it was their choice, arising out of a political disagreement, quite publicly and hotly debated in the pages of Socialist Organiser, about the then left-wing majority policy of high rate rises to counter Thatcher's cuts.

3.8. Again, the staff at our office is not self-appointed, but elected by our National Editorial Board.

3.9. Our AGM this year was open to all Labour Party members (as in previous years) and this time also to a BBC Newsnight crew. Anyone who was there can testify that the nominations for the NEB all came trom the floor, not from some *Executive Committee" and anyway there were 25 elected, not 34.

There has never been an election at a gathering of Socialist Organiser supporters in which nominations were limited - according to the Stalinist version of "democratic centralism" - to an official slate. rights to stand for office, and to All participants have had equal 3.10. The arguments that ap pear in the internal bulletins" are no different to those which appear in the paper. produce duplicated discussion bulletins not for conspiratorial reasons, but because some of our debates - for example, recently, on what's happening in Eastern Europe generate more writing than can be fitted into the paper without boring newer readers. We can supply NEC members with copies of the discussion bulletins if you wish.

3.11. No-one associated with Socialist Organiser lives at 54a Peckham Rye. (Visit the address and check! Why would it matter if they did? Only because the document, in the worst gutter-press traditions, wants to create an impression of us as weird people, 'pure from thought tainted by sub. jective circumstances", whatever that means, living all huddled together in a squalid coven.

3.12. The paper is printed by Press Link International Ltd, who operate not in Rye Lane but at the Elephant and Castle. This information can be got by reading any copy of Socialist Organiser: but yet again the anonymous author is evidently much more interested in his lurid tales of revolutionary covens of exIRA men than in such humdrum research as simply reading the paper!!

3.13. As noted above, Socialist Organiser is not organised in some sort of militarist Or hierarchical "democratic centralist" fashion. It does not have "different types of members"; all our supporters have an equal say.

3.14. In short: the document is better suited to the pages of the Sun than to the consideration of the NEC, though even the Sun would probably bin it for lack of journalistic professionalism.

If the Labour Party bans Socialist Organiser on the basis of this document, then it will have Labour Party itself — at its right to dealt a far bigger blow at the claim it is a democratic party than at Socialist Organiser. What is Socialist Organiser?

That, positively, is Socialist Organiser? What exactly is our socialism?

We think capitalism at Toot depends on the exploitation of wage labour by the owners of large property. We want to end that system by the working class acting to end it, and replace it by collective, cooperative, self-controlling ownership of the means of production. It is the goal expressed in the Labour Party's Clause IV Part 4.

We think the system we live under is not only one of exploitation, of what earlier Labour Party

----- pull-quotes -----

RGET MINERS!

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 454

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →