Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Friendship across culture

Socialist Organiser no. 453, 12 July 1990 · scan p. 5 · about 768 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

West German magazine Der Spiegel recently noted: "West German industry is holding back in a manner which surprises even the pessimists of German-German economic unification."

Banks, insurance companies and wholesale and retail trade have moved into the DDR, but not new productive capacity. 80% of West German investment in the GDR to date has been in the retail trading sector. West German capitalists see the GDR primarily as a new market for their goods, and as a bridge to other new markets in Eastern Europe.

Insofar as any investment takes place in new productive capacity in the GDR, it will be in order to profit from the low wages which continue to exist in the _GDR after monetary union. Jobs could therefore be axed in West Germany as production is transferred to the low-wage economy of the GDR.

Such is the industrial backwardness of the GDR that sections of West German capitalism fear could prove to be a black hole sucking in ever larger amounts of money. In order to guarantee wages (even at current levels) GDR facEYE Someone once described the Americans and the British as two nations divided by a single language. We are also divided by common assumptions.

I assumed that my American friend would be able to take some time off to spend with me when I recently visited the States. She did — she spent a week with me - her entire paid holiday allowance for the yearAs in Britain, most Americans working outside the higher echelons of the public sector get the national minimum paid holiday allowance. In Britain that's 15 days a year. In the USA it's five.

My friend couldn't even pretend to be ill. American workers are entitled to five paid sick days per year. After that it is either insurance or nothing. A woman with children simply can't afford to be ill. Her five days are likely to be taken up with children's illnesses.

It doesn't do to be ill in the States. Even with insurance (and millions, of Americans don't have it), the individual is responsible for 20% of the cost of a visit to the GP. Insurance only covers 100% of hospital treatment which is "nonelective". That sounds reasonable until you realise that "elective" doesn't just mean a nose job but such things as heart by-pass surgery. All the fabulous children's clinics which are at the forefront of treating disabled and seriously children are elective too...

Health insurance is related to work. When you start a new job, you strike a deal with your employer which specifies how much will be paid in insurance contributions and by whom. The insurance cover also has to include provision. for retirement — in other words has to continue as part of your pension. Otherwise, if you stop work, you stop being insured.

If you want to insure your children (without which they won't have any health care) that has to be done separately. A man's insurance doesn't cover his wife or vice versa. There is some safety-net provision for the poor, elderly and people who find themselves uninsured for whatever reason (like people who can't get insurance, because they are "high risk" or nonworking mothers, for example but it only covers emergencies.

So if an old lady breaks her leg she'll get it set, but she won't get the follow up like physiotherapy or a health visitor calling round to see that she's OK. Such a person couldn't even buy insurance to cover herself - she'd be too high a risk for the insurance company to take on.

Until recently we took our health care for granted. The NHS does, even now, provide a marvellous service by comparison to the American system, but for how long? Thatcher is determined to "Americanise" the health service and the new contract for GPs, based on cost-centering, is a step on the way.

Sparked by the discussion about the American health insurance system my mother told us bitterly about the days before the NHS. She can clearly remember agonising decisions about whether someone was ill enough to need a half-crown visit from the doctor.

The American system is cruel to the reasonably affluent. In one sense a choice exists about whether to pay for the best care for an ill child, or to buy a new car, take a holiday or send another child to college. But millions of Americans, inhabitants of the richest country in the world, have to watch their children die because they can't afford the doctor.

That is the "choice" the Tories want to give the British working

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 453

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →