Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A very bourgeois workers party

Socialist Organiser no. 453, 12 July 1990 · scan p. 9 · Patrick Murphy · about 905 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

NORTHLAND small but leading group A of Workers Party members resigned in the middle of this year's party conference in April.

Among them were some of the founders of modern Workers Party ideology, particularly Eamon Smullen, a leading recruit from the British Communist Party in 1973. The background to the split was a fierce debate about the identity and programme of the party in the post-Stalinist world.

The Workers Party has always been a fawning cheerleader for the Eastern Bloc regimes. As Party leader Prionsias De Rossa more dishonestly put it, "it is a valid criticism of my party that we did not more publicly criticise the defects we saw in communist countries"!

The combination of Stalinism's collapse and a significant increase in Workers Party parliamentary representation has accelerated the party's shift towards an even more mild reformist politics. At this. year's conference De Rossa repeated his assertion of last year that support for state control of industry was finished while a programme for a mixed economy was essential.

De Rossa promised a new radical programme for industry "based on the existence of a mixed economy" As usual with 'socialists' who embrace ths sort of politics the WP leader warned of the need for "able and courageous political leadership Prionsias De Rossa with a breadth of vision" in the period ahead. In other words, anyone concerned that all of this rhetoric is simply the abandonment of anything worth calling socialism lacks courage, vision and leadership.

So what of the dissidents? Were they cerenaig some version, however distorted, of class politics? Sadly, HU. The leadership's critics dic LUC really open social democrats. They support a leading party theorist, Eoghan Harris, who resigned when his document, *The Necessity of Social Democracy' was published in a highly edited form in the WP journal. Harris and associates argue for social democratic rather than socialist values, a different party structure and the end of democratic centralism.

The split was damaging to the party, coming, as it did, in the midst of a televised and wellreported conference, the most public in WP history. The acrimony is, however, hard to understand at first sight, given the slight political differences bewteen the factions.

At least two main explanations suggest themselves. First, there is no doubt that the old leadership continued to use well-worn Stalinist methods in dealing with their opponents' views. They controlled and frustrated dissident views, used the theorists to abandon socialism and republicanism, then used the workerism of the rank and file to attack the "arrogant intellectuals" Much of the drama of the resignations can be put down to frustration at being out-manoeuvred.

Secondly, and I think more importantly, it does matter to the WP whether they are formally socialists or social-democratic; not substantially in terms of content but certainly in terms of party competition. In the Irish electoral market the WP's main competitor is clearly the Irish Labour Party. They are the social-democratic tradition in Ireland, firmly linked to Kinnock's and Mitterand's parties in the Socialist International. It would be much harder to justify the separate existence of two parties if both proclaimed an openly social democratic programme. This wouldn't matter to an honest reformist theorist seeking respect for their ideas, but it matters a lot to party bureaucrats whose sole concern is their own career and positions.

Lastly, the leadership's position is much easier to sell to the members in a faction fight. The total abandonment of socialism was too much for rank and file members of a party with a very recent attachment to some version of Marxism. De Rossa's rebuff to the social democrats recalls vividly an old trade unionist's advice to the original enthusiast for reformism Eduard Bernstein, at the turn of the century. After listening with shock to a Bernstein speech extolling gradual piecemeal reforms, rather than militant class struggle, the wiseacre warned: "Eduard, one doesn't say such things in the movement; one simply does them." Such, exactly, is the difference between the Workers Party factions.

Little else has changed in the Workers Party. Their attitude to the North continues to be a bizarre inversion of their own past. "The biggest enemy of democracy in Ireland is the IRA," said General Secretary Sean Garland. Charles Haughey was condemned as an insincere advocate of democracy on the European stage because of a list of infringements of democracy in Ireland. Missing from the Workers Party list, however, is any reference to the rıgıd prohibition of Sinn Fein. Later in the conference there were a number of mentions for the notorious Section 31 of the Broadcasting Act. Under this provision no Sinn Fein representatives can be interviewed or reported on Irish TV or radio, a much more strict rule than any British measure. Last year a journalist lost her job for breaking the ban. Section 31 also has the honour of being the one policy which both sides of the WP faction fight firmly support!

Further than that, party leaders called for the more speedy extraditions of alleged terrorists and condemned Charles Haughey for his sluggishness on the issue. Haughey has been held back by public anxiety in Ireland in the wake of the Guildford 4, Winchester 3 and Birmingham 6 cases. Perhaps it is time for him to show more willingness to punish terrorists, however. I suggest he start by extraditing those suspected of the Aldershot Barracks bombing in 1972, in which seven civilians were killed.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 453

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →