Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Scargill and the IMO: what we said in 1985

Socialist Organiser no. 453, 12 July 1990 · scan pp. 3–5 · Claire Richards · about 3,468 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

it. Robert Maxwell is not morally fit to look Arthur Scargill in the eye.

In this situation honest socialists will say "Hands off Arthur Scargill!" It is for the miners to settle their own affairs, and if they think it necessary, to demand a detailed accounting from Arthur Scargill of the complicated financial jugglings with union and IMO funds. One consequence of the anti-Scargill witch-hunt is that it is likely to make mineworkers put the duty to defend Scargill from the lynch The emancipation of the working class is also the emancipation of all human. beings without distinction of sex or race"

Karl Marx Socialist Organiser PO Box 823 London SE15 4NA Nowadesk: 071-639 7965 Latest date for reports: first post Monday slished by WL Publications Ltd Box 823, London SE15 4NA Printed by Press Link International (UK) Ltd (TU)

Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office Signed articles do not necessarily reflect the views of Socialist Organiser During the miners' strike, when scab Polish coal was pouring into Britain, Arthur Scargill said at a meeting in Sheffield that he "owed Lech Walesa an apology".

Scargill, of course, had been particularly hostile to the Polish trade union movement Solidarnosc, before and after it was banned by the Stalinist police state. I doubt that Scargill ever sent that apology to Lech Walesa.

In fact Scargill seems to have learned nothing from the miners bitter experience with his scabbing Polish "socialist" comrades. Scargill is now in Moscow setting up an international organisation of miners - which will include the fake miners' unions of countries like Russia.

The Polish miners in Silesia who denounced the sending of scab coal to Britain had the official Polish miners' union imposed on them after Solidarnosc was outlawed by brute military force. Miners struck and some miners died resisting martial law in 1981.

The Polish miners won't be represented in Arthur's new miners' international by Solidarnosc but by the official government fake unions which have nothing , in common, with real trade unions.

The nearest equivalent in Britain to Arthur Scargill's East European and Russian partners in the new international is not the NUM but the scab union of Lynk and Prendergast.

Except that the East European police state unions are not even scab unions. The exact equivalent in Britain would be if the government banned trade unions and locked up trade union militants, abolishing all the rights and liberties won in Britain over the last eight centuries, at the same time taking absolute control of the media and most other things in society including the economy and then set up "unions" staffed by state agents unions" not for defending the workers but to help management carry out its productivity targets, and report dissident! workers and "troublemakers" to the police, etc.

Not so long ago in the USSR the former head of the secret police became the head of the Russian "TUC". He just moved from one policing job to another.

The secretary of the new miners' international will be Alain Simon, general secretary of the French miners' union, the vice president will be Michael Strebny of the USSR miners' "union" and the president will be....Arthur Scargill.

A miners' international is an excellent idea - but it must be an international of real unions. This one won't be.

Militant miners got some idea of what a police state is like when Thatcher sent her militarised squads of police into the coalfields during the miners' strike. They should tell Arthur Scargill to stop hobnobbing with the anti-working class scab unions of the Stalinist police state. don't think you can have a system of press freedom that does crucial damage to private individuals. The only restraint I wish to apply to the press is their treatment of private individuals."

The trouble with this (as Hattersley no stranger to journalism himself must know) is that all news involves. "private individuals". It is impossible to frame a law that protects the ordinary citizen from unwarranted press attention that does not also protect the rich and powerful from legitimate investigative journalism./ Actually, it was Hattersley (interviewed in the Independent) who convinced me once and for all against both Calcutt and the Labour Party's proposals for statutory controls: if this man, with his record of miserable shilly-shallying over the Salman Rushdie affair, and his contemptible attitude towards democracy and free speech within his own Sparkbrook Constituency Labour Partv, is so keen on statutory controls, then they must surely be opposed at all costs.

But doesn't something have to be done about the gutter press? Yes, indeed: make legal aid available in libel cases. This wouldn't solve all the problems surrounding the British press (eg. concentration of ownership) but it would at least give ordinary people some hope of redress. It's certainly preferable to giving increased control over the media to a government led by Mrs Thatcher...or, come to that, to one led by the likes of Roy Hattersley.

Scan page 4

ing theory and GRAFFITI The Socialist Workers not for the first time, threw supporters of Socialist Organiser out of their annual 'Marxism' event in London.

