The market in
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-07-12Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
A handbook for trade unionists by Socialist Organiser and Workers' Liberty El A handbook for trade unionists. £1 plus 22p post.
Towards capitalism
For workers' liberty?
A Socialist Organiser Workers Li rty pamphlet 60 pe The shape of the coming class struggle in Eastern Europe. 60p plus 22p post 've just read two interesting items by Gerry Bates and Duncan Chapel (Letters, SO450), concerning the problem of re-introducing the market economy in the states of Eastern Europe, and responding to the articles by Sylvia Bolger and Tony Dale on the same question (Letters, S0499).
As a Czechoslovak citizen, I can only agree with Mr Bates, that no apology for Stalinism is admissible, although I can hardly appreciate whether the previous system in East European countries, so-called "real socialism" was in some aspect better than capitalism — I've never lived under capitalism.
It is also a fact that I've never been hungry, homeless; I could study, free of charge, at the University; I've had my job secure until now... as have most of my fellow citizens. I think that there are probably some people in the West who wonder what more we want...
Well, it is not the political and ideological violation by the huge bureaucratic apparatus and permanent control of different-minded people by invisible or visible State Security that I want to write about now. The discussion is about the market -so I could write something about everyday hunting for the ordinary goods, queuing for the things of daily use.
There's always something missing in our state shops. If there is anything in the shops, you'd better take it, whether you need it or not, Union, has undeniably a higher living standard for working people -I am not sure whether it will remain true after the "shock cure" prescribed by the Finance Minister, Mr Klaus. Nevertheless, almost nobody in my country doubts that the "reasonable prices", which as a rule will mean higher prices, are justifiable, that the future dynamic development of the economy is connected with "economic prices" Almost all believe that the actual economic prices can be established only by the market.
To tell the truth, we don't know what the market is. The absolute majority of the population was born, or lived their adult life, after 1948, ie in the conditions of the planned economy, with the experience I've described above. That's why there are so many illusions, so many hopes in the market as a "universal medicine" for all ailments of our economy, so much trust in the market economy, moreover encouraged by foreign capital.
These notes are not intended to be an economic account, I only try to introduce, so to say, the "public opinion" of nowadays. Only the oldest. section of the population (more exactly, one part of this section, having its own bad experience from the pre-war Republic) is warning against uncontrolled private undertaking, even privatisation, against leaving the planned economy. As a matter of fact, it is rather problematic to declare them simply "Stalinist". Many of them believe that February 1948 was a socialist revolution. It requires serious analysis to decide whether it was or not. Naturally many older people believe that the state-owned property is the real socialist property. We've just realised what a bitter half-illusion, half-mystification it was; how terribly misinterpreted and misused was Marx's economic theory by the bureaucratic apparatus, how big was the "alienation of labour" in the state monopoly enterprises, in the so-called "real socialism":
Here we have two extreme standpoints: an uncritical admiration of a market coonomy of the western type on one hand, not only by the potential private entrepreneura, but Bush tells Havel all about the market mainly by people who simply want to be customers, not the "hunters" of goods: it is often emotional rather than rational.
On the other hand, there is a strict defence of the planned economy and rejection of the market as a principle; but, in fact, such a rigorous opinion has hardly any supporters now. And, finally, there is a large scale of opinion between these extremes - attempts at finding the real and lucrative balance between the plan and the market, thoughts of the "socially oriented market economy", of selfmanagement and workers' control. The quest markety hybridiot plan and actually possible? This can hardly be answered in a short time. All the winners winnerstic groupies, the fresh Czechoslovakia, and even the defeated Communist Party, have raised in their election programmes the requests for equal rights for all forms of ownership and for the establishing of a free-market economy.
It means people in Czechoslovakia, expecially the young people, want the market and will have the market, because they believe that the market mechanisms really can "gear production to human need". • Tony Dale, who visited Czechoslovakia recently, knows it quite well. They elected a market economy with all its risks. Unemployment still seems to be an unknown and rather underestimated phenomenon.
There really must not be an apology for stalınism, because Stalinism «real socialism" so terso-called ribly discredited the socialist idea, that people do prefer capitalism or "liberalism" . The other question is, what can the "left" - another problematic term in my country - offer as a programme of "genuine socialism'?
Xenia Suchova CelIarekia
----- pull-quotes -----
PROBLEMS STRUGGLES
EASTERN EUROPE