[Is Socialist Organiser a 'Le From front page…]
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-07-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
Is Socialist Organiser a 'Le From front page It is similar to the right-wing extremist smear-sheets which try to prove that the Labour Party is controlled by the KGB on the grounds that some members of the Party leadership may once had been in the Communist Party or may be active in some campaign where the Communist Party is also involved. In fact it is much more slipshod, sloppy and careless than most of the right-wing's smear sheets.
By listing some of the more gross lies (or errors of fact) I do not accept everything else in the document as correct: virtually every sentence is inaccurate or slanderous. i do demonstrate, I think, that the NEC must reject the whole document as completely untrustworthy.
2. I'll start, however, by outlining the facts on the matters that the document refers to.
As can be seen by looking at any issue of our paper, the editor of Socialist Organiser is John O'Mahony (not O'Mahoney: the corren apeliy isan be the pal bry but that amount of research seems to have been too much for the anonymous author or authors). Sean Matgamna is in fact just the Gaelic form of my name.
Before joining the Labour Party I was associated with various other socialist groups and newspapers. I have never made any secret of this. So were many other Labour Party members, including members of the NEC!
According to the weekly paper of one of the splinter WRPs, Workers Press, Joyce Gould herself was a founder member of the organisation that became Gerry Healy's WRP, the Socialist Labour League, in early 1959, thirty-one years ago.
Crooks, Patrick Murphy and Jahn O Mak SO's editor John O'Mahony: the "confidential" document accuses him of all manner of sins She has reconsidered certain things since then. So have I, though not in quite the same way.
A handful of other associates of our paper were also involved in some of those groups and newspapers. But only a handful; and none were involved with me in all the same groups as me at the same times. Socialist Organiser is not a continuation of a group which formed itself outside the Labour Party and then "entered"
The Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory was set up, and SO was launched, in 1978. The chair of its launch conference was Ted Knight, then leader of Lambeth Council, and its Secretary was Mike Davis, later an associate of the Labour Coordinating Committee. I was its organiser. Ken Livingstone was a keynote speaker. It was not "controlled" by the "International Communist League" or any such 21.ou The debate on Palestine, Zionism and anti-semitism (including "Trotsky and Zionism/)
"A Workers! Liberty pamphlet group.
Throughout its existence Socialist Organiser has been run openly and democratically. Meetings of local supporters' groups are open to all Labour Party members. The AGM each year, which elects the National Editorial Board, is publicly advertised and open to all Labour Party members. This year it was even filmed for television by BBC Newsnight. The editor and the editorial staff are elected to their Jobs by the NEB, not by any shady "Secretariat"!
All these facts can be checked. If members of the NEC would like to attend our next National Editorial Board and see for themselves, they will be welcome. 3. A selection from the document:
3.1. I was born in 1941, not 1943. I was brought to England by my parents as a child of 12. Precocious I may have been, but I had not at that age been a member of the IRA! In fact I have never been a member of the IRA or any Republican group.
I know of no rumours that I was ever on an IRA "hit-list" or that I have been "an informer" Presumably all this stuff is stuck in to create associations with military conspiracies and romantic guerilla revolutionaries.
In fact anyone who knows the history of the Republican Movement — and I have written quite a bit about it over the last 25 years -will doubt the existence of an "IRA hit-list" in the '60s, certainly after 1962 when the IRA declared a ceasefire. Socialist Organiser is not the only thing the author of this document is disablingly ignorant 3.2. I was for a while a member (in England) of' the Irish Workers?
The document lays out the thesis that Socialist Organiser is an organisation like Militant. Now I opposed and oppose the proscription of Militant; I believe that where Militant acts harmfully it must be fought politically. But it is false to equate Socialist Organiser with Militant.
The document tries to "prove" its case in two ways. The first stage of one "proof" is asserting that all such groups as Militant are formed around one individual; Socialist Organiser is said to be so organised itop the racists cashing in!
Perty fair me
Group, but in the mid-'60s, not the early '60s, when that group did not exist.
3.3. I was indeed earlier a member of the SLL, then very briefly associated with Militant, an *Leninist" groups and of sects like Militant, the WRP and the SW, to which they allege Socialist Organiser is identical, they plainly do not understand how such sects function or what it is that gives them their special character.
If they had bothered to do any research into Socialist Organiser — even to the extent of leafing through a file of the paper - they could not have made that mistake.
If you place Gerry Healy's WRP at one end of the spectrum, the SWP at the other and Militant in the centre, you see important differences but also certain things in common which give such sects their character. They are organised as tight single-faction organisations. There is a pre-designated leadership, and a narrowly defined set of ideas which function as shibboleths and are not open to discussion. Internal dissent is not allowed, or is allowed only so long as it does not impinge on the cardinal doctrines of the group. Dissent in the public press is very, very rare, and for most such groups simply unknown. Minorities are not allowed to form factions. The possibility of putting up an across-the-board alternative slate on a distinct political platform to challenge the incumbent leadership simply does not exist. It ceased to exist, for example, in the loosest and most nearly civilised of such N TH 00K association which ceased in 1966, not "the end of the 1960s". As many members of the NEC will recall, it is a fact, if an unfortunate one, that no-one on the leit was having big arguments about groups in Britain, the SWP, twenty years ago about the time I parted company with that organisation).
But more than that: I have only sketched in the formalities and structures. There is also the spirit of these groups. It is the spirit of the narrow, persecuting religious sect. The feeling and emotions and commitment which is a necessary part of any sustained activity around the old socialist programme of replacing capitalism by "the cooperative commonwealth" is all focused on the group, on its particular ideas and shibboleths, and on its own claimed identity as "the party" , the Church of the Lord.
It is that spirit - cultivated and cherished by the organisers of the groups listed above - which gives the final stamp to the groups character as sects. From the spirit flows intolerance, the transmutation of ideas supposedly based on theorising about an evolving and changing world into religious dogmas, believed on faith and separating the faithful and the saved from the sinners and the deservedly damned.
Such quasi-religious formations need intolerance, need a "party regime" that keeps an iron grip, need the typical internal atmosphere of an intense religous cult - or they disintegrate.
They need certainties and dogmas
----- pull-quotes -----
IRELAND: The Answer
, Jews alism
LEANELA thuinhou
DON® end SACI die
VO Kers LAB