This year's pretext was an open letter to SWP leader Tony Cliff, originally published in the latest Workers' Liberty magazine, and reproduced as a leaflet.

The open letter accuses Cliff of holding an implicitly antisemitic position on the Middle Eastern conflict, expressed in terms of fierce anti-Zionism.

It says, "The left is now in th same moral position vis-a-vis individual Jews as the medieval Christians who could say honestly that they wanted to save the Jews from themselves They wanted to convert them... (The anti-Zionist Left) at its hea proposes policies which amount to the murder of a nation." It is not a matter of name-calling. The open letter to Tony Cliff consists of about 3,000 words. of reasoned argument explaining why, despite their intention, the SWP functions as an anti-semiti propaganda group.

And it argues that Cliff, as a Palestinian Jew with much mor: authority on the issue, bears a special responsibility for this.

We are not surprised that the SWP are upset by the accusation that they are at least implicitly anti-semitic. The charge is intended to shock, to provoke thought, hopefully to provoke debate and reassessment. It would be a sorry state of affairs if it did not shock them.

But that the SWP's response to shock and outrage, rather than answer the charge and try to refute it, is to deny us the right to put it, is sorrier still. Their reflex reaction to sharp criticism is to ban it. If they don't like what you say, they er clude you from their meetings.

Socialist Organiser have been excluded by the SWP in the pas for alleged "Zionism". Some even gave this as an explanation, a few years ago, for their decision to refuse after five c six years of a commercial relationship - to continue printing our paper (although others alleg ed falsely we weren't paying ou bills).

Others on the left have also been excluded by them.

We and others have before met, as we did at Marxism 90, with physical force as the way of excluding us. They ripped up our literature and pushed us This is not, or should not be, acceptable in the socialist move ment. The charge of latent or a tual anti-semitism is a serious one, probably more so in the current climate than ever. We mean it seriously. We want it discussed.

The SWP's programme for thi Middle East conflict is that the Israeli Jewish nation, like no other nation, abolish itself. They propose this as an immediate answer to decades of national conflict. Cliff - "bears responsibility* They see all those, that is the majority of Jews, who identity ir some way with Israel and with Zionism, as an enemy. Their attitude to Zionism, that is to mainstream Jewish nationalism, is one of uncompromising hostility. But it is not simply the uncompromising hostility of socialists to all forms of nationalism. They see Zionism as worse than any other form of nationalism. Opposition to Zionism is the touch-stone of 'anti-imperialist' politics.

For Jews who are Zionists, i means unconditional renunciation, not only of the policies of the Israeli state towards the Palestinians, which Socialist Organiser also calls for, but renunciation of every aspect of Zionism, including the identification of a distinct Jewish nation in the Middle East.

Jews who are not prepared to go so far are seen as an enemy deserving only extreme opposition.| Only a small minority of Jews agree with the SWP's attitude. So in practice they are hostile to most Jews, actively hostile, campaigning hostile.

Democracy for the Palestinians is obviously essential for peace in the Middle East. But the SWP explicitly deny that any but a tiny minority of Israeli Jews can play any part in winning that democracy. They propose socialist revolution in the Middle East without the Israeli workers.

This is not the same as traditional anti-semitism. But it seems to us to be a new kind of anti-semitism: and with antisemitism on the rise in Europe, often disguised as anti-Zionism, it is extremely dangerous.

We wish most Jews had not been won to the Zionist movement. That they were was because of the failure of the labour movement to prevent the Holocaust. The Holocaust was the responsibility of fascism -and Stalinism, which miserably failed to fight fascism. It was not the responsibility of Zionism The left will be ineffective in fighting anti-semitism unless we clear up these issues. And we will only clear them up if we have open and democratic Kicking your enemies out of your meetings is a recipe for intolerance and an undemocratic future. As Rosa Luxemburg put it, democracy is the right for the one who disagrees. As our oper letter said to Cliff, the SWP should cut it out.

Anti-poll tax protestors A in Warrington won a victory last week when a 1,000-strong demonstration halted court proceedings against non-payers.

Labour-controlled Warrington council had issued summonses against 5,000 non-payers, but the cases were abandoned without a single liability order being authorised, as a result of the demonstration.

