Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

For a united socialist Europe!

Socialist Organiser no. 454, 19 July 1990 · scan p. 3 · about 749 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

IITORIAL Nicholas Ridley, the man who planned the miners' strike, deserves no sympathy for his sudden disappearance from the political scene.

Like so many other Thatcherite casualties, he did no more than say what others think; or rather, as it turns out, say publicly what others only say at Checkers.

The right-wing luminaries who gathered to discuss the national characteristics of the Germans at a meeting chaired by Margaret Thatcher have all been caught on the hop by the leaking of insider information. They learnedly advised the Prime Minister that Germans suffer, among other character defects, from angst, aggressiveness, bullying, egoism, sentimentality and a tendency to overestimate their abilities.

Professor Norman Stone insists passionately that these are all national characteristics the Germans used to have, as if nationally stereotyping the dead were somehow less reprehensible.

It says a lot for the standards of scholarship at Oxford University. Hitler's rise to power is not explicable through alleged national weaknesses of the Germans. In Germany there was a powerful workers' movement the most powerful there has ever been, perhaps - which could have defeated Hitler, That it fell to Hitler without a fight was not because it was German; it was because, between them, Social Democracy and Stalinism were inept and pitiful political forces.

That the French, Mr Ridley's other lump of national inadequacy, were conquered by Hitler was not because the presumed consumption of snails and frogs' legs renders a nation militarily inefficient. That too had historical roots.

Ridley and his puppet-mistress plainly share straightforward chauvinism about their soon-to-be partners in Europe. All the highpowered talk about Ecus and Ems comes down to a simple fact: they are being dragged into European unity against their better judgement, and if it were at all possible to avoid getting together with all these Huns and Frogs and other old enemies of Biggles, they would do so.

All of which is to be expected, no mainly bemoaning the limits to its own expansionism. But the Left has frequently joined in the chorus.

The campaign against entry intc the EEC was led, in Britain, by the mainstream Left. At root their fear was about "foreign" domination of Britain, and no amount of internationalist padding could alter this basic message.

Opposition to the EEC was tied to a nationalist economic programme. That, nowadays, is seldom heard.| In France, the Communist Party campaigned for a while against a 'German Europe" , and for *socialism in the colours of France": The same CP campaigned for restrictions on Arab immigration, and led physical attacks on immigrants who were "taking French jobs*"

Paranoia about German unification is these days quite widespread.

Of course German imperialism is not to be taken lightly. But nor are any of the imperialisms which make up the European community or its NATO ally across the Atlantic.

There is nothing about Germans which will make their imperialism qualitatively more rapacious or vile than anyone else's. And in reality, what the world is witnessing at the moment is not snatch-and-grab inter-imperialist rivalry like the periods before the two world wars. A European imperialism, within which Germany is especially strong, is being built.

The labour movement needs to respond to this but not with Ridleyesque cries of anti-German horror. It needs to develop its own European unity, its own international organisations and strategies; if capital is European, so must be the workers' movement.

The lack of accountability of EC institutoins is a genuine problem. The answer, surely, is for the labour movement to fight to make them accountable, to expand democracy across Europe. The European parliament should have teeth. Representative institutions across post 1992 Europe should be able to reflect the real wishes of Europeans.

The labour movements of Éurope should combine to fight racism on a European level. If citizens of different EC member states are to be free to move where they want to sell their labour, why not everyone? Why not north Africans who want to work in France in Britain, or who want to live Turks who want to go to Germany?

And if there are to be equal rights His Mistress's Voice for European workers, the labour movement should guarantee equal rights also for immigrant workers.

It is to be hoped that Ridley turns out to be the Thatcher government's last banana skin. His departure should certainly be with a heartfelt cheer.

But let's make sure movement doesn't shar prejudices that brot Ridley's fall. the labour any of the ght about

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 454

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →