Psychopaths, bondage and camp comedy
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-07-12Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Scene from another Almodovar film 'Woman on the Edge of a Die me up! Tie me down!' (which in Spanish goes by the rather snappier title of Atame!') is, from the point of view of sexual politics, the most resolutely reactionary film to have been made for years.
A nutcase is let out of a mental institution (and if 'nutcase' isn't a very right-on term, I'm only following in the film's footsteps) and sets about pursuing a woman with whom he previously has had a onenight stand, and with whom he is in love. She is a junkie and an actress in unbelievably bad horror B movies.
Failing to engage her in conversation, he bursts into her flat, headeventually tying her up so she can't butts her, and takes her prisoner, escape, promising to make her fall in love with him (shades of "The Collector'). He explains that he will be a good husband and a good father to their children.
And does she fall in love with him? Of course she does. After an initial period of understandable error, she discovers that he's really quite a nice guy, especially after he gets seriously beaten up while trying to buy her some smack. And he is, it would seem, an amazing lay.
So when she eventually escapes (from the flat she's imprisoned in, and less metaphorically from bondage), she decides to go back to him. They meet, tor some reason, at the top of an isolated castle, and live happily ever after.
The outrage with which the film has been met only goes to show that some people can't take a joke. Either that, I suppose, or that I am Nervous Breakdown' too gullible to be able to recognise genuine sexism when I see it.
Pedro Almodovar is one of Spain's most popular film makers, director of camp sexual comedies full of absurd set pieces. In 'Law of Desire', a gay film director is pursued by a handsome young psychopath who kills his boyfriend. And he turns out to be an okay sort of guy too, if my memory serves me correctly. So Almodovar is into psychopaths.
Tie me up! Tie me down!' is so obviously wildly over the top that I cannot believe that it is meant to be taken even remotely seriously. That the heroine falls for the hero (and he is intended to be a hero) is so completely ridiculous, so utterly improbable, no-one can believe it to be a real comment on women's attitudes to tough-guy men.
That if it's not meant to be of World War 2, in the home of an American capitalist, a war proWater, missing, sough the min the refuses to accept it, and waits for news from him that never comes. world which the gor It ha serious, it doesn't really have much point at all, would be a fair comment. Except it made me laugh out loud, and that's quite an achievement for a film where you have to crane your neck to read the subtitles.
My main objection is that Almodovar should choose such an extraordinarily beautiful man as his leading character and put him in an exclusively heterosexual role. Enis, were at the mercy of nature, they idealised as the work of s the added tragic dimension -NIC for us, uI cients, socialism, vironment. I contend, is a cop out. Almodovar knows that gay men will flock to see his movies. To then ignore them is not on. Unless he thinks his gay influence can survive on camp alone.
Its subject matter, despite its absurdity, denies the film the gentler charm of Almodovar's earlier movies. So it is disappointing. But even when he's disappointing, Almodovar is good for an afternoon's entertainment.
Air gir able the anwith cial enCC tro ou