[The Left was strong in the early "80s…]
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-07-12Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
The Left was strong in the early "80s. Why has it sufferad hard on issues where we should e tried to win greater support consolidate that support.
tat issues? think we shouldn't have rushed > the deputy leadership contest. I n't think Healey as deputy Her would mean anything. It was position of no importance. I n't happy about making that the trai thing. I said so. But once it done the choice was either to port the lett candidate, or objecy help the right. I certainly n't going to do that! didn't think that it was good to t the Tribune Group of MPs, er. By splitting it you handed it r to the opportunists. here are time when tactics are important. That's why now I kit's very important that alists remain in the Labour Parnd at the same time work very d to create an organisation or anisations which can fight for alism inside the Labour Party work with organisations out-at do you say to those who conle that because of the right e's victories, socialists should e the Labour Party? his is not the time. I'm not saythat at some time in the future e won't be a new socialist party.
this is not the moment. We e to organise the left for alism, but within the Labour rty. hat doesn't stop us colrating with people in the alist Movement and others who not in the Labour Party. It's er like what happened after I when the Socialist League was ted, and the Socialist League ked with the Independent our Party throughout the od from 1932.
there a competition for urces. For example, the SWP 'Leave the Labour Party". -ell, you're always going to get I don't think there's any mer. It you created a new party, i have all sorts of small -isations becoming part of it in to win people from the party meir organisation. It has ever thus.
Of course we are socialists, and we have fought for socialism in the Labour Party. But isn't it true that the reason for being in the Labour Party has never been because of its doubtful "socialism", but fundamentally because it is the mass party of the class linked to the unions? Isn't that the fundamental thing? No matter how far it has moved formally from socialism now, it remains the mass party of the class because of its trade union roots. Serious socialists should never voluntarily abandon the mass party of the class to the right wing. Isn't that the essential argument?
If they marginalise the unions in the party, then it's no longer the mass party of the working class. And you think that's what is happening?
It's beginning to happen. It's not just the Conference block vote. Some of the trade union leaders are quite happy to see the trade unions set aside, without any real influence. If they get away with that - and they're moving in that direction - then it is no longer the mass movement of the working class. So why should we stay in the Because there's an awful lot of people like us in the Labour Party who've got to be organised to work together. I don't think you can run before you can crawl. We have to take a step at a time. Maybe in the end we'll get chucked out anyway. In that case it'll be solved for us. It would be far better to be thrown out, if we are going to be thrown out, as an Grganised force of people working together for basic socialist ideas, than to go out as individuals one at a time with no perspectives. But you know the history of the Marxist matsment. You mentioned the SDF at the founding of the Labour Party. They had come along with their programma to a conference which was dominated by Liberal trade unionists. They made a motion that it be accepted. and when, predictably, it was not accepted, they walked out.
Isn't it true that the Marxist tradition in this country has been a heavily sectarian tradition? The consequence is that we've left the mass movement to the right wing and the soft left. Isn't that the Kinnock dominant trend?
Isn't that one of the problems we have to face now — a resurgence of self-defeating sectarianism in response to Kinnock?
Yes. I think I've made that clear in all the books I've written. Had the SDF remained in the Labour Party it might have been a different party.
Isn't that sectarian tradition also to be found in the Communist Party in the '20s, when they didn't want to stay in the Labour Party? Formally they wanted to stay, but in practice they didn't.
It was very different circumstances. The Soviet Union coming into existence, and the Communist International.
But the Labour Party was a mass movement which varied very much ideologically. There was pretty free PERSOE-JOBS atta he since then? Photo: John Harris