More strikes by local government workers are planned as the poll tax capped boroughs meet to push through cuts budgets.

600 job cuts are threatened in Haringey, North London, as well as the closure of library, childcare and adult education services. Haringey workers are currently voting on strike action. Hammersmith council plans to make El1m cuts; Southwark meets this week to push through f14m cuts.

In Tory-controlled Ealing, 2,500 NALGO workers walked out for 24 hours over the threat of 200 redundancies. The Tories have already closed the Race, Women's and Lesbian and Gay units.

Following their recent one-day strike, Barnsley teachers are currently ballotting on extending their industrial action. Greenwich housing workers are still on strike over claims for higher pay and better conditions relating to poll tax work.

In capitulating to Tory pressure and slashing jobs and services, Labour councils are certain find themselves facing increasing industrial action by their workforce, and rising non-payment levels.

The Tories have made it clear that there'll be no more money next year, either. The Cabinet review of the poll tax has come up with a mere £2.5 billion extra spending on the poll tax next year, most of which will be channelled into rebates. Not only will this have no serior's impact on helping those least able to pay, it will mean much higher bills next year. Current estimates suggest 10-14% rises in bills in 1991, just to maintin this year's spending levels (after cuts!): that's an average bill of f400.!

Which leaves the labour movement with two choices: to step up their role as Thatcher's henchmen - sacking workers; slashing desperately needed services; increased criminalisation and impoverishment of working class peong t Workers Liberty 1990 took the trophy this year for clear debate and democratic discussion. The school had a wider choice of sessions than ever before, with big names from both the academic and activist left.

The school united theory and practice: poll tax activists ple — or standing on the side of working class people and taking on the Tories and their hated class tax; fighting to make the poll tax unworkable.

Sadly, to date, our leaders show no stomach for a fight. Tory backbenchers have been more vociferous in their condemnation of the tax than most Labour MPs. Kinnock's spleen is vented on the poll tax campaigners, not Thatcher.

Trade union leaders such as the NUT's Doug McAvoy and NALGO's Alan Jinkinson have refused to co-ordinate and build the fight waged by their members in defence of jobs, conditions and services: all their energy has gone into undermining, and distancing themselves from, such rank and file action.

But the rank and file of the labour movement is prepared to fight. The newly-formed 'Councillors Against the Poll Tax' proves that some of our elected Labour representatives won't do the Tories' dirty work. Rank and file teachers have just held a successful conference to co-ordinate the fight 36-16, Clate.

ORKERS The triumpin @Pitine BERT bourgeolsie?

U$SR Albert Einstein of sociolisn Driper + The nature of the Solinlat states • and riey, Forum, retw €1.20 plus 22p post from WL, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA The latest issue of Workers Liberty is out now!

eory p debated tactics; Polish and East German socialists share their experiences; and we ha a discussioni around postThatcher British politics.

Comrades were free to follow the series of introductory courses, the East European discussions, or go alon to whatever took their fancy against redundancies throughout the country; the third NALGO Against the Poll Tax activists' conference will take place in autumn.

Such initiatives must be given the support of all anti-poll tax campaigners, and in particular, the National Federation. Links must be built between the community campaigns and the trade unions. Nor should we ignore the Labour Party: we must argue within the community campaigns for people to join the Labour Party, to take up the political battle against Kinnock and Co. and force them to back us against the Tories.

Industrial action linked to the political fight in the Labour Party can only strengthen the mass non-payment campaign; similarly, the strength of the anti-poll tax unions on the estates, and the success of the non-payment campaign, will encourage workers to take action against the cuts and poll tax.

A united strategy harnessing both the anger in the estates and the organised opposition of the working class through trade unions can beat the Tory tax.

The magazine hosts a wealth of material on Eastern Europe, including a survey of the left, an interview with the Polish Socialist Party and an editorial on the events of last year.

In a rave from the grave we reprint an excellent article by Albert Einstein on 'Why you should be a socialist' - a clear, concise and knowledgeable statement from a man renowned for revolutionising our understan ding of the physical world.

Nearer to home, Eric Heffer discusses religion and socialism and Reg Race sug gests a role for the newly formed Labour Party Socialists.

And in the light of the horrifying resurgence of antisemitism across Europe, Sean Matgamna pens a controversial open letter to Tony Cliff of the SWP on anti-semitism and the left. - including the football!

You won't find a more exciting activist school on the British left. We've made special arrangements to avoi a clash with the World Cup next year - so book early for 19911

Scan page 5

SADSPARKASS By Stan Crooke In Sunday 1 July the East drawn as the currency o the German Democratic Republic (GDR) and replaced by the Deutschmark, the currency of West Germany.

Control over monetary policy and the entire banking system in the GDR passed into the hands of the West German Bundesbank.

Contrary to the impression given by much of the left press in Britain and Germany, economists and bankers in West Germany (and elsewhere) are deeply divided in their predictions about the precise consequences the monetary union of East and West Germany.

In recent months, for example, the West German stock markets, hoping for the best, have boomed. But the West German bond market, fearing the worst, has slumped. Some sections of West German capitalism would have preferred a slower and more gradual process of monetary union.

Even if the precise consequences of monetary union are still being argued about, the likely pattern of events in the East German economy in the months ahead is clear enough.

Unemployment will increase sharply as East German concerns go to the wall in the face of West German competition. In June alone (ie. even before monetary union) unemployment rose by 47,000, a jump of 50% on the May total. Even conservative estimates, such as those of the West German Economic Research Institute or the Industrial Bank of Japan, suggest that two million could end up on the dole. Other estimates go as high as four, or even six, million — out of a total workforce of just over eight million.

Prices will rise as well, and have already started to do so. The cost of phone calls has nearly doubled, whilst the costs of the parcel post have more than quadrupled. Most foodstuffs and other basic consumer goods are already as expensive in the GDR as in West Germany. Rents are set to treble from January.

West German bankers hope that the worst of the inflation can be staved off until after December, when the first all-German elections since 1933 are due to be held, for fear that high inflation would cost the ruling Conservative electoral support.

There are no plans for large-scale investment in the GDR. As the tories need subsidies amounting to between 5 and 7,000,000,000 DM per month. The alternative is mass unemployment, necessitating enormous expenditure on unemployment benefits.

Whether West German capital can get away with pushing unemployment up and living standards down depends upon the level of resistance they meet from workers in the GDR, and how much support the latter receive from workers in West Germany and elsewhere.

Until recently the level of working class organisation and combativity in the GDR has remained weak, as the majority of workers looked towards unification with West Germany as the solution to the country's economic problems.

The FDGB (the old state-run "trade union'" umbrella organisation) has lost members and now functions as little more than a financial administrator for the individual "unions" within it. But the leaders of the latter have also failed to lead a campaign in defence of jobs and living standards.

The West German DGB (equivalent of the British TUC) has begun to play an increasing role in the GDR. its message to workers is to stay calm and keep their heads down, in case they frighten away West German investment in their workplaces.

The approach of the DGB mirrors that of West German capitalists. Opel boss Louis Hughes, for example, has warned that whether or not a car factory is built in Eisenach depends upon how much "wage restraint" East German workers show.

Attempts to build an independent trade union movement, such as those of the Initiative for Independent Trade Unions, have hitherto proved unsuccessful and attracted only a small minority of workers.

But as the date of monetary union drew closer and the danger of Job losses became clearer, workers began to move into action to detend their interests. There have already been strikes in the leather and textile industries in particular. And as monetary union came into force, East Berlin refuse workers were out on strike. Pay-rises of up to 30% have been demanded by striking workers.

Hospital workers, workers in the water industry, the police, and, most importantly of all, by engineering workers (there are 1.6 million of them in the GDR, the biggest sector of the workforce) all have pay claims in the pipeline. Queuing for D-marks Employees of the Interflug airline are threatening to strike as of this week over proposed "rationalisation" measures.

Alongside of the strikes there are renewed attempts by members of the Initative for Independent Trade NKFURT Unions and of left-wing groups such as the United Left to rebuild working class organisation in the workplace.

Socialists and workplace activists in this country could play a useful role in supporting such developments by linking up with workplaces in the GDR and providing their workers with information about their own experiences of unionising workplaces, building rank and file groups, and leading disputes over pay and jobs.

IS Wi the ing. odd need thro ou t the I watt ethin he

----- pull-quotes -----

the "primacy of press freedom": "I know the arguments but I think they are very much overstated.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 453

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →