Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Support hospital

Socialist Organiser no. 453, 12 July 1990 · scan pp. 11–12 · about 2,015 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

Sition eat Schools, leisure centres, children's homes and libraries will close as a result. Large-scale redundancies coupled with a drive against union organisation can also be expected.

Council workers need to fight these attacks. Build for all-out borough-wide strike action, link up with workers in other poll tax capped boroughs!

Since 23 May, 50 members of NUPE, NALGO and CoHSE have been taking strike action in hospitals across Central Birmingham Health Authority:

We are administrative, clerical and secretarial staff and we provide an essential service to patients and to other health service staff — but our dedication has been rewarded with al disgraceful slap in the face by management. We submitted regrading claims over a year ago — after a long delay management decided to review the grades of all admin and clerical staff within the authority. When the results came out, surprise, surprise, only a handful of regradings but the majority of us left where we were, on paltry pay.

Limited industrial action began in March, | but was suspended when vacant Estate Management Office post. The level of cover the management were demanding would have made it the bestcovered post in the city! At Wilbraham office, management instructed staff to cover for an ACTTS member on strike due to the Shanton dispute - causing them to walk out. And at Burnage staff were also instructed to cover for a vacant post.

The NALGO branch officials were for once willing to make the dispute official, but before it was put to the vote at a mass meeting, the management backed down, withdrawing their threats of disciplinary action to the workers involved and agreeing to negotiations with the unions at local level over cover for all vacant posts.

But the whole issue arises out of the refusal of the Labour council to take on the Tories over cuts in local jobs and services and their complete failure to fight over the poll tax.

Local government workers will be forced more and more to take on more work to keep the already skeleton service on the rails. So strikes like this one by Manchester housing workers will be inevitable.

Scan page 12

Oppose the ves to Dal ORGANISER Organiser!

Stop this purge! Statament by the Editorial Board Be should not proscribe any organisation without the opportunity for the full facts to be heard and their case put forward," declares David Blankett MP in a letter to Socialist Organer.

That's the bare minimum of justice: charges, evidence, and a hearing for the defence before conviction or sentence. Yet, but for lack of time, the Labour Party National Executive on 27 June would have proceeded in exactly the opposite way: sentence passed before the "defendant" was even officially informed of any proceedings, let alone given a hearing.

A report from National Organiser Joyce Gould, mainly about the deselection of Frank Field MP in Birkenhead, also included the following proposal:

*That the NEC under Clause I! (3) and 4 (b) and in persuant of the conference decision of 1982, regards Socialist Organiser as declare [sic] Socialist Organiser as ineligible for affiliation to the party and inconsistent with the Constitutional Rules."

Presumably Labour HQ officials reckoned they could sort out the grammar and spelling later. The drift was clear: Socialist Organiser should be banned.

The National Executive in February decided to "investigate" our paper, because Frank Field had thrown accusations about Socialist Organiser "controlling" Wallasey Constituency Labour Party into his great ragbag of a dossier contesting his deselection. To this day no-one from Labour Party HQ has contacted our editorial staff, returned out phone calls, or even officially notified us of the "investigation""!

Yet Joyce Gould proposed the ban. The proposal is still on the NEC's agenda, and almost certain to be discussed at its next meeting on 25 July. We still have not been officially contacted or informed, though by unofficial means we do now know what's proposed.

Socialist Organiser's editorial staff have written to Joyce Gould and to all NEC members asking that we be officially supplied with copies of all charges and evidence against us, that we have a chance to present a reply to the NEC, and that representatives should be able to attend the NEC to put our case and answer questions.

Jovce Gould's "evidence" is very thin. In the body of her report she states: "Extracts from Discussion Bulletins published by Socialist Organiser clearly identify it as an entrist organisation". The back-up to that statement is just six sentences from an old discussion bulletin, quoted out of context, which form an "Appendix" to the report together with a haphazard list of some people who are on our editorial stati, some who aren't, and some who have been in the past, under the titles "Secretariat" and "Executive Committee"

The relevant clauses from the Labour Party rules are II (3) and III II (3) states: *Political organisations not affiliated to or associated under a national agreement with the party on January 1, 1946, having their own programme, principles and policy for distinctive and separate propaganda, or possessing branches in the constituencies Or engaged in the promotion of parliamentary or local government candidatures, or owing allegiance to filiation to the party."

III (4) states: "No member of the Labour Party shall engage in a sustained course of conduct prejudicial to the Party... Where appropriate, the National Constitutional Committee shall have regard to involvement in financial support for and/ or the organisation of and/or the activities of any organisatior declared ineligible for affiliation... but the NEC shall not have regard to the mere holding or expression of beliefs and opinions."] The clauses were put in their present form in the course of the banning of Militant. First, Militant was found to be an organisation ineligible for affiliation. But thousands of Labour Party members belong to organisations ineligible for affiliation, from CND to the Catholic Church, and they can't all be expelled. So Clause III (4) was drafted on the understanding that Militant was a case where it was "appropriate" to regard support for a group ineligible for affiliation to "a sustained course of conduct prejudicial to the Party". In other cases it would not be "appropriate".

So what do Joyce Gould's six sentences show about support for Socialist Organiser constituting sustained course of conduct prejudicial to the Party"? These are the six:

*Sometimes in the past we have been sectarian towards the Labour Party. But in 1978-1979 we learned some new things about working in the Labour Party as the best militants inside the movement. We have to be the best militants. But we are also Marxists - not tied to the rhythms of the Labour Party, and working in a medium which isn't ours."

"We need to focus on building ourselves; use the period to educate ourselves and build; maintain our links with the Labour Party but don't get dragged down by it. We are not parasitic on the Labour Party - we have our own organisation, programme, etc. We need a 'sectarian turn' in the sense of bolder self-presentation, but without turning away from the movement."

They are in fact extracts from minutes of a National Editorial Board, snippets from what individuals (not the committee by resolution or any such body) said But those individuals talk about "working in the Labour Party as the best militants inside the movement. We have to be the best AIRER militants"!

Being the best builders of the Labour Party — that's "a sustained course of conduct prejudicial to the Party"? Other comments in the same minutes include: "In my Labour Party membership has trebled. Healthy Labour Party branches can be built... " and "We can recruit people to the Labour Party via poll tax campaigns. One ward recruited 100... " Very "prejudicial to the Party"!

Joyce Gould's prize exhibit is doubtless the sentence: "We are not parasitic on the Labour Party — we have our own organisation, programme, etc." It seems to put us in the wrong under Clause II (3).

But that's more word play than substance. And even then it goes nowhere towards showing that this is a case where it is "appropriate" under Clause III (4) to consider support for group ineligible for affiliation as being "prejudicial" to the Party.

In context, what the "prize exhibit" sentence says is that where supporters of Socialist Organiser find Labour Party ward branches small and depressed - as unfortunately often happens these days - they should not be "parasitic" they should not passively sit back and moan: they should go out, sell the paper on the streets, on the picket lines, and door to door, and bring new people into the Party.

"Our own organisation, programme, etc? Our paper regularly carries a "Where We Stand" column outlining our political platform - which is not a platform counterposed to the Labour Party, but a programme of policies to which we seek to win the Labour Party and the labour movement - and asking readers to join our local supporters' groups. There is no mystery about that. Nobody publishes a paper like Socialist Organiser without having some distinctive ideas to argue, and nobody but a millionaire publishes such a paper without having an organised network for distributing, selling, and fund-raising.

Every one of the literally hundreds of pressure groups, campaigns and caucuses in the Labour Party has some distinctive programme and some sort of organisation. Otherwise those groups would not exist, levy subscriptions, elect committees, issue publications, organise meetings, as in fact they do.

If all such groups were banned, then every member of the National Executive would probably have to be expelled! If Joyce Gould were making a serious case, she would have to adduce evidence that the policies and organisational network of Socialist Organiser are of a particular type to be "prejudicial to the Party". She adduces no such evidence.

In fact, as far as we can see, our ideas and our ways of organising would make us entirely eligible for inclusion in the Labour Party's "register" of approved groups.

Our local group meetings are open to all Labour Party members. Our AGM is publicly advertised and open to all Labour Party members (this year, it was even filmed for television by BBC Newsnight). We are not conspiratorial. And we have said, and say again, that we are quite ready to consider changing the way we organise if the NEC-finds it objectionable.

It's a frame-up. Joyce Gould is patching together threads and fragments in order to target the Marxist left.

If she gets away with this, every group and newspaper in the Labour Party is at risk. Or rather: every group and newspaper on the left is at risk - the right wing will continue to caucus and conspire at will, as always.

Labour Briefing, Labour Party Socialists, Campaign Group News and local Campaign Groups, the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy, Socialist Outlook, Socialist Action, Women for Socialism - all could be banned at will (and presumably without even being informed that charges had been tabled) if this precedent is established.

The issues are even more far-reaching than when Militant was proscribed. We said at the time, and we think we've been proved right, that Militant had been selected as an easy target to frighten the left and start a precedent.

But the official argument - and many people who are by no means right-wingers or devotees of a Stalinist one-faction party accepted it — was that Militant was a special case. It had special ways of organising and behaving which marked it out from all other groups in the party - tighter, more sectarian, more conspiratorial, in short, damaging.

No such special case is argued against Socialist Organiser. The case against us is a case against any attempt to publish and organise for left wing ideas in the Labour Party. Don't let them get away with it! -Pass emergency motions to NEC, and send copies to SO, Box 823, London SE15 4NA

----- pull-quotes -----

any political organisation situated abroad, shall be ineligible for af-

Sociarist BRITAN

AA B Than

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 453

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →